advertisement

Audiophile MP3 players

Donald Bell Donald Bell, Senior Editor June 19, 2008

Before I dive into what is sure to be a controversial product roundup, let me qualify what I mean by "audiophile MP3 players" (my apologies in advance to Steve Guttenberg). The following MP3 players are not necessarily the best sounding MP3 players when judged by subjective listening tests. Instead, this list contains players that have performed remarkably during CNET Labs bench tests, where they are evaluated on the accuracy of their sound reproduction.

So, in recognition of those few golden-eared purists who are willing sink low enough to use an MP3 player but refuse to accept anything but the truest sounding device available, here are the six MP3 players with the highest marks from CNET Labs' Eric Franklin. Using an Audio Precision ATS-2 Audio Analyzer, Eric has measured each of these MP3 players for frequency response deviation, total harmonic distortion and noise (THD+N), signal to noise ratio (SNR), maximum power output, and crosstalk.

The player with the best overall score is the Creative Zen, which scored a frequency response deviation average under 1.47 dB, a -82.2 dB THD+N average, and a -83.6 dBr SNR average. The rest of the players are listed here in descending order of their overall score. Perhaps the biggest surprise on this list is the Insignia Pilot, which took the best score for signal to noise, yet faired only average in total harmonic distortion.

For a more in-depth look at the test scores of each of these MP3 players, head over to the MP3 Insider blog.

More Resources
MP3 players with great EQ,
MP3 Insider blog and podcast,
Long-lasting MP3 players,
Best non-iPod MP3 players for Mac
Product name
Creative Zen (16GB)
Play CNET Video
Close

Creative Zen (16GB)

Creative Zen Stone Plus (2GB, black)
Play CNET Video
Close

Creative Zen Stone Plus (2GB, black)

Apple iPod Classic (80GB, silver)
Play CNET Video
Close

Apple iPod Classic (80GB, silver)

SanDisk Sansa Clip (2GB, candy apple red)
Play CNET Video
Close

SanDisk Sansa Clip (2GB, candy apple red)

Sony Walkman NWZ-S718F (8GB, black)
Play CNET Video
Close

Sony Walkman NWZ-S718F (8GB, black)

CNET Editors' choice
Price $159.00 to $319.20 $51.27 to $61.99 $207.95 to $249.99 Check Prices $39.99 to $64.99 $179.99 to $199.95
CNET editors' rating
Average user rating
Review date September 14, 2007 July 26, 2007 September 10, 2007 December 19, 2007 October 08, 2007 April 11, 2008
The Bottom Line We're hard-pressed to find anything not to like about the Creative Zen. It's a great option for anyone looking for a great-sounding, pocketable MP3 player with an excellent, video-capable screen and plenty of extra features. For those who want a supersmall and cute MP3 player that offers more than just simple music playback, the Creative Zen Stone Plus fits the bill nicely. The iPod Classic is a refinement of the formula that put the iPod on the map. Few can match its combination of storage capacity, battery life, and advanced user interface. The Insignia Pilot won't please audio purists, but it's a great option for feature hounds who appreciate a good value--and the ability to listen to music sans wires. The SanDisk Sansa Clip is an incredible value that's set to edge out the competition with a user-friendly interface, gym-worthy design, and great sound quality. The sum of the NWZ-S710F's audio enhancement and noise-canceling features adds up to one of the most pleasant and private music experiences you can have for less than $200.
Similar Products Compare more products Compare more products Compare more products Compare more products Compare more products Compare more products
Features
Battery technology Lithium ion
Lithium polymer
Lithium ion
Lithium ion
Info unavailable Info unavailable
Display type Info unavailable Info unavailable LCD 2.5 in
Info unavailable Info unavailable Info unavailable
Digital player (recorder) WMA
WAV
ADPCM
Audible
MP3
AAC
WMA
WAV
ADPCM
Protected WMA (DRM 9)
Audible
MP3
Info unavailable WMA
WAV
Ogg Vorbis
Protected WMA (DRM 10)
WMAPro
Audible
MP3
WMA
Protected WMA (DRM)
Audible
MP3
WMA
Protected WMA (DRM)
PCM
MP3
AAC
Digital Player total harmonic distortion Info unavailable 0.1 %
Info unavailable Info unavailable Info unavailable Info unavailable
Software type Creative ZENcast Organizer
Creative Media Explorer
Drivers & Utilities
Drivers & Utilities
Info unavailable Info unavailable Drivers & Utilities
Drivers & Utilities
Device type Info unavailable Info unavailable Portable media center
Info unavailable Info unavailable Info unavailable
Dimensions (WxDxH) 3.3 in x 0.4 in x 2.2 in
2.2 in x 0.5 in x 1.4 in
Info unavailable 3.3 in x 0.4 in x 1.6 in
Info unavailable Info unavailable
Color Black
Black
Silver
Info unavailable Red
Black
Mfr estimated battery life Info unavailable 9.5 hour(s)
30 hour(s)
25 hour(s)
Info unavailable