On TechRepublic: Breaking the law with your computer

Search:
Go!




Click Here
On Call: Answers for your cell phone questions.
Put down the phone and drive
By Kent German 
July 12, 2005

Kent German, CNET's cell phone guru, wants to answer your questions about cell phones, services, and accessories. Send him a question!

Haunted phone?

Nokia 6800
Nokia 6800
Q: I have a Nokia 6800 cell phone with Cingular. I plug it in at night in the bedroom, and periodically it will drive the TV crazy, even if the TV is off. I can not use it at work because it affects the clarity of the phone lines. Is it the phone? Other people I talk to about it say their phones don't cause this. Also, the same phone won't ring but will give me a missed call or a message instead. Is it haunted or what?
--Larry

A: Many cell phones can cause interference with other gadgets. But in my experience, it is the cell phone that suffers most. I can get static during a call when I'm close to my television, my microwave, or my computer. Many times, there's not a lot you can do, save trying a different phone, as it can just be the nature of two electronic devices trying to exist in the same space. We test our phones for interference, and if we encounter anything, we try and include it in the review.

That said, your predicament is peculiar. I've never seen cell phones cause interference in a TV that is turned off. I'm not exactly sure what is happening, but I don't think there's anything particular about the Nokia 6800 that would cause this to happen. If there's a metal surface around your charging place, your TV that could be a factor as metal tends to disrupt cell signals. As for your other question, calls that go straight to voicemail can happen when you're in an area with spotty reception. If these problems continue, I would contact Cingular and ask about exchanging the phone.

Without SIM
Q: What can I do to replace a broken AT&T phone without having to change carriers? My plan with the former AT&T cannot be beaten by any plan available today for the money. I've read I could buy an unlocked phone, but my phone never had a SIM card. Am I out of luck?
--Janice

A: SIM cards may be commonplace now, but just a few years ago, most phones didn't have them at all. I remember when I bought my first cell phone, I purchased the ubiquitous Nokia 5160 (the GSM version of the Nokia 5185i) with AT&T. Like your mobile, the 5160 did not have a SIM card.

Nokia 5185i
Nokia 5185i

Unfortunately, your options are limited. Only GSM cell phones with SIM cards can be unlocked so that you can easily change the phone number. If you bought another SIM-less phone, you'd have to ask Cingular (who now owns your AT&T contract) to activate the new mobile with your current digits. The carrier might be willing to do so without a new contract, but it has no incentive to keep you on an old AT&T plan. And even if it does so, you aren't entitled to the rebates that come with a new contract, and you'll wind up paying full price for the new handset. Alternatively, if you bought a new unlocked phone that requires a SIM, you'd have to ask Cingular for a card. No, it's not particularly fair, but it's what I see happening.

Bluetooth beware?
Q: Much has been said about cell phone radiation. What about Bluetooth radiation? I use my Bluetooth headset sometimes and would like to know how safe it is.
--Prasanna

A: As we report in our quick guide to Bluetooth, Bluetooth signals work via a short-range radio frequency. That frequency operates at a much lower power level than your phone, so the threat from radiation is insignificant. Also like a cell phone, Bluetooth devices disperse their signals in random directions, rather than in a straight beam. If you're really worried about radiation, keep in mind that when using a headset, your phone will probably be resting away from your body. Since your handset will have a much higher SAR rating than the headset, you'll probably feel better with this arrangement.

Signal boosters

Have you used a cell phone signal booster?
Q: Are there technologies or products that can be used in areas of weak cell phone signals to improve reception?
--Thomas

A: There are a number of signal boosters available, but we're skeptical about their effectiveness. I can't recommend any at the moment, as we have not reviewed them, but we will begin evaluating them soon. Stay tuned for further details.

On hold...

Driving to distraction 
A new law in Chicago goes into effect this week that will require the use of a hands-free device if you're talking on a cell phone while driving. By passing the legislation, Chicago joins a group of other states and municipalities that have limited mobile use while behind the wheel. While regulations in some states are specifically for teens--not that a 16-year-old needs a car and a phone in the first place--the Chicago law will apply to all drivers. In fact, a Chicago friend called me just the other day to commemorate his last in-car call. Though some hail these new rules, I'm a bit skeptical.

Don't get me wrong; I think the laws are well intentioned. I'm practically run down on the street each day by some chatty Cathy or Carl who is more concerned with their all-important call than what is on the road in front of them. Yet I question the effectiveness of these laws. First off, will they do any good? If we can't get Americans to stop buying gas guzzlers or driving distances of less than a block, how are we going to stop ourselves from jabbering on the road? And just how are these laws going to be enforced? It seems as if perpetrators will be caught only if they're stopped by the police for doing something else. And there's another thing. As a Chicago TV station and the San Francisco Chronicle report, some have questioned whether using a headset or an in-car Bluetooth system really makes a difference. Sure, both your hands may be on the wheel when using them--though I doubt that's a certainty--but if you're more concerned with dinner plans, a spat with a friend, or some brouhaha at work, your focus on your driving will suffer regardless; it's all about your concentration. So as I see it, treat phone calls in the cars like you would in a restaurant. If the call isn't pressing, wait until you're done or take it outside.

More commentary
Buzz Report
Molly Wood
Taking a bite out of hype.
Security Watch
Robert Vamosi
Don't get burned by viruses and hackers.
Fully Equipped
David Carnoy
The electronics you lust for.
On Call
Kent German
Solutions for your wireless woes.
Driving It
Wayne Cunningham
What's hot and what's not in car tech.


TalkBack
45 messages

Article discussion: On Call: Put down the phone and drive


Latest post:

"oh bull"
by okimguilty2 (See profile) - December 22, 2005 9:37 AM PST
in New York, hillary clinton 1st made this claim.. in fact not long ago she said she will spend the rest of her life, stopping cell phones, hands free or not being used while driv... (Read more).
Sort by: Title |
Date
| Most helpful

What happened from when...

Years ago to make a phone call you found a pay phone..then pagers came out and p... (Read more)
by ppono (See profile) - August 4, 2005 7:17 AM PDT

Just what we need...more government!

We already have more idiotic laws just about driving than we had years ago. We ... (Read more)
by 65Z01 (See profile) - August 3, 2005 4:36 AM PDT

signal boosters

Yes I have used them and AM using one. It all happened when they stopped making ... (Read more)
by OntheCoast (See profile) - July 20, 2005 10:32 AM PDT

HANG UP AND DRIVE!

Hands free - I agree with the opinion that this will (and does) leave more hands... (Read more)
by tpatridge (See profile) - July 17, 2005 7:53 AM PDT

It doesn't matter whether the call can wait

You say, "If the call isn't pressing, wait until you're done or take it outside.... (Read more)
by rpvoss (See profile) - July 14, 2005 12:05 PM PDT

Business

I feel some of you are ignorant to the important use of cell phones...conducting... (Read more)
by Ominx (See profile) - July 14, 2005 8:45 AM PDT

No Tele while in Trans!

I'm afraid that while I'm one of the last people who wants/needs more government... (Read more)
by mhein (See profile) - July 13, 2005 12:03 PM PDT

cell phones and driving

Driving is a full time job, not something to do while you're talking on the phon... (Read more)
by docarter (See profile) - July 13, 2005 11:54 AM PDT

Phones and driving

The main reason phones in cars are bad is very simple-- an example -- if you are... (Read more)
by M2150 (See profile) - July 13, 2005 10:00 AM PDT


© 2008 CNET Networks, Inc., a CBS Company. All rights reserved. | Privacy Policy | Terms of Use