• On TechRepublic: FREE download: Automated invoice form
August 11, 2008 6:30 AM PDT

Top 5 music discovery tips for the unhip, unmotivated

by Donald Bell
Photo of music anthology books.

We swear, there's no reading required to expand your musical horizons these days. Well...aside from this article, at least.

(Credit: Donald Bell/CNET Networks)


When you're young, new music is everywhere: radio, Facebook profiles, borrowed iPods, or even burned CDs. It's not hard to find tunes you love. The music appetites of 13- to 21-year-olds are voracious and the consequences of being musically unhip can be punishing.

Then something happens: you get older; work a full-time job; get married; have a mortgage; have children; adopt a particularly demanding parrot; and so on. You wake up one day and realize your taste in music hasn't budged since your early '20s and the prospect of discovering good, new music now seems like an overwhelming chore, fraught with disappointment. I know, I'm living proof.

We're all familiar with the long, depressing list of activities that seemed easy in youth that now take effort. Fortunately, finding good music isn't as tough as working off that middle-age gut. Since its inception, the Internet has helped us--mostly illegally--discover new music. Finally, tools for legal and efficient online music discovery are hitting their stride.

To help you help yourself, we've collected our favorite techniques to help the lazy, hurried, or unhip (or, face it, aging) connect with good, new music.


Music discovery technique No. 1: Personalized Internet radio

Recommended: Pandora, Slacker
Also see: AOL Radio, Live 365

There was a time your FM radio offered a steady stream of new music. Today, with the exception of public and college radio (which have their own challenges), annoying ads, and tight song rotations leave you little to learn. In short: radio sucks.

Screen shot of Pandora Web site.

Using Pandora's Music Genome Project to passively stumble onto new music is about as simple as it gets. Click to enlarge.

(Credit: Pandora)

Lucky for us, Internet radio's infinite bandwidth offers thousands of well-groomed stations eager to prove their musical good taste. Sifting through the Web's deep directories of Internet radio stations requires time and patience, however, so we're going to focus on the automatic, personalized options offered by Pandora and Slacker.

The beauty of both Pandora and Slacker is their passive approach to music discovery. All you have to do is call up their Web site and select an artist or genre as a starting point for music recommendations. Just like rating rented movies in Netflix, rating songs in Pandora or Slacker improves the quality of their recommendations and tailors your playlist to suit your taste. To help you track down the new music you're hearing, most online radio stations display the currently playing artist, album, and song title, and links to acquire the music online.


Music discovery technique No. 2: Find someone with good taste

Recommended: Last.fm, iLike
Also see: iMeem, Blip.fm

Many of us have at least one or two friends who pride themselves on their good taste in music--friends who would create mix tapes or burn CDs for you back in your salad days. There's still no replacement for a good, old-fashioned mix tape, however, there are new and faster ways to co-opt your buddy's music library.

Screenshot of Last.fm.

Last.fm tells me Veronica and I have 'Low musical compatibility'--probably because she has better taste in music than I do. Click to enlarge.

(Credit: Last.fm)

For those of us with shrunken social lives and stale music collections, the public vetting of our listening habits on Web sites such as iLike and Last.fm seems more embarrassing than rewarding. The payoff of participation in these music-focused social networks isn't bragging rights, but the capability to glimpse at the music collections of friends with good taste. By automatically pulling usage data directly from users' iTunes music libraries (or Windows Media Player), Last.fm and iLike chart your most frequently played songs and those of your friends, allowing you to compare tastes and preview tracks.

If you're music-savvy friends aren't techie enough for something like Last.fm, don't sweat it--you use these sites to find strangers with similar music tastes and listen to other songs they tend to like.

Editors' note: Last.fm is owned by CNET's parent company, CBS Interactive.


Music discovery technique No. 3: Subscription music

Recommended: Rhapsody; Napster
Also see: Slacker; Zune Pass

Screen shot of Zune Marketplace.

Here's the beauty of subscription music services: instead of wasting my time deciding which (if any) Kanye West album is worthy of downloading, I can just download his entire catalog and sort out the crappy songs later. Click to enlarge.

(Credit: Microsoft)

In his book The Paradox of Choice, author Barry Schwartz lays out his theory that consumers often become paralyzed with indecision when they face an overwhelming number of choices. I feel this way every time I browse Apple's iTunes music catalog--a problem compounded by the fact that I'm just too cheap to buy a song for $0.99 cents without scrutinizing its 30-second preview like a grocer inspecting fruit. I spend so much time cherry-picking the songs I want to buy that I don't have time left over to casually explore. As a cautious consumer, I'm actually scared that browsing iTunes aimlessly may cause me to buy something I'll regret later, both musically and financially. (To wit: "Why the hell did I think I needed to buy the collected B-sides of Warrant?")

Throwing $12 to $15 a month toward a music subscription service from Rhapsody, Napster, or Zune Pass (for Zune owners) will make you feel like a Survivor contestant dropped in the middle an all-you-can-eat buffet. Suddenly, you don't have worry about overspending or buyer's remorse--you can just download any random damn thing that catches your attention and decide later whether it's worth keeping. Download 1 song or 10,000, it doesn't matter: you pay the same flat fee per month.

Of course, you don't own these songs the same way you would a CD or DRM-free MP3 file. If you stop paying your monthly subscription fee, the music you've downloaded won't play. The trick is to not think of subscription music as a substitute for your music collection. Just think of this as a way to unblock your music Mojo.


Music discovery technique No. 4: Virtual concerts

Recommended: Concert.tv
Also see: Video podcasts

Lest we forget, music recordings were invented as a substitute for live performances. There's still nothing as musically powerful as seeing a great band perform in a room full of wild fans, and even bad performances can refine your taste in music.

Screenshot of Concert.tv Web site.

As the name implies, Concert.tv offers streaming concert videos. They're not all winners, but some of these performances will give you the shivers (in a good way). Click to enlarge.

(Credit: Concert.tv)

If your adult responsibilities take priority over a night spent developing acute tinnitus and a hangover, don't fret. Legions of concertgoers will drink beer and sacrifice their hearing on your behalf and at some point in the show, many of them will raise their cameras and mobile phones in the air and snap a keepsake video to share online.

Most established acts (notably Prince) resent the new concert self-publishing pastime, but up-and-coming acts tend to embrace the opportunity for exposure.

To find these clips, you can turn to Concert.tv, one of the better catchall concert video Web sites, with a wide selection of content spanning many genres. Or, you can subscribe to video podcasts such as The Interface or Blogotheque's Take Away Shows and have new concerts automatically load onto your iPod every few weeks.

Music discovery technique No. 5: Blogs

Recommended: Hype Machine
Also see: Mog, Pitchfork

Screenshot of Hype Machine.

Hype Machine scrapes the Internet's music blogs for hot new content and includes streaming audio previews.

(Credit: Hype Machine)

Despite Elvis Costello's claim that "Writing about music is like dancing about architecture," online music blogs have given way to an explosion of compelling music reviews. Today's online music writers can even embed music clips (often full songs) in their reviews to help get their point across.

I've listed this music blog technique last because I know that reading music reviews sounds tedious. However, for those of you who already religiously check your newsfeeds in the morning, adding a few music blogs to your list is a painless way to keep new artists on your radar and new music in your headphones.

In particular, Hype Machine tops our list of online music blogs because it aggregates the best work of many smaller music blogs and emphasizes hearing new music as much as reading about it.


Music discovery techniques No. 6 to 100...

I've listed the best five ways I know of to discover new music these days, but I know there must be others out there. I hope you'll fill me in by sounding off in the comments section and telling me what else has worked for you and what hasn't.

Donald Bell is CNET Reviews' senior editor for MP3 players and portable audio, and one half of the MP3 Insider blog and weekly podcast. He also likes getting his hands dirty with digital audio tools for musicians and DJs.
Recent posts from MP3 Insider
Sharetones: Make a ton of ringtones on Android
MP3 Insider 152: X, Zii, and why?
Get a 16GB Creative Zen Mozaic for just $110
Creative Zii touch-screen player outed by FCC
Walkman versus the rest--Ask the Editors
Update: Sony addresses W-Series Walkman sweat-resistance concerns
Prizefight: iPod Touch vs. Samsung P3
MP3 Insider 151: Bluetooth madness
Add a Comment (Log in or register) Showing 1 of 2 pages (29 Comments)
by jarkoet August 12, 2008 5:20 AM PDT
I use Wikipedia, I just enter an artist I like and you can usually find artists music that they will be featured on or will be releasing in the very recent future. Then all you have to do is what for Itunes to carry the song. Its abit more research but I usually know singles several weeks before they are released.
Reply to this comment
by drewmcd621 August 12, 2008 8:02 AM PDT
Skreemr.com is a great site that searches blogs for posted music
Reply to this comment
by Riggs3001 August 12, 2008 8:15 AM PDT
Admittedly the point of this story appears to be for the shilling of internet services. If you want to actually get connected to good music you need but to go listen to the Internet feed for KEXP! It's recommended by astronauts.
Reply to this comment
by talker29 August 12, 2008 8:17 AM PDT
I've been going to albums I like on amazon.com, them scrolling down to the "you might also like..." section, I've found some good stuff this way
Reply to this comment
by sablespecter August 12, 2008 10:16 AM PDT
RE: "We swear, there's no reading required to expand your musical horizons these days."

But reading is still one of the very best ways to expand your musical horizons. I know you didn't say it's not, but that's how old school I am: I actually *do* read about artists and music, and I mean beyond the blogs and music mags. (In fact, I probably read more about that than any other topic.) I think it's part of what they used to (still?) call "music appreciation" and I think that's apt.

I know it's hard to find time but I consider it an investment with a great return. The list of artists that I've gotten into because I read a guide to their music or a biography or even an extended feature in a long-format rock magazine like MOJO is a long list indeed. Including bands that I was once short-sighted enough to think were lame just based on listens to the couple of songs that *lame radio* stations keep in their shortlists or the "hits" that invariably bubble to the top of "recent plays" lists on the social sites.

If that return isn't rewarding enough, you can then "re-invest" your dividends by also making your reading about music a social activity through tagging/reviewing/recommending what you've read via book tagging sites like LibraryThing. When you do, you can then discover other good reads that like-minded readers have discovered. (My collection is on there under the same "sablespecter" profile name.)
Reply to this comment
by smitty2324 August 12, 2008 10:33 AM PDT
emusic.com. Best subscription site out there. You can download 50+ songs a month for $15. It also has decent social interaction where you can rate bands and people who like similar music will offer suggestions.
Reply to this comment
by ace10134 August 12, 2008 6:33 PM PDT
Zune Social and Zune Marketplace

With the Social, I can just look at what my friends listen to and then download those songs if i like them, and because I have the Zune Pass, I get them all for $15 a month.

And with the Zune Marketplace, you can go to an artist's page, and then look at related artists, who the artist was influenced by, and the top listeners of the artists. I've found many new bands by doing this.

Zune and Microsoft has mastered the art of music discovery
Reply to this comment
by jskrenes August 12, 2008 8:59 PM PDT
Not sure if the regular rhapsody has this, but Verizon's VCAST w/rhapsody has a deal where you can enter in your favorite artists and it creates a virtual radio station for you. That and the fact I sell VZW phones is making me think of changing my zune subscription to VCAST w/rhapsody.

Also, this link from crave http://news.cnet.com/8301-17938_105-9991977-1.html has instructions on how to strip your songs from their DRM restrictions, and using audacity works for subscription stuff.
Reply to this comment
by gabevidal August 13, 2008 3:30 AM PDT
There's also the concert site sonicliving.com

You tell it who you want to see and it tells you when they're playing - it works with iTunes, Last.fm and Pandora (a couple of the top picks for finding music).
Reply to this comment
by spork27 August 13, 2008 6:07 AM PDT
I use Last.fm. I type in an artist that I like and then if you gives you kind of a cloud list of genres that that artist fits in. From there I pick one of the genres and look at the top artists for that genre. Pick one of the artists, check out some of there songs, pick a genre from the cloud list, and so forth and so on...
Reply to this comment
by twister141 August 13, 2008 8:45 AM PDT
I've been using JANGO.COM for years and I love it! The problem with Pandora is the limited number of skips you can do, where Jango is unlimited. That's important to me because I am really picky about my music.
Reply to this comment
by ajharbison August 14, 2008 9:44 AM PDT
A shameless plug.... I author a blog called The Listening Blog (http://www.thelisteningblog.com) that fits neatly into your category #5. I have a college degree in music composition, but I'm interested in all kinds of music--art music, popular music, theatre, film, etc.--and I write about all of these on the blog. I try to include clips and full songs whenever possible, and I've made extensive use of Last.fm and iLike in the past. If anyone is interested you're more than welcome to check it out:

http://www.thelisteningblog.com
Reply to this comment
by officelover August 14, 2008 10:13 AM PDT
When I watch a movie with a soundtrack that I like, I look up the soundtrack (if commercially available), and make note of the artists.
Reply to this comment
by shredbobted August 14, 2008 11:09 AM PDT
XM radio. Yes, like most good stuff, you have to pay for it. The benefit is, there aren't any commercials on most of the channels, and shows like Bob Dylan's Theme Time Radio Hour, Tom Petty's Buried Treasure, and Marty Stuart's American Odyssey are not only entertaining, they have introduced me to music I never would have thought of listening to. Granted, some of it is old, not new, but a lot of new music ain't any good anyway. And while my friends may think they're music experts, Tom, Bob, and Marty actually have the qualifications and diverse musical taste to send me in new, yummy directions. For example, I heard Atmosphere's "Sunshine" for the first time on American Odyssey; a great hip-hop band I never would have known about, and a great song, from a show that mostly concentrates on country. I highly suggest XM station #2. I rarely listen to a show without hearing something I want to buy.
Reply to this comment
by Wesinpdx August 14, 2008 12:01 PM PDT
I have never found finding music difficult. Go to an independent record store and listen to what they play. Oh, that involves taking time to pay attention, I know, but most record store people know enough about music to help you out. Also read some music magazines and reviews. And go to some shows. You know like you did when you were young. Americans have more free time than they know what to do with and make everything seem a heck of a lot more difficult than it needs to be. Music is entertainment, fer chrissakes. Entertain yourself. All this personalized radio and internet nonsense is screwing up the whole joy of discovery.
Reply to this comment
by jrae656 August 14, 2008 1:05 PM PDT
I like getting new ideas from the net as much as the next person, but I still find the good old fashioned way of going to concerts the best. Over the past couple of years, I've gotten free tickets for several shows, or picked up others for $15-20, for dozens of bands I have never heard of before. And I would say 75% of the bands I've heard I've really liked, some of which I've gone back to see since. If you are lucky enough to have cheaper venues, or get free tickets, it's definitely the way to go. Or tag along with a friend when they go see their faves. There's nothing like hearing a band live to really see who's great and who's not.
Reply to this comment
by RoscoMontoya August 14, 2008 1:15 PM PDT
I know it may be a little shameful to say, but I usually find new music on youtube, actually, that's how I discovered Nightwish, and they've now become my favorite band.
Reply to this comment
by yummyshark August 14, 2008 1:28 PM PDT
With the style of music I love (death metal), I've found I have to 'discover' it by an means possible, because these bands are typcially a) not from the U.S. b) do not get radio play c) do not tour, and d) are not for sale at a retail store. It's hard to even know what's out there! Therefore, I network by seeking out death metal websites, reading on the internet about the bands, who they used to play with, who they signed with, etc. and then I load all these artists and band names into Pandora. I LOVE PANDORA! Then if I find an artist I really like, I've gone to Amazon and bought used CDs for cheap so I can hear the rest of the tunes on a CD that Pandora didn't play. Basically, I do a running combination of the author's suggestions. I've had great success.
Reply to this comment
by oldgreycat August 15, 2008 1:03 PM PDT
Amazon's recommendations. They do a good job of introducing me to new music, such as Adele or Duffy, and new-to-me music, such as Peggy Lee.
Reply to this comment
by soundman45 August 17, 2008 7:16 AM PDT
Looking for good music ? Try searching the 500 greatest albums of all time, according to Rolling Stone magazine. You can't go wrong !
Reply to this comment
by xapdal August 18, 2008 1:48 AM PDT
yah i tried that but it really screws up itunes
Showing 1 of 2 pages (29 Comments)
Subscribe to the MP3 Insider podcast

Subscribe to the audio podcast via RSS
Subscribe to the video podcast via RSS

Subscribe to the audio podcast via iTunes
Subscribe to the video podcast via iTunes

advertisement

About MP3 Insider

MP3 Insider is a blog and weekly podcast created by CNET's MP3 technology experts, Donald Bell and Jasmine France. Each week, Jasmine and Donald discuss the latest digital music (and video) news, hardware, software, and media services, and address reader calls and e-mail. Send us e-mail at mp3insider@cnet.com or call us at 1-800-720-CNET (2638) and be a part of the show.

View all MP3 Insider podcast episode blog entries

Add this feed to your online news reader

MP3 Insider topics

More on MP3 Insider
MP3 Insider live stream (Tuesdays, 11:30AM PST)
CNET Reviews: MP3 players and PVPs
Music posts at Crave blog
Music downloads at Download.com
Audio and video software at Download.com
Donald's Zune Social profile
Donald's Last.FM profile
The hosts of MP3 Insider
Donald Bell Donald Bell is an electronic musician, a veteran record store employee, and a fearless hardware hacker. He's also CNET's Senior Editor for MP3 and digital audio.
Jasmine France Jasmine France is CNET's resident digital audio doyenne, writing and editing product reviews, crave blogs, and feature stories on all things MP3. And if you need advice on headphones, she's your girl.

Latest posts from Crave

MP3 Insider Weekly/newsletter
MP3 Insider Weekly Delivered on Wednesdays. Brings you the latest reviews and tips in the world of digital music. view all CNET newsletters
Podroll
Here are a few of our favorite podcasts elsewhere in the universe.
XLR8R TV
Stones Throw
Mad Decent Worldwide Radio
Better Propaganda
Music Sessions from Studio C
Other CNET podcasts