Puffed-up cell phones: Handsets that didn't quite live up to their hype

Kent German
Kent German Senior Editor January 16, 2007
There's lot of hoopla when it comes to cell phones, and many handset introductions are preceded by months of hype and tons of publicity. Just consider Apple's recent iPhone announcement as tech writers--CNET included--fell over themselves to report the latest tidbits even before Steve Jobs made it official. Unfortunately, anything that gets too much attention before it hits store shelves has great potential to disappoint, as the phones in reality can't live up to our frenzied expectations. We show you four cell phones that suffered this fate. The Motorola Q for Verizon Wireless brought thin to the smart phone, but we weren't wowed by the limitations to its wireless capabilities. Verizon's much-heralded LG VX8500 Chocolate was indeed pretty, but its touch-sensitive controls were too much trouble. The Bang & Olufsen Serene earns points for a unique design, but it's nowhere near worth its $1,000-plus price tag. And speaking of expensive, the Motorola Razr V3i Dolce & Gabbana had plenty of bling, but it was all a bit much for us. Not to mention that we're somewhat over the whole Razr design, as well.
Play video
Play video
Play video
Product Motorola Q (Verizon Wireless) LG Chocolate VX8500 (black, Verizon Wireless) Motorola Razr V3i Dolce & Gabbana (T-Mobile)
Price $72.99 $4.99 $117.64
CNET editors' rating 3 stars 3.5 stars 3 stars
Average user rating 2.5 stars 2.5 stars 3.5 stars
Release date Info unavailable Info unavailable Info unavailable
Bottom line
The Motorola Q lives up to much of the hype by offering good call quality, an excellent multimedia experience, and the essential productivity tools, all wrapped up in a sexy little package.
Though the LG Chocolate is beautifully designed and offers a respectable mix of features and performance, it doesn't quite live up to the hype.
With mixed performance and a standard feature set, the Motorola Razr V3i Dolce & Gabbana ultimately is a design-first phone.
Service Provider

Verizon Wireless

Verizon Wireless

T-Mobile

Cellular technology

CDMA2000 1X

CDMA2000 1X

GSM

Band / mode

CDMA2000 1X 1900/800

CDMA2000 1X 1900/800

GSM 850/900/1800/1900 (Quadband)

Wireless Interface

Bluetooth

Infrared (IrDA)

Bluetooth

Bluetooth

Weight

4.1 oz

3.5 oz

3.5 oz

Full specifications Full specifications Full specifications Full specifications
Buying choices Prices from 1 store Prices from 1 store Prices from 1 store