• On The Insider: Britney's Bikini-Clad Top 10
September 12, 2008 1:29 PM PDT

How much do you text?

by Nicole Lee
The QWERTY keyboard on the Blitz is for texting

The QWERTY keyboard on the Blitz is made for texting

(Credit: Corinne Schulze/CNET)

On September 10, CTIA reported that American cell-phone subscribers are sending more text messages than ever despite the rising cost. About 75 billion SMS text messages were sent in June alone, according to the report. Of course, texting is only a relatively recent boom here in the U.S.--people from Europe and Asia have been sending and receiving text messages for years, most likely due to the low cost of texting over there.

With that in mind, many manufacturers are racing each other to develop messaging-centric phones with full QWERTY keyboards, but that aren't smart phones. The recently released Verizon Wireless Blitz has a slide-out QWERTY keyboard, and at CTIA this past week, Sprint announced the LG Lotus, which has a fold-out QWERTY keyboard. Samsung also announced the Samsung Rant, a slider device reminiscent of the LG Rumor, both of which have hidden QWERTY keyboards.

But will these devices be popular among frequent texters? I know several of my friends who learned to type out text messages with a 12-number keypad via T9, and claim that they actually text more slowly with a QWERTY keyboard. I hear the same thing with a lot of teenagers and tweens who've never used a phone with a QWERTY keyboard, and find texting with T9 easier. For those who are newer to texting though, I can see QWERTY phones like this being a big hit.

How about you, dear readers? Are you on the texting bandwagon? If so, how much do you text? Are you on an unlimited text-message plan, or do you opt for the cheaper ones? And would you be interested in any of these new messaging phones that aren't smart phones? Let us know in the comments below.

Nicole Lee is an associate editor for CNET, covering cell phones, Bluetooth headsets, and all things mobile. She's also pretty geeky--she likes World of Warcraft, comic books, and shiny gadgets. E-mail Nicole.
Recent posts from CTIA show
Jabra Halo makes its debut
Wi-Ex shows new cell phone signal boosters
On Call: Lessons from CTIA
CTIA 2009 wrap-up
Brief look at the LG Wine
Samsung to launch two Android devices in U.S.
LG Banter also available from U.S. Cellular
BlueAnt announces the BlueAnt S1
Add a Comment (Log in or register) Showing 1 of 2 pages (38 Comments)
by Dred242 September 12, 2008 3:26 PM PDT
I have the Motorola E815 flip phone with a T9 keyboard. Typing on this phone totally sucks. I would love to text more but my phone holds be back. My wife and both my kids own NEW phones with QWERTY keyboards (two LG eNV2's and one Samsung U-740 Alias).....I feel so left out! My next phone will have a QWERTY keyboard, count on it.
Reply to this comment
by bryancmak September 12, 2008 5:28 PM PDT
I love to text. I have a regular keypad and texting with T9 is extremely fast, even my friends with QWERTY phones are amazed. Typing on my friends' QWERTY phone is definitely not as fast for me, but I'm not all that slow. So I think that if i had a little more practice with one, I could start sending out messages more rapidly than before.

So it really comes down to whether your willing to spend a little extra time learning how to use a QWERTY keyboard phone
Reply to this comment
by IAM_MATT September 13, 2008 4:46 AM PDT
Usually the disadvantage of the QWERTY keyboards (for me) is that it requires two hands. I, being a former high school student, remember the days of texting under the desk so the teacher wouldn't see. T9 is obviously the hands down winner in that type of environment. T9 is not just for school, though. Sometimes I'll be laying down and I'll receive a text. I like to lay on my sides so it's very helpful to only have to use one hand to type out a reply.

The bottom line with T9 is that it's better for single-handed users.

I did own a smart phone at one point with a QWERTY keyboard. It had its uses. For example, I wouldn't have to keep pressing zero (or whichever button is used to find the next word) to get the word that I want. With T9, for example, if I wanted to type out 'dime' I would press the appropriate corresponding number keys (3463) and 'find' would be the first word to show up. I have to press zero three times before dime, the desired word, shows up.

The bottom line with QWERTY is that it's optimal for users who are more comfortable using both hands, and like their words to show up on the first try.


Personally, I prefer T9, but hey, I'm a single-handed user. I feel that it's faster for me, and face it, sometimes you can't always use both hands.
Reply to this comment
by HyVoltage January 6, 2009 1:45 AM PST
I think we all know the REAL reason you only have one free hand available! <wink/grin>
Sorry, I couldn't resist. ;-)
by jture September 13, 2008 7:00 AM PDT
And now a word from the age of the dinosaurs (i.e., people born before 1980) - I've never sent a text message in my life and I'm not going to start now. Not interested. I want my phone to be a PHONE, not a camera/music-player/daily planner/messaging device/computer/everything else. Cellphone salespeople hate me!
Reply to this comment
by walnuts79 September 13, 2008 8:56 AM PDT
Well first of all I dont think im a dinosaur because I was born in 1979. And I have been texting ever since I got my first phone my nextel i90 or something like that. I used to have an lg8300 and I loved it. I was a texting champion. Now I got a blackberry pearl with the suretype. At first it took me a few days to learn how to type and now I think im just as fast as i was with the t9. And I have had an unlimited texting plan for a few years now. And I think I text quite a bit...maybe in the few thousands a month range... But I dont think i would trade in my bb for a regular phone though. But to me the qwerty or the regular phone pad does not make a difference to me.
Reply to this comment
by jaymattlin September 13, 2008 9:00 AM PDT
Texting on my QWERTY keyboard is so much better than using T9.
Reply to this comment
by myles taylor September 13, 2008 11:53 AM PDT
I like the options that give me both. I had a hard time with T9 at first, but I got used to it. I don't think I would prefer a QWERTY keyboard at this point. I've gotten used to typing on my iPod touch too, so I could get used to a touch screen. I suppose that I would get used to QWERTY too. I don't mind T9.
Reply to this comment
by Faztang September 13, 2008 12:43 PM PDT
I have the EnV 2 from Verizon. It's a GREAT non-smart phone with a QWERTY keyboard.
Very compact design, yet spacious keyboard. I switched to Verizon because my prior carrier AT&T has hardly any QWERTY cell phones (all of their phones are smart phones with expensive data plans)
Verizon seems to have the most QWERTY cell phones (not smart phones) options out there at all kinds of price points.
Reply to this comment
by atomicbomb156 September 13, 2008 2:12 PM PDT
I have a sony ericsson w600i. It has T9 but I prefer not to use it. I use a lot of words that it doesn't know and i hate correcting it. And I can still text one handed without looking at the keyboard so it doesn't really matter to me. I don't want to qwerty keyboard on my phone because I'm so used to using the numeric keypad. And I send maybe 1000 texts a month? The most I've sent a month was about 2 years ago when I maxed at 2000 a month. I receive on average 1500 texts a month. Luckily we have unlimited texting :/
Reply to this comment
by stuart6022 September 13, 2008 7:42 PM PDT
Personally, I prefer to talk as I feel texting like email is very impersonal. People send me text messages all the time and I just ignore them. I don't understand when a person is 10 feet away, they have to IM.
Reply to this comment
by HyVoltage January 6, 2009 1:54 AM PST
Well, there are significant advantages to using text messages instead of calling someone, the biggest one being that sometimes you want to ask a quick simple question or give a small piece of information ("I'll meet you there at 6:00") and you don't want to get into a possibly time-consuming conversation with the other person.
by JTsosa25 September 13, 2008 8:11 PM PDT
I like both but would like a full QWERTY keyboard,but all my phone have been T9 so i learned to text with it.
What i like is what the Blackberry Pearl has 2 letters to a button.
Reply to this comment
by mssbais September 13, 2008 8:35 PM PDT
I'm old (46) by texting standards, but I'm totally hooked. It's the perfect communication medium for all those times (many each day) that you want to get a note to a friend or co-worker without interrupting them or trying to get their attention through the usual deluge of emails. My peers don't get it; they all say "Who needs texting, with voice mail, email, cell phones..." Their loss. I use QWERTY just because my AT&T Tilt has it, but I'm also not afraid of learning T9 which would be great for single-handedness. Old people (my peers) need to suck it up and figure out that (a) texting will be a standard communication mode of the future, and (b) T9 is fast and more convenient. DEAL WITH IT.
Reply to this comment
by Placebo1985 September 14, 2008 2:27 AM PDT
I have been texting a bit since my early tweens but I really prefer voice conversation when possible. I like the QWERTY keyboards but I can see how someone with larger fingers might hate them.I use the T9 right now and it takes some getting used to. I only really text with people who insist on texting because they are frugal and it's cheap here in Europe. I probably send/receive about 100 SMS a month, so I'm not a heavy user.
Reply to this comment
by thefox84 September 14, 2008 8:32 AM PDT
I definitely prefer the Qwerty keyboard now that I've gotten so used to it. I used to have the Nokia 6126 which was actually pretty good at texting and had a nice feel to it, but the phone was cheap and I tried to skimp on the cell phone carrier so the phone constantly had problems and the network was just awful. I got a maroon Env2 with Verizon and have never looked back... the reception is great everywhere and always better than the rest of the Verizon phones in my family. The call quality is great, the texting is great, the music is always nice to have on me(4 gig minisd card for only $17.99!) , and I don't have to pay for an expensive data plan. And hell I can even text with T9 on the outside of the phone with one hand(which I NEVER do)... but overall I think its the ideal phone for texters, nothing can even come close to it.
Reply to this comment
by tech_junky48 September 14, 2008 11:32 AM PDT
I'm a teenager, but I don't text. It may be "cool" but I really don't see the point. With AT&T , my parents have over 2000 rollover minutes, plus around 550 more every month. I talk, I don't text, because it's faster for me to say it. I see no real advantage. Sure, it's uncool (hey, I'm posting here, that should say something about my coolness) but it's cheaper. As for my phone, I have a blackjack 2 smartphone, and I never wanna go back to the "dumb" phone.
Reply to this comment
by Wesuhley October 17, 2008 5:58 PM PDT
What is the point of having a "smart" phone if you only do "dumb" stuff on it (Ex.Calling)?? Go back to the "dumb phone" lol.. =]

Smart Phones with QWERTY keyboards are MADE for texting/emails/IMs! duhr.
by RS_Mgr_La September 14, 2008 11:56 AM PDT
Part of the reason why I chose the EnV2 is because I can text in T9 on the front OR use the QWERTY inside. Best of both worlds.
Reply to this comment
by zlguocius September 14, 2008 2:39 PM PDT
About a year ago I started getting text message spam. I called Verizon (my wireless provider), and they could not block particular numbers, though they did offer to delete the charges on spam I had already received. I didn't want to have to call them every time I got a spam text message, so I chose the only other way to stop it: drop the text messaging feature all together.

Now I'm unable to text message at all, which means less money for Verizon and less convenience for me. Good going, Verizon.
Reply to this comment
by sting7k September 14, 2008 5:00 PM PDT
I text all the time. I never was one for T9, on my old phones I used to turn it off as I had quickly memorized how many key presses for each letter and was pretty fast. Since then all my phones have had QWERTY keyboards (tmobile MDA, tmobile dash, unlocked HTC S710) and now I have an iPhone (3G). I got the original iPhone when it came out and grew to love the touch screen keyboard. Like some pointed out the problem with a QWERTY keyboard phone is it really needs 2 hands to work. On the iPhone I find I am still very fast with one hand on its touch keyboard and the spell correction is very good, I do wish there was landscape mode for when I want to use 2 hands.
Reply to this comment
by AppleSuxLeo September 14, 2008 5:21 PM PDT
The Amtrack train conductor that killed 25+ people , and injured hundreds more...was texting. He was squashed beyond recognition !
Reply to this comment
by kylebuttermore September 14, 2008 11:47 PM PDT
t9 is better
Reply to this comment
Showing 1 of 2 pages (38 Comments)
advertisement

About CTIA show

The CTIA show highlights the latest in hot cell phones, accessories, and services. CNET brings you the top wireless news from the conference.

Add this feed to your online news reader

CTIA show topics