• On The Insider: Judge Bans Real Housewives Sex Tape
June 25, 2008 3:20 PM PDT

Best MP3 players for podcasts

by Jasmine France

Obviously, an MP3 player's foremost purpose is music playback, but these days people are using their devices for much more than just that. You can view photos, watch videos, even play games in some cases. But perhaps one of the most popular side dishes people like to enjoy is podcasts--heck, it's the main dish for some. Podcasts are great for many reasons, not the least of which is the fact that they're free. Plus, you can count on finding someone talking about just about any topic known to man, so there's something for everyone. Of course, not every MP3 player handles podcasts equally, which is why I've rounded up some of the best options for you here. The criteria? At the very least have a separate menu sort dedicated to podcasts and some decent software available for managing them. Advanced features include bookmarking capability (whether active or passive), accelerated fast forwarding, and the ability to delete podcasts on the fly once you're done listening.

    (Credit: CNET Networks)
  1. Microsoft Zune: A fantastic podcast option, the Zune even ekes past the iPod for the top spot. The software is excellent for podcasts: You can manage how many episodes you want to sync to your device on a subscription-by-subscription level, meaning you can update three episodes of Buzz Out Loud, but only one of MP3 Insider and so on. You can also unsubscribe from podcasts directly from the player, and there's an option to wirelessly sync new podcasts when you charge your player at night. The Zune also offers accelerated fast forwarding and passive bookmarking to automatically remember your spot in each podcast.
  2. (Credit: CNET Networks)
  3. Apple iPod Touch: Ah, the forerunner. iTunes gets a lot of credit here: It's a great program for managing podcasts, aside from some minor quibbles (automatically unsubscribing you after several missed downloads, for example). The iPod also offers passive bookmarking, and the Touch is great for video podcasts, which you can delete immediately after watching.
  4. (Credit: CNET Networks)
  5. Creative Zen: Creative has gotten better with podcast support over the years. The ZenCast software is solid for podcast management, and the Zen has a separate podcast sort in the menus, though you must drill down into genre to find it. The player features active bookmarking, which you can place in various spots in the same podcast (if desired)--it remembers these spots even after syncing. You can also delete tracks on the fly and fast forward and rewind with acceleration.
  6. (Credit: CNET Networks)
  7. Cowon D2: This player is pretty unique in the way it manages podcasts. The D2 comes loaded with PodcastReady's MyPodder software, which runs directly from the device itself. Every time you plug the player into your computer, podcasts are updated based on your specified settings, of which there are many. I think that's pretty neat: lots of customization and no app cluttering up your hard drive. The D2 also offers variable playback speeds, so you can listen to podcasts faster or slower than normal.
  8. (Credit: CNET Networks)
  9. SanDisk Sansa Fuze: The Fuze doesn't come with its own podcast software, but it, too, will work with MyPodder. There's a dedicated podcast section in the music menu, accelerated fast forwarding, and passive bookmarking. Like the D2, the Fuze offers a variety of playback speeds: slow, normal, or fast. You can also delete files on the fly.
  10. (Credit: CNET Networks)
  11. Ibiza Rhapsody: The Ibiza Rhapsody might be the coolest of the bunch for some users. You don't even need a computer to update your podcasts: You can do it directly on the player anywhere you have an available Wi-Fi connection.

For a side-by-side comparison of the products, please click here.

For more than five years, Jasmine France has covered a variety of tech products for CNET--from scanners to keyboards to GPS devices--but she's happiest where she is now: sitting atop a pile of MP3 players, "testing" every music service known to man, and jamming a variety of earbuds in every shape and color into her absurdly small ears. E-mail Jasmine.
Recent posts from MP3 Insider
Sharetones: Make a ton of ringtones on Android
MP3 Insider 152: X, Zii, and why?
Get a 16GB Creative Zen Mozaic for just $110
Creative Zii touch-screen player outed by FCC
Walkman versus the rest--Ask the Editors
Update: Sony addresses W-Series Walkman sweat-resistance concerns
Prizefight: iPod Touch vs. Samsung P3
MP3 Insider 151: Bluetooth madness
Add a Comment (Log in or register) (19 Comments)
  • prev
  • 1
  • next
by rufustel June 25, 2008 3:47 PM PDT
And guess what, Jasmine--the SanDisk Sansa Clip, that tiny wonder, has the same podcast capabilities as its bigger sibling the Sansa Fuze. Fantastic!
Reply to this comment
by patchman10 June 25, 2008 3:48 PM PDT
I totally agree with Zune at the #1 spot for Podcasts...I have found it awesome for podcasts. I subscribe to about 20 different ones and what i find very useful that you did not mention is that it further divides podcast into Video\Audio podcasts.
Reply to this comment
by NPGMBR June 26, 2008 6:17 AM PDT
You subscribe to 20. I can hardly handle two. Check Zune Arts, thats a neat little Zune specific podcast.
by etrader83 June 26, 2008 7:36 AM PDT
I have a question:

How is the iPhone in terms of handling Podcasts?

Does it offer automatic wireless (either on the cell data network or through wi-fi) updates of podcast episodes?
Reply to this comment
by noblesun June 26, 2008 11:12 AM PDT
You have to use the iTunes software on your computer to sync Podcasts with the iPhone. You can't delete Podcasts on the fly like you can with the Touch either but the presentation is still pretty nice on the iPhone.
by trisor July 3, 2008 7:50 AM PDT
You need to manage your podcasts through iTunes with the iPhone - can't update wirelessly.
by GT1Boy June 26, 2008 8:08 AM PDT
Don't forget the Sony PSP. No PC is needed to download audio/video pocasts via WiFi with its built-in RSS feed aggregator or web browser.

I have been using my PSP for listening to podcasts on my daily 2 1/2 hour roundtrip commute for the last 3 years. My only complaints are that Sony hasn't added bookmarking and 640x480 mp4 video support. However the PSP does remember where you stopped in the last audio and video file you played even when it is turned off.
Reply to this comment
by kikeda June 26, 2008 12:25 PM PDT
I have a zune and I like it, but all the video podcasts seem to be formatted for the ipod or other mp4 players. To sync a video podcast on the zune takes forever. Not sure how it became #1 because of that. see how long it takes to get a copy of a video onto the zune, ok if letting it sit overnight, but to do it while trying to go out the door...
Reply to this comment
by Jasmineflower June 26, 2008 3:01 PM PDT
Definitely see your point, and I should have been more specific. I elected to focus on audio podcasts only for this particular story, because the players that handle audio podcasts well don't necessarily handle video podcasts well and vice versa. So it's difficult to have a catch-all story for both. We're planning a separate feature that focuses on devices that are best for free video content, including vodcasts. Stay tuned!
by wallm June 26, 2008 2:54 PM PDT
hmm like I told Jason, if it is so #1, why don't you have a zune podcast button like the ipod, i cant tell you what a pain it is to copy a url when you have google reader automatically take ALL rss feeds, ands i cant get a link to copy and paste into zune software.

so if its #1.
a zune button!!! or at least a url box to copy.
Reply to this comment
by VAHitokiri July 1, 2008 9:31 PM PDT
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16855102050

it's a creative zen in red!
Reply to this comment
by trisor July 3, 2008 8:14 AM PDT
The Zune is No 1 because Jasmine doesn't like the Click Wheel
Reply to this comment
by Jasmineflower July 3, 2008 11:50 AM PDT
Actually, the Click Wheel had no weighting in this feature. The Zune edged out the iPod for one reason: the software lets you select updates on a subscription-by-subscription basis, rather than forcing you to get the same number of every selected subscription. I can get the 3 most recent episodes of This American Life, one of MP3 Insider, and 5 of Coffee Break Spanish, for example. It was still a narrow "win," though.
by amanning July 10, 2008 3:50 PM PDT
W960i phone is excellent for podcasts. I listen to lots of podcasts. I had the Creative Zen V plus which was very good, but didn't store the bookmark per track (you could have a list of 10 book marked tracks). I've had other mp3 players, various iRivers etc but none has been quite right for podcasts. Until now. I've been won over by my W960i phone. The touch screen is slow and it helps if you have small fingers. However, for podcasts it is brilliant. I can save a bookmark for any track. Can build play lists, see recent additions, delete tracks after listening... and the inbuilt speaker is pretty good so I can listen to podcasts without having earphones at home... Oh and the music quality on this phone (yes it makes calls) is the first phone that has meant that I leave my mp3 player at home. It would be nice to have more than 8gb of onboard storage simply because of some of a few videos and photos that end up taking up space. (SInce a lot of podcats don;t have the tags on them that I want, I download podcasts, use mp3tag ot bulk edit tags and then drag and drop to the phone).
Reply to this comment
by amanning July 10, 2008 3:50 PM PDT
W960i phone is excellent for podcasts. I listen to lots of podcasts. I had the Creative Zen V plus which was very good, but didn't store the bookmark per track (you could have a list of 10 book marked tracks). I've had other mp3 players, various iRivers etc but none has been quite right for podcasts. Until now. I've been won over by my W960i phone. The touch screen is slow and it helps if you have small fingers. However, for podcasts it is brilliant. I can save a bookmark for any track. Can build play lists, see recent additions, delete tracks after listening... and the inbuilt speaker is pretty good so I can listen to podcasts without having earphones at home... Oh and the music quality on this phone (yes it makes calls) is the first phone that has meant that I leave my mp3 player at home. It would be nice to have more than 8gb of onboard storage simply because of some of a few videos and photos that end up taking up space. (SInce a lot of podcats don;t have the tags on them that I want, I download podcasts, use mp3tag ot bulk edit tags and then drag and drop to the phone).
Reply to this comment
by mondolmk July 18, 2008 7:49 AM PDT
Jasmine:

Thanks for doing this roundup; I believe that podcast specific mp3 players will be a strong market in the coming years, but this is the first review addressing this market I have found.

I am still using an old iriver (ifp-890) because the other players I have looked at didn't meet my needs any better, I am looking for: multiple bookmarks, erase on the fly, replaceable batteries, non-linear fast forward/reverse, small size, adequate volume and most of all a reasonable user interface. I am willing to drop one or more of these criteria for a good player, most likely the replaceable battery aspect. For my needs-BBC,CBC,NPR , CNET and other spoken word podcasts- 4 GB of memory probably represents well over 100 hours of storage, so the size of the memory is hardly an issue these days.

I look forward to trying out the Fuze or Clip. If the Zune wasn't a Microsoft product and smaller it would be great. Itunes software is so slow and such a hog of CPU cycles I would love to avoid the ipod. The Creative Zen is just too much money for something I wear around my neck 3-4 hours a day. The price and size of the Cowan D2 surprised me so I might try that.
Reply to this comment
by quikboy2 July 25, 2008 9:40 PM PDT
"If the Zune wasn't a Microsoft product and smaller it would be great."

So being made by Microsoft already makes it a fail for you? Wow. Microsoft made Zune, so I don't see how it can't be a MS product. You can't undo that.

And the 4GB and 8GB are already pretty small in my opinion. Don't forget that they have bigger screens than most players of that size and storage.

Have you even used a Zune?
by quikboy2 July 25, 2008 9:28 PM PDT
The Zune is definitely great for podcasting! I love the fast-forwarding feature when it gets too boring. Just my opinion, but I think the Zune software is more smoother to use, than iTunes for managing podcasts.
Reply to this comment
by November 16, 2008 1:14 PM PST
I use a Nokia N800 and the gpodder app. Haven't seen a solution for me any better than this (wlan, audio, ogg, video, etc). They don't make the N800 anymore, have a newer N810. I'm waiting until wimax is available before I buy my next device.
Reply to this comment
(19 Comments)
  • prev
  • 1
  • next
Subscribe to the MP3 Insider podcast

Subscribe to the audio podcast via RSS
Subscribe to the video podcast via RSS

Subscribe to the audio podcast via iTunes
Subscribe to the video podcast via iTunes

advertisement

About MP3 Insider

MP3 Insider is a blog and weekly podcast created by CNET's MP3 technology experts, Donald Bell and Jasmine France. Each week, Jasmine and Donald discuss the latest digital music (and video) news, hardware, software, and media services, and address reader calls and e-mail. Send us e-mail at mp3insider@cnet.com or call us at 1-800-720-CNET (2638) and be a part of the show.

View all MP3 Insider podcast episode blog entries

Add this feed to your online news reader

MP3 Insider topics

More on MP3 Insider
MP3 Insider live stream (Tuesdays, 11:30AM PST)
CNET Reviews: MP3 players and PVPs
Music posts at Crave blog
Music downloads at Download.com
Audio and video software at Download.com
Donald's Zune Social profile
Donald's Last.FM profile
The hosts of MP3 Insider
Donald Bell Donald Bell is an electronic musician, a veteran record store employee, and a fearless hardware hacker. He's also CNET's Senior Editor for MP3 and digital audio.
Jasmine France Jasmine France is CNET's resident digital audio doyenne, writing and editing product reviews, crave blogs, and feature stories on all things MP3. And if you need advice on headphones, she's your girl.

Latest posts from Crave

MP3 Insider Weekly/newsletter
MP3 Insider Weekly Delivered on Wednesdays. Brings you the latest reviews and tips in the world of digital music. view all CNET newsletters
Podroll
Here are a few of our favorite podcasts elsewhere in the universe.
XLR8R TV
Stones Throw
Mad Decent Worldwide Radio
Better Propaganda
Music Sessions from Studio C
Other CNET podcasts