ie8 fix
Ask the Editors:

Can DVD/HDD recorders pause live TV?

Ask the editorsAsk the Editors
Most recent questions
Can DVD/HDD recorders pause live TV?
September 2, 2005

Q
I'm in the market for a DVR/DVD-recorder combo, and I've looked at the Humax and Toshiba TiVo models, but I'm turned off by the TiVo subscription fees. The Pioneer DVR-533H-S looks very attractive, but I was curious about a section of the review that said it couldn't pause live TV. Could you explain the difference between how DVD recorders and DVRs like TiVo handle live TV?
Submitted by:
Tom,
CNET reader e-mail
David Katzmaier
David Katzmaier
Senior editor
Tom, the difference is basically one of user interface. With a few DVD/hard disk recorders--such as the TiVo-based Humax DRT800, as well as at least one non-TiVo deck, Philips's HDRW720--any time you're watching TV via the device, you can just press Pause and Rewind, or Fast-forward afterward, to control "live" TV. With DVD recorders such as the Pioneer and the Panasonic DMR-EH50, you must manually press Record first or already be watching a timer recording. Then you can go into a menu or press a button (Play on those two decks) to go into Chase Playback mode, which is basically the same thing, allowing you to pause, rewind, and fast-forward back to real-time. As someone used to DVRs, I prefer TiVo's "always-on" method, but perhaps Pioneer wanted their recorders to behave more like a VCR and figured always-on recording would confuse users. Also, with TiVo/Humax/Philips, the HDD is always spinning and can cause wear and tear, although in my experience, DVR hard drives last a very long time.



Rate this answer
 How useful was this
 tip for you?

 Very
 Somewhat
 Not at all






David Katzmaier, a TV reviewer with five years' experience, has color bars and a resolution chart tattooed inside either eyelid.