On TV.com: KIM KARDASHIAN is hot hot hot

Search:
Go!


HDTV World > Optimize your HDTV > Choose your HD service

HDTV World: Everything you need to know about HDTV

Choose your HD service

John P. Falcone
By John P. Falcone
(September 8, 2005)


Which provider offers better high-def programming options: cable or satellite?


Once you've chosen your HDTV equipment, you need to settle on how you'll be receiving HDTV programming. As with standard TV, you have three choices: cable, satellite, or an over-the-air antenna. Each method has its advantages and disadvantages, as well as its own set of special equipment requirements and caveats.

Choose a connection method:  Cable | Satellite | Over the air

Pros:

  • Wide variety of programming available, including cable HDTV networks and local HDTV stations.

  • Many carriers will provide the set-top box, HD DVR, or HD package for less than $10 per month, if not free.

  • Digital Cable Ready HDTVs need only a CableCard smart card, available from your cable provider, to receive all programming, including HD--no cable box necessary.

  • Bundled broadband Internet access available from most cable providers.
Cons:

  • While more HDTV programming is available over cable than via an antenna, choices are still spotty.

  • No cable access in many rural areas.

  • Regular monthly charges still apply.


What's available:

Varies by area; lineup may include some or all of the following:

  • ABC
  • CBS
  • Fox
  • NBC
  • TNT-HD
  • PBS
  • UPN
  • WB
  • ESPN-HD
  • Universal HD
  • TNT HD
  • Discovery HD Theater
  • InHD
  • InHD2
  • HDNet
  • HDNet Movies
  • Additional independent stations


Additional HD channels:

  • HBO-HD*
  • Cinemax HD*
  • TMC HD*
  • Starz HD*
  • Encore HD*


Equipment you'll need:

  • Cable box method: You supply an HDTV or an HD monitor; cable company will supply an HD cable box or an HD DVR for a small monthly premium above the standard cable bill.

  • CableCard method: You supply a Digital Cable Ready HDTV; cable company will supply the CableCard for a small monthly premium beyond the standard cable bill. (Note: Anyone wanting a DVR, a full on-screen programming guide, and/or video-on-demand services should go with the cable box method instead.)



Pros:

  • New MPEG-4 compression technology will bring dozens of HD networks and hundreds of local HD stations to satellite subscribers by the end of 2005.

  • Satellite HDTV packages are often more affordable than cable counterparts.
Cons:

  • Existing subscribers must buy set-top boxes (STBs).

  • Existing subscribers will have to upgrade their STBs to receive MPEG-4 transmissions.

  • Current boxes require awkward over-the-air antennas to get local HD channels.


What's available:

DirecTV HD package ($11 per month):

  • ESPN HD
  • ESPN2 HD
  • Discovery HD Theater
  • HDNet
  • HDNet Movies
  • Universal HD
  • YES HD


Also available:

  • High-definition PPV ($4.99 each)
  • Showtime HDTV (for Showtime subscribers)
  • HBO HDTV (for HBO subscribers)
  • NBA TV (for subscribers)
  • Select NFL Sunday Ticket games (for subscribers)
  • HD feeds for ABC, CBS, Fox, and NBC (certain areas only)


Dish Network HD Pack ($9.99 per month):

  • ESPN HD
  • Discovery HD Theater
  • HDNet
  • HDNet Movies
  • TNT HD


Also available:

  • CBS HDTV (certain areas only)
  • Dish Network pay-per-view in HD ($5.99 each)
  • Showtime HDTV (for Showtime subscribers)
  • HBO HDTV (for HBO subscribers)
  • NBA TV (for subscribers)


Equipment you'll need:

  • DirecTV: You supply an HDTV or an HD monitor; purchase and install a triple LNB satellite dish and an HD satellite box or a DVR. 
    Service:
    888/238-7177 or www.directv.com
    (or contact your local satellite installer)

  • Dish Network: You supply an HDTV or an HD monitor; purchase and install a triple LNB satellite dish and an HD satellite box or a DVR. 
    Service:
    800/333-3474 or www.dishnetwork.com
    (or contact your local satellite installer)



Pros:

  • No monthly fees.
  • HDTVs with built-in tuners need nothing more than an antenna connection to receive local HD programming.
Cons:

  • Many HDTV sets require expensive set-top boxes to decode over-the-air HD signals.
  • Outdoor antenna required in most cases.
  • HD signals won't reach viewers in outlying areas.
  • No specialty channels such as HBO or ESPN.


What's available:

Varies by area; best-case scenario is:

  • ABC
  • CBS
  • Fox
  • NBC
  • Pax
  • Telemundo
  • PBS
  • UPN
  • WB
  • Additional independent stations


Equipment you'll need:

  • HDTV with built-in tuner: You supply the HDTV with the built-in tuner, as well as an antenna. You'll need to mount the antenna yourself and make the necessary connections.

  • HDTV-ready TV or monitor: You supply the HD-ready TV/monitor, an external HD tuner, and an antenna. You'll need to mount the antenna yourself and make the necessary connections.




Printer-friendly versionPrinter-friendly version
Send feedbackSend feedback
E-mail to a friendE-mail to a friend
Featured HDTV videos:
advertisement
Resources from our sponsors

Comcast has the most HD. More than satellite. More than anyone.


The Samsung LN52A650 LCD is latest CNET editors' choice award winner.



TalkBack
14 messages

Article discussion: Choose your HD service


Latest post:

"What about FIOS and U-VERSE"
by socraticgp (See profile) - March 13, 2008 9:21 PM PDT
I thought that you article was useful, but what about the new digital services from Verizon and AT&T? (Read more).
Sort by: Title |
Date
| Most helpful

update hdtv info

this info needs to be updated, there are references to 2005, over 2 years ago. T... (Read more)
by jbail51 (See profile) - December 9, 2007 4:16 AM PST

WRONG (Out of Date) INFORMATION

You've dropped the ball, guys.
This information is "spoiled" and needs to be ... (Read more)
by Hi-def Jeff (See profile) - February 14, 2007 9:40 AM PST

Old information

It may be time for a new review (Read more)
by bstew007 (See profile) - December 27, 2006 6:21 PM PST

Do your own research

It's surprising that cnet would misinform the public on such a hot subject like ... (Read more)
by p1n1c0 (See profile) - December 27, 2006 2:14 PM PST

Need to consider HD quality as well

This is a good primer but it leaves out the whole compression issue. Over the ai... (Read more)
by dan_canale (See profile) - December 27, 2006 12:23 PM PST

Channel list is outdated

Somebody needs to update the HD channel list. This is not a current representat... (Read more)
by ryan.gaines (See profile) - December 27, 2006 12:16 PM PST

Old Content

Once again, Cnet trumpets an antique feature story on its homepage (12/27/06). ... (Read more)
by heinriph (See profile) - December 27, 2006 11:29 AM PST

Umm... dozens?

I notice we are more than half way through 2006 and there is still only a dozen ... (Read more)
by nickj1088 (See profile) - August 8, 2006 3:04 PM PDT

Is ATSC a scam?

DBS isn't an option (my equatorial view is obstructed), and I have ...issues... ... (Read more)
by punterjoe (See profile) - July 1, 2006 5:12 AM PDT


© 2008 CNET Networks, Inc., a CBS Company. All rights reserved. | Privacy Policy | Terms of Use