Version: 2008
  • On The Insider: Britney's Bikini-Clad Top 10
advertisement
On Call: Answers for your cell phone questions.
Can you trust your carrier?
By Kent German 
April 19, 2005

Kent German, CNET's cell phone guru, wants to answer your questions about cell phones, services, and accessories. Send him a question!

Roam if you want to

Samsung SCH-A790
Samsung SCH-A790
Q: I use Verizon cell service, and I need to know what to do in order to travel internationally and be able to send and receive calls. Verizon does not have adequate responses to my questions. Can you help?
--rstelth

A: Like Sprint PCS, Verizon uses a technology called CDMA. While CDMA has extensive coverage in the United States, it's used in only a few other countries. I usually tell world travelers to go with a GSM carrier such as T-Mobile or Cingular because GSM is the dominant global technology, but you're not totally out of luck.

Until recently, your only real option with Verizon was to rent a GSM phone. Fortunately, though, you now have a better--albeit still limited--option. The Samsung SCH-A790 is one of very few cell phones to operate on both a GSM and CDMA network (Sprint offers a similar phone, the IP-A790). Stateside calls operate on Verizon's CDMA network and count toward your normal calling plan, while calls made overseas switch to GSM using the included SIM card. Verizon promises coverage in more than 100 countries, but keep in mind that such intercontinental chatting comes at a price. Not only will you pay per-minute charges of $1.29 to $2.49, you're also subject to long-distance charges. That means an additional 65 cents per minute for most countries, but it can range up to an astronomical $9.17 (yes, per minute) if you ever visit Gabon, Africa.

Data drama

Nokia 6310i
Nokia 6310i
Q: I use a Nokia 6310i that I purchased maybe four years ago. I really like the phone, but my question relates to the computer services. I have Cingular, but when I tried to sign up with the Cingular data service plan (approximately $10 per month), the company told me because I did not purchase my phone from a Cingular "dealer," the phone was not able to support the service. The employees' answer to why this is the case was not anything I understood, so after going 'round and 'round with the Cingular serviceperson, I gave up. Is this a lost cause?
--Holly

A: Like all businesses, cell phone carriers like to make money. They want you to buy a phone directly from them, rather than purchasing an unlocked phone from a third-party source; obviously, this earns them an extra buck. Handsets that you buy, say, at a mobile store that's not operated by Cingular may not come with the necessary settings that are unique to your carrier to activate data service. So it's not that your phone isn't applicable with data services--in fact, it supports text and multimedia messaging, e-mail, Web browsing, and PC syncing--but it's probably that it doesn't have the correct information for the carrier's IP address and access point. I would try searching the Web or using this tool on Nokia's site to see if you can get the appropriate settings; you can then send them as a text message to your phone, or you can enter them yourself in the phone's Settings menu.

Bluetooth or "halftooth"?
Q: I bought a Motorola V710 (the worse phone out there). Verizon currently is the subject of a lawsuit over this phone because of its disabled Bluetooth. But now, Verizon has decided to support the Motorola E815, which promises a lot of goodies. Where can I find more about that phone? And what will Verizon do for those of us who bought the V710? Will the E815 be free for us?
--Joao

Do you have Bluetooth or "halftooth"? TalkBack to me below.
A: Let me start with a little background. As Verizon's first Bluetooth phone, the V710 excited even us. But we soon got a nasty surprise when we discovered that Verizon had configured the V710's Bluetooth so that it could be used only to connect to a wireless headset and not for data transfer. Some customers responded with a class action suit.

Despite the controversy, I bet that Verizon won't offer the Motorola E815 as compensation if it loses the lawsuit (which is unlikely, anyway). Though the E815 looks like a stylish mobile that's packed with features, it would be extremely frustrating if the promised Bluetooth is limited again. Verizon and Sprint have done this a few times now, and it's become my pet peeve. Since T-Mobile and Cingular offer unlimited Bluetooth, it baffles me why the others can't do the same. Though Verizon claims it has other reasons for doing so, the company's intentions seem clear: if you can't send files through Bluetooth, you're forced to use and pay for its data-transfer services. That's just unacceptable.


On hold...

...Mobile America 
I get a lot of questions asking why the United States is so far behind Europe and Asia in the quality of its phones. A reader who recently visited Japan said, "The new phones they have are unbelievable! Why is the States so far behind on cell phone technology?"

A proper answer to this question could fill a book, but I'm going to give it a shot in what little space I have by addressing a couple of points. The first is that the United States uses two cellular standards (CDMA and GSM), while Europe and most of the world use only GSM. When you have only one standard in a given area such as Europe, it creates several advantages. For example, a single unifying network makes it possible to send multimedia messages to any phone regardless of carrier; it's also easier for developers to integrate features such as Bluetooth when they don't have to create differing versions. Also, because there were government deadlines in Europe for implementing 3G networks, carriers had more incentive and the necessary spectrum to roll them out.

Another issue is that in the States, carriers are king. They control the market and can make or break a phone--even a really cool one--by deciding whether to pick it up. And don't forget that carriers want to use features such as flashy multimedia to their advantage. If they can't figure out how to make money off of them, those goodies might never see the light of an American day. In fact, Verizon and Sprint are rumored to have dropped Motorola's iTunes phone for this very reason. But like I said, this question is a complex one, and there is much more to a complete answer.

More commentary
Buzz Report
Molly Wood
Taking a bite out of hype.
Security Watch
Robert Vamosi
Don't get burned by viruses and hackers.
Fully Equipped
David Carnoy
The electronics you lust for.
On Call
Kent German
Solutions for your wireless woes.
Driving It
Wayne Cunningham
What's hot and what's not in car tech.

advertisement