On MP3.com: Worst MP3 Players of 2007

Search:
Go!


advertisement

MP3 players that shaped 2007

Jasmine France
Jasmine France, Senior Associate Editor
February 08, 2008

As we creep slowly into 2008, I can't seem to shake the sinking feeling that this year isn't going to have much to offer in the realm of MP3 players. Truly, it's going to be hard to follow 2007. The year ushered in a growing selection of devices with wireless capabilities, touch screens, and high capacity flash memory at increasingly lower prices--not to mention the slow death of hard drive-based portable media players. In fact, many of my top selections from the past year comprise at least one of these features, along with many other desirable traits. True, they are not all necessarily the highest scorers of the year, but each one gave 2007 a little piece of its MP3 player identity.

The year Microsoft and Sony stepped-up their game. Let's face it: the first-generation Zune was released amid plentiful skepticism and criticism and--although it had plenty of redeeming qualities--the Zune didn't really come into its own until the second iteration. The design was slimmed down, the Wi-Fi features were refined and expanded, and the already excellent interface got a refresh. Plus, the player sounds great. While we're on the subject of stellar audio quality, let's talk Sony. The electronics giant made a lot of people really pleased when it finally gave up on its horrific SonicStage software, and moved its new Walkman's to the more user-friendly MTP platform. Sony added support for both AAC and WMA, while retaining its reputation for excellent battery life and sound. As a result, the NWZ-A818 is one of the best players I've ever laid hands on (I even bought one for my own brother). Other players of note: the fabulously green flash Zune, and the FM radio-sporting Sony NWZ-S615.

The year touch screens and the Web hit mainstream PMPs. Oh, the touch screen. You either love it, or you hate it (or maybe you're indifferent). Regardless of your feelings on the matter, there was no stopping this new interface's infestation in the portable media player market. No doubt, it has some benefits, one of them being increased control functionality on relatively compact devices. This has helped manufacturers include Web applications on MP3 players, such as the iPod Touch, and the Archos 605 WiFi. Both players utilize their wireless capabilities for handy, on-demand video functionality. There's nothing like a promise of instant gratification to get more consumers snatching up devices. Other players of note: the Bluetooth-friendly Samsung P2, and the Cowon D2, which doesn't offer wireless features but is awesome just the same.

The year flash memory took over the world. The slow extermination of the hard drive in MP3 players has been met with mixed feelings. On the one hand, flash memory is more stable, consumes less power, and just seems to get cheaper and cheaper each day. On the other hand, we're a ways off from file-hoarding 120GB capacities in solid state form. However, manufacturers have made their choice and its flash, so you might as well start getting used to it. On the plus side, you can take solace in the fact that 2007 saw the introduction of an MP3 player--the Creative Zen, to be exact--with 32GB of internal flash memory as well as an SD card expansion slot. Also, things got really cheap over the last year, with SanDisk pushing out a great-sounding, handily-designed 2GB Sansa Clip for less than $50. Other players of note: pretty much all of them.


  remove this product remove this product remove this product remove this product remove this product remove this product
Product name Zune (second generation, 80GB, black)
Zune (second generation, 80GB, black)  
Sony NWZ-A818 (8GB, black)
Sony NWZ-A818 (8GB, black)  
Apple iPod Touch (16GB)
Apple iPod Touch (16GB)  
Archos 605 WiFi (30GB)
Archos 605 WiFi (30GB)  
SanDisk Sansa Clip (2GB, candy apple red)
SanDisk Sansa Clip (2GB, candy apple red)  
Creative Zen (32GB)
Creative Zen (32GB)  







Review date November 12, 2007   September 25, 2007   September 17, 2007   August 30, 2007   October 08, 2007   September 14, 2007  







CNET editors' rating 8.3 out of 10 8.3
Excellent
8.0 out of 10 8.0
Excellent
8.7 out of 10 8.7
Excellent
8.7 out of 10 8.7
Excellent
7.5 out of 10 7.5
Very good
8.3 out of 10 8.3
Excellent







Users' rating 7.7 out of 10 7.7
Very good
8.5 out of 10 8.5
Excellent
7.7 out of 10 7.7
Very good
6.6 out of 10 6.6
Good
8.8 out of 10 8.8
Excellent
9.2 out of 10 9.2
Spectacular







Buying choices
Prices from online stores:
processing...

Searching for pricing data...


 
Prices from online stores:
processing...

Searching for pricing data...


 
Prices from online stores:
processing...

Searching for pricing data...


 
Prices from online stores:
processing...

Searching for pricing data...


 
Prices from online stores:
processing...

Searching for pricing data...


 
Prices from online stores:
processing...

Searching for pricing data...


 







Local shopping No local stores found No local stores found No local stores found No local stores found No local stores found No local stores found







Product videos Watch video Watch video Watch video Watch video Watch video Watch video







Review summary The Zune has blossomed from an ugly duckling into a worthy iPod alternative. The Sony NWZ-A810 offers a fantastic display, a sleek design and interface, and a stellar battery life--plus, it's one of the few MP3 players that sound great right out of the box. Users looking for the whole package (sans radio) will be pleased. The iPod Touch is a beautiful product, inside and out, but prepare yourself for sticker shock. The Archos 605 WiFi portable video player is one of the best mobile distractions money can buy. The SanDisk Sansa Clip is an incredible value that's set to edge out the competition with a user-friendly interface, gym-worthy design, and great sound quality. We're hard-pressed to find anything not to like about the Creative Zen. It's a great option for anyone looking for a great-sounding, pocketable MP3 player with an excellent, video-capable screen and plenty of extra features.







Product series   See all products in this series See all products in this series See all products in this series See all products in this series See all products in this series







My Products
Basic Specs
Battery technology Lithium ion Lithium ion Lithium ion Lithium polymer Info unavailable Lithium ion







Mfr estimated battery life 20 hour(s) 33 hour(s) 22 hour(s) Info unavailable Info unavailable Info unavailable







Width 2.4 in 1.7 in 2.4 in 4.8 in Info unavailable 3.3 in







Depth 0.5 in 0.4 in 0.3 in 0.6 in Info unavailable 0.4 in







Height 4.3 in 3.5 in 4.3 in 3.2 in Info unavailable 2.2 in







Weight 4.5 oz 1.9 oz 4.2 oz 6.7 oz Info unavailable 2.3 oz







Color Black Black Info unavailable Info unavailable Red Black







PC interface(s) supported Info unavailable Hi-Speed USB Info unavailable Info unavailable Hi-Speed USB Hi-Speed USB







Flash memory installed Info unavailable 8 GB Info unavailable Info unavailable 2 GB 32 GB







Flash memory form factor Info unavailable Integrated Info unavailable Info unavailable Integrated Integrated







Dimensions (WxDxH) Info unavailable 1.7 in x 0.4 in x 3.5 in Info unavailable Info unavailable Info unavailable 3.3 in x 0.4 in x 2.2 in







Resolution Info unavailable 240 x 320 Info unavailable Info unavailable Info unavailable 320 x 240







Software type Info unavailable Drivers & Utilities , Microsoft Windows Media Player 11 Info unavailable Info unavailable Drivers & Utilities Drivers & Utilities , Creative Media Explorer , Creative ZENcast Organizer







Product type Info unavailable Digital player Info unavailable Info unavailable Digital player / radio Digital player / radio







Sound output mode Info unavailable Stereo Info unavailable Info unavailable Stereo Stereo







Sound effects Info unavailable Clear Bass Info unavailable Info unavailable Info unavailable Info unavailable







Equalizer factory presets Info unavailable Pop , Jazz , Heavy , Custom , Unique Info unavailable Info unavailable Info unavailable Pop , Jazz , Rock , Disco , Vocal , NewAge , Classic , Acoustical







Amplifier response bandwidth Info unavailable 20 - 20000 Hz Info unavailable Info unavailable Info unavailable Info unavailable







Amplifier total output power Info unavailable 10 mW Info unavailable Info unavailable Info unavailable Info unavailable







Digital player (recorder) Info unavailable AAC , MP3 , PCM , WMA , Protected WMA (DRM 10) Info unavailable Info unavailable MP3 , WMA , Audible , Protected WMA (DRM) AAC , MP3 , WAV , WMA , ADPCM , Audible







Device type Info unavailable Info unavailable Portable media center Digital AV player Info unavailable Info unavailable







Key multimedia features Info unavailable Info unavailable Digital photo viewer , Digital video player , Digital audio player Digital audio player , Digital photo viewer , Digital video player , External HDD function Info unavailable Info unavailable







Display type Info unavailable Info unavailable 3.5 in TFT 4.3 in - Color Info unavailable Info unavailable







Supported still images formats Info unavailable Info unavailable JPEG , BMP , GIF , TIFF , PSD , PNG BMP , PNG , JPEG Info unavailable Info unavailable







Supported audio formats Info unavailable Info unavailable AAC , Protected AAC , MP3 , MP3 VBR , Audible 2 , Audible 3 , Audible 4 , Apple Lossless , WAV , AIFF MP3 , PCM , WAV , WMA , ADPCM , Protected WMA (DRM) Info unavailable Info unavailable







Video playback formats Info unavailable Info unavailable MPEG-4 WMV , MPEG-4 , Protected WMV (DRM) Info unavailable Info unavailable







PC interfaces Info unavailable Info unavailable USB 2.0 Hi-Speed USB , IEEE 802.11b , IEEE 802.11g Info unavailable Info unavailable







Included accessories Info unavailable Info unavailable Earphone , USB cable , Docking adapter , Polishing cloth , Stand USB cable , Carrying pouch , Stereo headphones Info unavailable Info unavailable







Hard drive Info unavailable Info unavailable Info unavailable 30 GB Info unavailable Info unavailable







Digital player signal-to-noise ratio Info unavailable Info unavailable Info unavailable Info unavailable Info unavailable 97 dB







Manufacturer warranty Info unavailable Info unavailable Info unavailable Info unavailable Info unavailable 1 year warranty







Product name Zune (second generation, 80GB, black)   Sony NWZ-A818 (8GB, black)   Apple iPod Touch (16GB)   Archos 605 WiFi (30GB)   SanDisk Sansa Clip (2GB, candy apple red)   Creative Zen (32GB)  







Full specifications Full Specifications Full Specifications Full Specifications Full Specifications Full Specifications Full Specifications







Price range Check latest prices
$230-260
from 8 stores
Check latest prices
$162-200
from 3 stores
Check latest prices
$320-430
from 16 stores
Check latest prices
$200-300
from 15 stores
Check latest prices
$60-100
from 2 stores
Check latest prices
$270-310
from 8 stores