In round 2, we focus on the players' size and design, as well as any additional pimp factor that makes the user feel extra cool. Is it ever possible to out-sexy Apple's design? Has the Zune outgrown its awkward phase?
| Player | Jasmine | Donald | Brian | Total |
|
iPod Classic (2G) |
4 Sexy is a state of mind, and there's no denying this iPod thinks it's sexy, even if it is the hefty one in the family. I love the brushed metal look. Hawt. |
3 The Classic is the classiest high-capacity MP3 player you can buy, but it's not exactly sexy. The design is iconic, but it also screams "old school." |
4 Fewer buttons is always better, and the metal finish is hot. The screen looks great, but it's kind of wimpy in size. |
3.7 |
|
Zune 120 (3G) |
3 Hmm. Not unsexy, per se. More utilitarian, which has its own appeal. Nothing like that big, beautiful screen, though. It blows the iPod out of the water for videos. |
3 The Zune's advanced features and optional case etchings definitely angle at a younger audience, but its unapologetically chunky design still echoes the brick aesthetic of the original model. |
4 The screen is almost twice the size of the iPod and that's important to me. Claims of it being "ugly" are exaggerated. |
3.3 |