On MovieTome: TRANSFORMERS 2 SPOILERS!

Search:
Go!


Alpha Blog: CNET's gadget & tech news and opinions blogged by our editors
March 16, 2006, 10:51 AM PST
The haunting of seat 6F
Posted by: Rafe Needleman

ThinkPad X41
Is my X41 haunted?
[+] Enlarge photo
A weird and scary thing happened to me on my flight down to PC Forum. I opened up my ThinkPad X41 laptop to do some work, and the machine wouldn't start up. I thought maybe it was a sleep mode problem (the machine had been in standby), so I turned off the laptop and restarted it. Then I got a hard disk controller error I had never seen before. I restarted, and it happened again. Slightly worried (but not too much, since I am obsessive about backups), I powered down, took out the battery, waited a few seconds, then reassembled the laptop and started it up again. It worked. By this time we were descending, so I had to power down right away. I chalked up the error to a random glitch. At PC Forum, I had no problems and was able to blog away merrily.

But on the flight back, the same thing happened. I opened up the laptop and got an error. And this time, nothing I did would get the machine to work. Yet when I got home, everything was fine. What happened?

Here are the working theories:

1. I was in the same seat, 6F, on both flights. Possibly I was on the same airplane. Perhaps there was some strange electromagnetic phenomenon (or a ghost) that kept my hard disk from working.

2. The ThinkPad has a protection system that parks the hard disk when it detects shock or excess vibration. It could be that the vibration of the airplane kicked in the protection system and kept the hard disk from working.

3. The lower atmospheric pressure in the cabin may have affected the hard disk or a cable connecting it. That would explain why the machine started working during descent. An editor I work with at CNET says her iPod acts up in airplanes; another has a similar problem with his PSP.

What else could it be? Should I get a new laptop?

TalkBack
8 messages

laptop and notebook computers online

laptop computers can be a rather tricky buy at times, I would suggest that you look out for the cheapest and yet latest desktop on the market,

the best way to do this is on what they call warehouse sale markets some of them are online.

these warehouse owners have a service where they sell laptop computers to normal customers like you and me, however with very reduced prices due to the fact that they do not have as much costs as normal shops do, such as rent and a employees etc. as you know most online shops have rather competitive prices sometimes cutting the laptop price to a half.

one such website for laptop computers is :

http://umgarticles.atspace.com/laptop-computer.htm
by imediacorporation (See profile) - July 17, 2006 1:50 AM PDT

Not Pressure related

As a pilot, i can tell you this is probbably not related to pressure changes during operation of the computer. Commercial aircraft are pressurized to an altitude of approx. 8000 feet. As you are not allowed to have any electronics on prior to 10,000ft on departure, and are asked to turn them off well before decending below 10,000ft, you should not experience any difference in pressure during the course of the flight in which the computer would be in operation. I would find it hard to believe that 8000ft difference in pressure would render a laptop inoperable, as I have yet to hear of anyone in the rockies having issues w/ their computers. Either way, I would feel pretty confident that most laptops, especially the one mentioned in the post would be aircraft pressurization tested, as 99% of laptops used for business are used in aircraft.
by Ual232 (See profile) - March 26, 2006 7:17 AM PST
5 out of 5 users found this comment helpful | 1 comment

Environmental Specs

I would expect that your issue is not related to solid state components on the system, and most likely not related to cables or connections.

Your system is running POST, so I think that your diagnosis is accurate concerning the HD. I am not a HD expert, but looking at the environmental specs for common 2.5" drives, it looks like they are only spec'd for up to 10K' in altitude, very close to the pressurization you might find on an airplane when it reaches its max altitude.

Having been involved in spec-manship on PC components before, I wouldn't be surprised if this is a loose spec, and not the kind of spec that is tested for each component, so having samples that are a sigma out or so in the operating characteristics might not be considered a big deal. Also, the value and "quality" of the spec might vary from mfg. to mfg. leading to what appears odd behavior from device to device.

A call to your HD mfg. might help clear up if their HDDs operate like this. Also, I wouldn't be surprised if HD mfgs have products with improved specs for the jet setters, and if not, they develop them soon given all of the devices people use on aircraft now.
by njoyner (See profile) - March 20, 2006 3:16 PM PST
10 out of 10 users found this comment helpful

Sounds pressure related

I sugest you read up on "Air Bearing"

"An air bearing is a bearing that literally consists of a layer of atmospheric air used as the working fluid for a fluid bearing. Air bearings are often used where the gap between moving surfaces must be small and where differential velocity is high enough to allow the viscosity of air to build up enough pressure to keep the moving surfaces separated.

Examples of the use of an air bearing is the "flying head" in a computer's hard disk drive. Systems requiring highly precise motion typically incorporate air bearing technology in order to achieve accurate and repeatable motion with low friction and no wear. Common applications include machine tools, multi axis metrology systems, and spindles for the semiconductor and data storage industries."

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Air_bearings
by sidewinder (See profile) - March 20, 2006 2:36 PM PST

Ghosts or Pressures

The lower atmospheric pressure is a better reason in my opinion. However, there could be other factors taken into account when one flys at such great heights.
by PencilPadded (See profile) - March 20, 2006 8:03 AM PST

(NT) Lots of things can cause this problem.

by nectufine (See profile) - March 20, 2006 4:26 AM PST
0 out of 10 users found this comment helpful

it happened to my ipod!

Very interesting to know about the electromagnetic phenomenon. My ipod Nano screen freezed on a flight from DC to SF! Surprisly, I used the same ipod for a longer flight last Dec (~15 hrs) and it didn't happen!
I still don't get it!
by harith (See profile) - March 17, 2006 8:04 AM PST

March 2006 archive

S M Tu W Th F S
      1 2 3 4
5 6 7 8 9 10 11
12 13 14 15 16 17 18
19 20 21 22 23 24 25
26 27 28 29 30 31

for Alpha.CNET.com

1x1
 

advertisement



© 2008 CNET Networks, Inc., a CBS Company. All rights reserved. | Privacy Policy | Terms of Use