Back to Newsletter Archive page
CNET | Community Help & how-to
CNET
July 23, 2010
3D TVs: True innovation or hype?

Dear CNET members,

Happy Friday! Well folks, I'm back from Maui, Hawaii, and I'm recharged and refreshed! However, I'm still having paradise withdraws from time to time--but who wouldn't after leaving such a beautiful island. For those of you expecting a picture of me in a hula skirt doing a dance, you're out of luck. I dropped the skirt and picked up a fishing pole. Here is a photo of me right off the coast of Maui fighting my catch--a 27-pound Wahoo (Ono) fish! Overall, it was a great vacation. By the way, thanks to those who e-mailed to recommend some local restaurants and places to check out on Maui, they helped tremendously! Now let's move on to the topic of 3D TVs.

Ahh 3D TVs: True innovation or hype? That is the question. Personally, I think it is somewhere in between; however, who can predict where it goes from here on out. With more 3D movies rolling out in at the box office, it does make me wonder if that's the direction in which we are headed for home viewing and it may eventually become the norm as HDTV has become today. (10 years ago, I'm sure many of you thought HDTV was all hype.) Today, 3D TV is still very new and a lot the information on it is still foreign to many of us, but it never hurts to understand more of it. So I'm glad James submitted this question, and I'm very happy to say that in the answers provided by our members. Though some answers are more technical than others, many people did a wonderful job providing their opinions and info that demystifies 3D TVs technology. With these informative answers, I hope that after reading it, James and everyone in the same boats as him will be able to make a better-educated decision if 3D TVs are worth looking into. For more information on 3D TVs, CNET editor David Katzmaier gives also a great run down on his 3D TV FAQ blog. Good luck with your decisions folks and a big thank you to all those who contributed. Have an awesome weekend!

Cheers!
- Lee


Got suggestions? Send me an e-mail: messageboards@cnet.com

Lee Koo
Lee Koo
CNET Community manager
Last week's question
3D TVs: True innovation or hype?
QuestionI'm starting to shop for a new TV and keep seeing a lot about 3D TVs. Should I consider them in my research or is it a waste of time and money? Has anyone seen demos? How's the picture quality? Can the feature be turned on and off? Would I have to wear special glasses just to watch my TV? What about movies? Netflix and Blockbuster don't offer 3D movies, do any movie channels? Trying to separate true innovation from hype. Thanks!

-- Submitted by: James G.

AnswerFeatured member solutions
for last week's question:

 "Best guess- the next parallel to the adoption of HDTV"
-- Submitted by: Scott Gardener

 "Both"
-- Submitted by: timhood

 "3D might be a gimmick, it might not. My guess is it will"
-- Submitted by: minimalist

 "3D TV: Is it worth it?"
-- Submitted by: dgoodrum

 Read all member contributions

 Thanks to all who contributed!

Previous questions and answers
1. Oops, I accidentally unplugged my USB hard drive, now I can't access it.

2. Why are my Windows system restore points disappearing?

3. Buying a new PC, will I regret the integrated graphics card later?

4. Can I create my own Windows 7 recovery disc without all the bloatware?

5. Need help; Windows 7 system freezes after it sits inactive for a while?

 All previous Community newsletters
Community buzz
1. CPU fan constantly running at full speed

2. Malware programs: Can you more than one scan at a time?

3. Sound bar speakers basics

4. Position of cooling fans in my PC

5. E-mail account hijacked and sending spam to address book of friends

6. Bloomberg: Jobs knew in advance of iPhone 4 antenna risks

 More from the CNET forums

Mac nugget
1. Windows 7 on Mac - can it be installed without problems?

2. MacBook Pro performance becoming too slow

 More from the Mac OS forum
Security alerts and updates
1. Security news - July 23, 2010

2. Updates - July 23, 2010

3. Vulnerabilities and fixes - July 23, 2010

4. Mozilla Firefox browser add-on insecure

 More from the security forum
Simple question, simple answer
1. My firewall constantly blocking intrusions. Am I in security danger?

2. Windows 7: Giving programs I trust authority to run

3. Is it normal for CDs to get really hot in the CD-ROM drive?

4. Browser history eraser?

5. How do I tell if I have XP SP3 installed?

6. Considering iPad, can you install software like MS Word, Excel, etc?

7. Windows Vista: How do you open two windows side-by-side?
Check out next week's question:
Security concerns on public Wi-Fi access
Next week's questionI have heard much about how Wi-Fi is not secure. Yet last week a news report lead me to believe that the problem is when people log into Wi-Fi networks where the administrator/company is unknown and unscrupulous as they can see what you are doing and then steal passwords, credit card numbers, and so on. The report inferred that a Wi-Fi network is OK if it is from a trusted source like your known hotel chain, Borders, or Starbucks where the network manager wouldn't do that--we assume anyway. Is this true that the problem comes from is who is running the network or are all Wi-Fi open networks easily open to hackers and theft? A follow up question, would a Wi-Fi network from a trusted source with a simple access password for all (even if given to a hacker) stop all the problems? And are there actual ways that one can securely use public Wi-Fi networks without worries of hackers and possible theft of personal information? Thank you.

-- Submitted by: Jon M.

  Know the answer? Click here to submit it!

Have a tech-related question?
Click here to e-mail us on one of these topics:

· PC troubleshooting
· PC upgrading
· Digital music
· Consumer electronics
· Multimedia
· Internet security
· Digital cameras
· Home audio & video

Need help tech right away? Don't wait for us, post your questions in the CNET forums for all the tech help and how-tos.

Quick pollCommunity quick poll
Weigh in on this week poll topic!
Is a 3D TV something you are considering?

(Please click on button to vote)

 There's nothing to consider, I already have one!
 Definitely, I plan to get one very soon.
 Yes, but waiting for the prices to come down.
 Yes, but not until I see more 3D movie titles and 3D channels available.
 Yes, but not until it becomes standardized.
 Forget 3D TV, I still need a flat panel TV.
 No way, it all hype and will be gone in a few years.

Vote and discuss it here!
Help your fellow members
1. Removing gum from LCD TV screen without damaging it?

2. Plenty of memory, but PC still very slow

3. When doing downloads they stop at 99% and never complete

4. iPod classic without iTunes access--possible or not?

More from the CNET forums
 Windows 7  Windows XP  Digital cameras
 Desktops  Laptops  MP3 players
 Home audio & video  Spyware, viruses, & security  View all forums







2010 CBS Interactive Inc. All rights reserved. CNET, CNET.com and the CNET logo are registered trademarks of CBS Interactive Inc. Used by permission. CNET
 Back to Newsletter Archive page