Version: 2008
  • On CHOW: Sexy vampire party
advertisement
HOME VIDEO
To TiVo or Replay?
Now that you've decided to change your TV-watching habits, the question is "Which DVR is right for me?"

ReplayTV 5040
ReplayTV 5040  
The full skinny on the 40-hour ReplayTV 5040.
TiVo DVR Series2 (40 hr)
TiVo DVR Series2 (40 hr) 
Read our analysis of the TiVo Series2 40-hour version. 
Read the review  Check prices


Introduction
An overview of the current DVR market.
Ratings compared
Detailed accounts of the numbers behind the numbers in our reviews.
Beyond the ratings
Ratings aren't everything, so here are other factors to consider.
Other options
A brief summary of other DVRs and links to reviews.
TiVo tricks
Program your TiVo Series2 for commercial skip and Ethernet access.
TiVo Home Media Option
An in-depth review of TiVo's $99 networking upgrade.
Other options
The standalone versions of TiVo and Replay that we discuss here work with your existing satellite dish or cable box. Since TiVo licenses its technology, other standalone products such as Sony's SVR-3000 are also available for sale.


DishNetwork PVR501
Then there are combination satellite receiver/DVRs--such as the Dish Network DishPVR 501 and the Hughes HDVR2--which incorporate the DVR hard drive and the satellite receiver in one box and require a satellite subscription. Combination products are very popular; Dish Network actually has more DVRs in American homes than either TiVo or Replay, thanks to its DishPVR 501. The Hughes HDVR2 and the Philips DSR7000 are the only DirecTV/TiVo systems available with two tuners.

DVR/DVD combination products have also begun to appear. The RCA Scenium DRS7000N uses the free GuidePlus program guide. Panasonic's DMR-HS2, DMR-E80H, and DMR-E100H can record to their internal hard drive or their DVD burner, but they forgo any programming guide in favor of manual VCR Plus input. Toshiba's RD-X2 also combines DVR functionality (sans programming guide) with a DVD recorder.

A best-of-both-worlds option may be on the horizon with the announcement of TiVo Basic service. Third-party manufacturers will soon be able to bundle a stripped-down version of the TiVo service with their DVRs. TiVo Basic will sacrifice many of TiVo's trademark features, but it will not require a monthly or lifetime fee (though users may pay to upgrade to full TiVo functionality at any point). Toshiba's SD-H400, an 80GB DVR/DVD player combo, and Pioneer's DVR-810H are expected to be the first products to offer TiVo Basic.

Read the full review:
TiVo