Version: 2008
  • On BNET: Vote: How will Apple blow it?
advertisement
Ask the Editors: Surprise! You killed your USB drive
Send feedback Send feedback   E-mail to a friend E-mail to a friend
Ask the editorsAsk the Editors
Most recent questions
How do I edit video descriptions in iTunes?
How to export song list from iTunes?
Are glass screens better for MP3 players?
An MP3 player for mom
Taking an iPod between Mac and PC
When will a new iPod come out?
Apple iTunes deal with EMI
Daylight-saving time and smart phones?
Computers with Blu-ray or HD-DVD drives?
Make mine a Mac?
Camera's best for close-ups and telephoto shots
See all questions
Surprise! You killed your USB drive
February 23, 2006
Q
I was told that if I remove a USB pen drive from a PC without first using the Safely Remove Hardware option on the Windows Taskbar, the flash memory could be damaged. Is it true?
Submitted by:
ferrerdoug
via e-mail
Justin Jaffe
Justin Jaffe
Senior editor
Yes, it is true that you can damage your flash memory drive with a "surprise removal of hardware," as Microsoft calls it. It's better to be safe than sorry and click through the Safely Remove Hardware applet to stop the device before removing it.

Rate this answer
 How useful was this
 tip for you?
 Very
 Somewhat
 Not at all

However, most times, you won't experience any difficulty if you just yank your USB drive from the PC. The problems associated with surprise removal are more of an issue with older versions of Windows than with the more recent XP. That said, I had an old USB drive that I connected to and removed from my laptop (running XP) hundreds of times without incident--and without bothering with the Safely Remove Hardware routine. Then one day, I pulled it out, and that was it--dead. So now I (usually) use the Safely Remove Hardware app. Learned my lesson.

Check out this page on Microsoft's site for more information about XP and surprise removal.





MORE RESOURCES 
Thumbdrive wars: USB vs. FireWire flash drives
Storage in a flash: USB flash drives

 Get more from your USB flash drive
More wires, more fire: FireWire 800


Justin Jaffe is CNET's resident laptop expert. His writings, reviews, and recommendations have also appeared in Business Week, Wired, and the San Francisco Chronicle.


 
Reviews & advice
Site map
Editorial policies
Meet the editors
How we test
Forums
Internet speed test
Popular topics
Apple iPhone
Apple iPod
Cell phones
Dell
GPS
LCD TV
CNET sites
CNET Site map
CNET TV
Downloads
News
Reviews
Shopper.com
More information
Newsletters
CNET Mobile
Customer Help Center
RSS
CNET Widgets
About CNET
sponsored