240Hz LCD HDTVs: Twice as nice?

David Katzmaier
David Katzmaier Senior Editor June 3, 2009
As LCD and plasma vie for popularity and picture-quality bragging rights, one perceived weakness of the LCD camp has provided a reason for TV makers to charge more for step-up models: image blurring. LCD sets with higher refresh rates, like 120Hz and now 240Hz, aim to clean up blurring with newfangled technology.

Each of the LCDs below delivers improved motion resolution, otherwise known as less blurring, compared with other LCDs, and higher refresh rates are the main reason. The Sony and Samsung sets are true 240Hz models, meaning they take the original 60Hz source and repeat each frame four times. The Toshiba and LG, on the other hand, only repeat each frame twice--the same as standard 120Hz models--and then use a scanning backlight to further reduce blurring. The effects of each technology are similar, although the Toshiba and LG did score a bit lower on our motion resolution test. It's worth noting that plasma TVs score as well if not better than any 240Hz model on this test, and certain LED-backlit models also do very well.

The kicker is that, to our eyes at least, image blurring is really difficult to see. In one review, we set up the Toshiba next to the Samsung and disabled the latter's processing--rendering its motion resolution equivalent to an LCD with a 60Hz refresh rate--and watched a fast-paced hockey game. It was nearly impossible to see any difference between the two.

We understand some viewers are more susceptible to image blurring, and for them the 240Hz displays might be worth the $200-$400 premium being charged today. But for most people, 240Hz isn't worth it.

Play video
Play video
Product Toshiba REGZA 47ZV650U Sony Bravia KDL-52XBR9
Price $2,009.10 $3,895.93
CNET editors' rating 3 stars 3 stars
Average user rating 3 stars 3 stars
Release date April 15, 2009 Info unavailable
Bottom line
Although subpar black levels keep it from besting the LCD champs, the Toshiba ZV650U series is still one of the better 240Hz values among TVs with a 240Hz effect.
Sony's high-end KDL-XBR9 series of LCD TV offers a bundle of extras and solid picture quality, but the price will turn off most buyers.
Product type

LCD TV

LCD TV

Diagonal size

47 in

52 in

Technology

TFT active matrix

TFT active matrix

LCD backlight technology

Wide Color Gamut-CCFL

Wide Color Gamut-CCFL

Resolution

1920 x 1080

1920 x 1080

Display format

1080p

1080p

Refresh rate

240Hz

240Hz

Dynamic contrast ratio

100000:1

1000000:1

Image aspect ratio

16:9

16:9

Pixel response time

8 ms

Info unavailable
Widescreen

Widescreen

Widescreen

Widescreen modes

TheaterWide

Conventional 4:3

Wide Zoom

Full

Normal

Stretch

Auto Wide

Conventional 4:3

Zoom

Supported DTV resolutions

1080/24p

1080/60p

720/60p

1080/60i

480/60p

1080/24p

480/60i

TV tuner presence

Yes

Yes

Digital TV tuner

ATSC

QAM

ATSC

QAM

Speaker(s)

2 x Right/left channel speaker - Built-in

2 x Right/left channel speaker - Built-in - 10 Watt

Sound output mode

Stereo

Stereo

Addtional features

Audyssey EQ

Dolby Volume

Invisible Speaker System

Mute button

Invisible Speaker System

Voice Zoom

Auto volume adjustment

Input/Output connections

1 x Digital audio input (optical) - Rear

1 x VGA input (15 pin D-Sub (DB-15)) - Rear

3 x HDMI (19 pin HDMI Type A) - Rear

2 x HD component input (RCA phono x 3) - Rear

3 x Audio line-in (RCA phono x 2) - Rear

1 x Fixed audio output (RCA phono x 2) - Rear

1 x Audio line-in (Mini-phone stereo 3.5 mm) - Rear

1 x Remote control (RCA phono) - Rear

1 x Composite video/audio input (RCA phono x 3) - Side

1 x HDMI (19 pin HDMI Type A) - Side

1 x S-Video input (4 pin mini-DIN) - Rear

1 x USB - Side

1 x Composite video input (RCA phono) - Rear

3 x Audio line-in - Rear

1 x Audio line-in - Side

Audio line-out (RCA phono x 2) - Rear

2 x Component video input (RCA phono x 3) - Rear

1 x Composite video input (RCA phono) - Rear

1 x Composite video input (RCA phono) - Side

1 x Digital audio output (optical) (TOSLINK) - Rear

1 x S-Video input (4 pin mini-DIN) - Rear

1 x VGA input (15 pin HD D-Sub (HD-15)) - Rear

3 x HDMI (19 pin HDMI Type A) - Rear

1 x HDMI (19 pin HDMI Type A) - Side

1 x Network (RJ-45) - Rear

1 x Audio line-in (Mini-phone stereo 3.5 mm) - Rear

1 x USB - Rear

1 x USB 2.0 - Side

Video interface

HDMI

S-Video

Component

Composite

HDMI

S-Video

Component

Composite

HDMI ports qty

4

4

PC interface

VGA (HD-15)

HDMI

VGA (HD-15)

Dimensions (WxDxH)

46.5 in x 3.7 in x 28.9 in - Without stand

48.8 in x 3.3 in x 29.3 in - Without stand

Weight

50.3 lbs

57.1 lbs

Internet streaming services Info unavailable

BRAVIA Internet Video

Comb filter Info unavailable

3D digital

HDCP compatible Info unavailable

Yes

Surround mode Info unavailable

Yes

Sound effects Info unavailable

S-FORCE Front Surround Sound

Total output power Info unavailable

20 Watt

Manufacturer warranty Info unavailable

1 year warranty

Full specifications Full specifications Full specifications
Buying choices Prices from 1 store Prices from 1 store