• On TV.com: THE GIRLS NEXT DOOR photos
Click Here
advertisement
On Call: Answers for your cell phone questions.
Cell security, and your questions answered
By Kent German 
November 1, 2005

Kent German, CNET's cell phone guru, wants to answer your questions about cell phones, services, and accessories. Send him a question!

Using Cingular service

Sony Ericsson S700i
Sony Ericsson S700i
Q: I have family in South America, and they mentioned that they could buy an unlocked Sony Ericsson S700i and send it with a cousin who's traveling to the United States. Will that phone work with my current Cingular Wireless account?
--Alex

A: Since the Sony Ericsson S700i uses GSM, it will work with Cingular. Yet there's one point you need to consider. The S700i operates on the GSM 900/1800/1900 bands, while Cingular primarily uses the GSM 850 band in the United States; the 900 and 1800 bands are used in Europe. Although Cingular also has some coverage in the 1900 band that it gained from the AT&T Wireless merger, Cingular's emphasis is on the 850 band. That means your coverage may be spotty in some places.

For the best Cingular coverage, I would get a phone that uses the GSM 850 band. You might consider the Sony Ericsson S710a. Like the S700i, the S710 operates on the 850/1800/1900 bands, and you can even buy it directly from Cingular with service rebates. If you have your heart set on the S700i, just know that while making and receiving calls on Cingular's network is possible, it's not an "official" Cingular phone. Or you could switch to T-Mobile if you're off your Cingular contract, as T-Mobile concentrates on the GSM 1900 band, rather than the 850 band.

Push-to-talk between carriers?

LG VX4700
LG VX4700
Q: I am a Verizon Wireless customer and have always admired Nextel's Direct Connect push-to-talk (PTT) feature. When I saw Verizon introduce its PTT feature a year or so ago, I was pretty excited, but it seems like Verizon seems isn't marketing it very aggressively. Any idea why the lack of enthusiasm over the carrier's PTT? Also, is there any chance that the Verizon and Nextel PTT features will ever be able to work with each other? (I know they use different wireless technologies.)
--Brian

A: You're correct, Brian, in that Verizon's push-to-talk network does seem like an afterthought. The launch of the service was quiet, and Verizon hasn't pushed it much since then. Nextel, on the other hand, has defined itself with its Direct Connect service for most of its existence, and Sprint and even Alltel rolled out PTT networks to more fanfare. I'm not sure why Verizon has kept things so low key, but it's evident even in its cell phone lineup. So far, the carrier has just three humdrum PTT phones, the latest being the LG VX4700.

In regard to your second question, the Verizon and Nextel PTT networks are incompatible at present. Like you said, the carriers use two different networks: Verizon uses CDMA, while Nextel uses iDEN. You can make regular calls between the two carriers, of course, but PTT calls are not possible. With the Sprint and Nextel merger, we will see some future interoperability between their PTT networks, but Verizon--and Alltel, for that matter--will be left out for some time.

Tracfone troubles

Motorola V60i
Motorola V60i
Q: I decided to buy my first cell phone earlier this summer. Since I plan to use it only for emergencies and didn't want to sign a contract, I decided the best option was to go with Tracfone's prepaid service. I bought a Motorola V60i from Wal-Mart, but when I got home, I couldn't get it to activate properly. Tracfone suggested I take it back to the store, but Wal-Mart said it couldn't help me beyond giving my money back. Who should help me with this? Do I even have Tracfone service in my area (De Pere, Wisconsin)?
--Penny


A: Tracfone is definitely responsible for helping you with activation. Wal-Mart acts only as the retailer in this case, so there's not much it can do besides sell you the phone. According to Tracfone's Web site, there is coverage in your area, but there aren't any Tracfone-operated stores. So in your case, you're going to have to contact the company over the phone or request online technical support. Alternatively, you might also check if a Tracfone representative ever visits your Wal-Mart. If so, they would be able to help you. But if you still can't get assistance to your satisfaction, I would return the phone and switch to another prepaid carrier. As you said, you didn't sign a contract, so there's nothing to stop you from moving on. You can evaluate several options in CNET's quick guide to prepaid phones.

Cellular signals
Q: What kind of information can be transmitted in a cellular signal? I know the signals transmit the caller's number, but can they also transmit information to the phone that requires it to perform a certain action, such as a ring as a vibration? If so, why don't cell phone companies offer this feature to call people who you know are in a meeting or at a movie?
--Christopher

What's your dream cell phone feature? TalkBack to me below.
A: You're a bit ahead of your time, Christopher. While the recipient of your call can always set their phone to vibrate or play a certain ring tone when you phone them, it's not a feature you can request as the caller. Of course, there are ways to contact someone discreetly with a cell phone. Besides a simple text message, some cell phones, such as the Nokia 6101, allow you to send a voice message to contacts without having their phone ring. Then again, if you know someone's in a meeting or at a movie, I hope you limit your calls to emergencies only. And if they're at a movie, I hope they just turn their cell phone off.


On hold...

Cellular security 
I received a reader inquiry last month regarding the security of cell phone conversations. The reader said he had read that it was possible to tap into cell phone conversations. As a result, he was worried about giving out secure information, such as a credit card number, over the phone because he didn't want it falling on nefarious ears. Although I wouldn't want anything like this to happen to me either, I think his worries border on paranoia.

Granted, such fears are not totally unfounded. Despite the fact that calls made on digital networks are more secure than analog networks (just read Primary Colors), there's always the possibility that a truly determined person could hack into a call if they so desired. But when you really think about it, if you wanted to remain totally safe from credit card fraud, you wouldn't get one in the first place. Stealing credit information online is a much bigger possibility than doing it over a cell phone. Yet, shopping online has become very common. The same reader also said he wasn't worried about giving his information over a landline. But landlines--cordless phones especially--are vulnerable to eavesdropping as well. And what's to stop a store clerk from stealing your number or even someone who works at the issuing bank? In all fairness, it could happen almost anywhere.

So give yourself a rest and don't get too worried about such things. Like I said, it can happen. But the chances it will happen to you are slim, especially when you consider there are millions of people in this country with credit cards and cell phones.

More commentary
Buzz Report
Molly Wood
Taking a bite out of hype.
Security Watch
Robert Vamosi
Don't get burned by viruses and hackers.
Fully Equipped
David Carnoy
The electronics you lust for.
On Call
Kent German
Solutions for your wireless woes.
Driving It
Wayne Cunningham
What's hot and what's not in car tech.

advertisement