Editors' Top Televisions
updated June 14, 2006
 

  Your wife or significant other doesn't want to fill the living room with a boxy rear-projector, yet you still want a big picture. Welcome to the perfect compromise: an inches-thick flat plasma display. These panels can handle all your video needs, including HDTV, although many so-called EDTV versions don't have enough pixels to do high-def content justice. Then again, EDTV plasmas cost less than higher-resolution models. Plasmas are expensive regardless of how many pixels they have, but they're getting more affordable all the time. And can you really put a price on domestic bliss?
-- David Katzmaier, senior editor

 

Editors' top televisions:


Shopping by brand? According to CNET editors, here are this category's major players:
Hitachi  |  JVC  |  LG  |  Mitsubishi  |  Panasonic  |  Philips  |  Pioneer  |  RCA  |  Samsung  |  Sharp  |  Sony  |  Toshiba

Related top products:  DVRs (TiVo)  |  DVD decks  |  Home audio products
 
Plasma TV
Televisions Editors' rating Price Summary
Pioneer PDP-5060HD
Released: 09/30/2005
8.0 out of 10 8.0
Excellent
 
The Pioneer PDP-5060HD offers excellent picture quality, great style, and superior features--its only real downside is that it's priced more than the competition.
Specs: Plasma TV , 50 in, 1100 cd/m2, 4000:1 , 1280 x 768 , 16:9 , Black
 

Pioneer PDP-4360HD
Released: 09/01/2005
8.0 out of 10 8.0
Excellent
 
Pioneer's PDP-4360HD offers improved black-level performance and excellent overall picture quality, but it costs a bit more than the competition.
Specs: Plasma TV , 43 in, 1100 cd/m2, 4000:1 , 1024 x 768 , 16:9
 

Panasonic TH-42PHD8UK
Released: 10/01/2005
7.8 out of 10 7.8
Very good
 
The 42-inch Panasonic TH-42PHD8UK is a great deal for the money, but only if you're comfortable adding inputs, you don't need a tuner, and you remember to buy a stand.
Specs: Plasma panel , 42 in, 3000:1 , 1024 x 768 , 16:9
 

Panasonic TH-50PHD8UK
Released: 09/01/2005
7.8 out of 10 7.8
Very good
 
Although it's missing a couple of inputs, the Panasonic TH-50PHD8UK surpasses any 50-inch plasma we've reviewed in terms of image quality and overall value.
Specs: Plasma panel , 50 in, 3000:1 , 1366 x 768 , 16:9 , Black
 

Panasonic TH-37PHD8UK
Released: 09/01/2005
7.8 out of 10 7.8
Very good
 
Despite limited features and connectivity, the Panasonic TH-37PHD8UK is one of the best small-screen plasmas on the market today in terms of picture quality.
Specs: Plasma panel , 37 in, 3000:1 , 1024 x 720 , 16:9
 

Panasonic TH-42PX60U
Released: 04/15/2006
7.5 out of 10 7.5
Very good
 
The Panasonic TH-42PX60U sets the standard for value among full-featured 42-inch plasmas.
Specs: Plasma TV , 42 in, 10000:1 , 1024 x 768 , 16:9
 

HP PL4200N
Released: 09/01/2005
7.3 out of 10 7.3
Very good
 
Despite some trade-offs in color fidelity, the HP PL4200N delivers a surprisingly solid picture with excellent blacks and plenty of punch.
Specs: Plasma TV , 42 in, 3000:1 , 1024 x 768 , 16:9 , Black
 

Hitachi 55HDT52
Released: 10/15/2005
7.1 out of 10 7.1
Very good
 
The 55-inch Hitachi 55HDT52 plasma looks beautiful on the outside, but its image quality isn't up to the same standards as its styling.
Specs: Plasma TV , 55 in, 1366 x 768 , 16:9 , Black
 

Vizio P50HDM
Released: 08/01/2005
7.0 out of 10 7.0
Very good
 
With commendable image quality and plenty of connections, the relatively inexpensive V Vizio P50HDM 50-inch plasma is the best value in its class.
Specs: Plasma panel , 50 in, 1000 cd/m2, 10000:1 , 1366 x 768 , 16:9 , Black
 

Dell W4201C
Released: 12/01/2005
6.9 out of 10 6.9
Good
 
While the Dell W4201C is suitable for brightly lit environments, its image quality for home theater falls short of that of the best plasmas we've seen.
Specs: Plasma TV , 42 in, 1100 cd/m2, 10000:1 , 1024 x 768 , 16:9 , Silver
 

Hitachi 42HDT52
Released: 10/01/2005
6.8 out of 10 6.8
Good
 
While the Hitachi 42HDT52 plasma is full-featured and downright beautiful to look at, its image quality doesn't quite measure up to that of the tough competition.
Specs: Plasma TV , 42 in, 1024 x 1024 , 16:9 , Black
 

Dell W5001C
Released: 09/28/2005
6.5 out of 10 6.5
Good
 
Although promising on paper, in the real world the Dell W5001C's problems handling darker material prevent it from outperforming most other 50-inch plasmas.
Specs: Plasma TV , 50 in, 1100 cd/m2, 8000:1 , 1366 x 768 , 16:9
 




   

Samsung HP-S4253
Released: 05/01/2006
6.2 out of 10 6.2
Good
 
Although the Samsung HP-S4253's glossy black styling and numerous inputs work in its favor, its issues with picture quality lessen its value.
Specs: Plasma TV , 42 in, 1300 cd/m2, 10000:1 , 1024 x 768 , 16:9 , Black
 

Vizio P42
Released: 03/20/2006
6.2 out of 10 6.2
Good
 
Discerning viewers won't be satisfied with its home-theater performance, but nobody can deny that the Vizio P42HDTV is a great bargain for casual TV watching.
Specs: Plasma TV , 42 in, 1200 cd/m2, 10000:1 , 1024 x 768 , 16:9
 

Philips 42PF9630A
Released: 07/15/2005
6.2 out of 10 6.2
Good
 
Unfortunately, this somewhat expensive plasma's unique style and solid connectivity bay are not backed up by home-theater-worthy image quality.
Specs: Plasma TV , 42 in, 1500 cd/m2, 10000:1 , 1024 x 768 , 16:9 , Pearl white silver
 

 
Additional electronics coverage
 
  • On CHOW: His burger will EAT your burger