• On ZDNet: Why I Will never buy a Mac
advertisement

Triple play: Portable Media Center devices compared
James Kim
James Kim,
senior editor

In the Windows Media world, these portable media devices can do it all: WMV movies, WMA music, and digital photos with the greatest of ease, thanks to a revolutionary Windows Mobile-based user interface. Portable Media Centers (PMCs) sacrifice certain features found on conventional portable video players such as audio/video recording, an FM tuner, and native compatibility with many popular media formats, but they're also the easiest in the world to use, in part because of its automatic syncing relationship with Windows Media Player (WMP) 10.0. As portable extensions of WMP 10.0, the devices let you watch TV shows recorded on your Media Center PC, listen to on-the-go music subscription services such as Napster or Rhapsody, and view photos and album art while you listen to music. Since the PMC operating system's launch last fall, only three devices have made it to the stores. The first to hit the market, Creative's Zen, is bulky but has excellent battery life and unique customizable preset buttons. The Samsung YH-999 has a stylish and compact form factor but wimpy battery life. Finally, the iRiver PMC-120 (which has a non-PMC brother--good for comparison) represents a nice medium with a less bulky design and decent battery life.

Remove from list Remove from list Remove from list
Product name Zen Portable Media Center
Zen Portable Media Center
Samsung YEPP YH-999 PMC (20GB)
Samsung YEPP YH-999 PMC (20GB)
iRiver PMC-120
iRiver PMC-120




Review date September 1, 2004 April 19, 2005 May 6, 2005




Editors' rating
(Editors' rating explained)
6.7 out of 10 6.7
Good




Buying choices
Prices from online stores:
processing...

Searching for pricing data...


Prices from online stores:
processing...

Searching for pricing data...


Prices from online stores:
processing...

Searching for pricing data...






Review summary Eight months after its announcement, the Creative Zen PMC is finally here. Despite its bulk, the player is solid, but it's the Microsoft Portable Media Center software that deserves most of the praise. If you want the most stylish PMC, look no further than the YH-999; if you need a battery that goes the distance, try elsewhere. Although the PMC-120 is a much better device than its Linux-based brother, the PMP-120, it's not the best Portable Media Center device available.




My Products




User comments Be one of the first to rate this product! Be one of the first to rate this product! Be one of the first to rate this product!
Basic Specs
 
 
 
 
Product name Zen Portable Media Center Samsung YEPP YH-999 PMC (20GB) iRiver PMC-120




Full specifications Full specifications Full specifications Full specifications




Price range   Email me when this product is available
 
  Email me when this product is available
 
  Email me when this product is available