ie8 fix
Ask the Editors:

Should you buy a wide-screen TV?

Ask the editorsAsk the Editors
Most recent questions
Should you buy a wide-screen TV?
February 11, 2005
Q
My wife and I are going to buy a new big-screen TV (about 50 to 52 inches), probably a rear-projection set (but maybe a DLP or LCD), and we plan on spending from $1,400 to $2,400. We watch just regular TV from DirecTV 99 percent of the time, we don't want any bars on the sides, and we don't want the stretched look. We will not be paying for HD programming real soon but do not want our new expensive TV to become obsolete. Should we just buy a 4:3 rear-projection set, or do we need to go with a wide screen?
Submitted by:
Scott R.,
via e-mail
David Katzmaier
David Katzmaier
Senior editor
You're truly in a pickle, Scott. The problem is, while HDTV manufacturers are anxious to ditch 4:3 sets in favor of wide-screen, content providers continue to deliver most of their shows in 4:3. Yes, there is a lot more wide-screen HDTV programming available now than there was last year, and there should be even more next year, but it's still almost always sports, prime-time dramas, and special events. In two or three years, however, you'll probably find that your HD options are extensive and affordable enough to warrant going wide, at which point, your not-too-old 4:3 TV will be effectively obsolete. If you can stomach that thought, go ahead and get a 4:3 HDTV (no DLP or LCD sets, though--they're all wide-screen). If not, you'll have to buck up, get a wide-screen, and watch with bars or stretching.





Rate this answer
 How useful was this
 tip for you?

 Very
 Somewhat
 Not at all






David Katzmaier, a TV reviewer with five years' experience, has color bars and a resolution chart tattooed inside either eyelid.