More on iDVD 4.0.1 audio problems
Continuing our coverage of a problem with iDVD 4.0.1's slide show audio accompaniment where there is a slight pause when a transition is used between photos, it now appears even more likely that the problem is relegated to certain DVD drive models.
Carmen Kubo writes "I am experiencing the same audio problem with slide show using iDVD 4.01. I have the following drive: PIONEER DVD-RW DVR-104 [Ed.- this is the same Pioneer drive used in some PowerMac G4 and G4 iMac models.]
Roland G writes "I have the iDVD slide show audio problem on my KLH-8350 DVD player. This player has no other issues with any DVD I've thrown at it, an otherwise very reliable player."
Another reader: "On an Apex DVD player there's audio gaps during sideshows, so if you're playing music, it's very annoying; but on an Electrohome EH-8181a, the playback audio is fine, but then as each slide goes by, the photo stills 'jumps' one by one very slightly. On other players, neither of these glitches show up.
And another "My DVD player is a Memorex. It is a model that handles all media, such as CD-R, CD-RW, MP3 CD and the like. I will have to try another player."
Meanwhile, Paul Purves reports another audio issue with his PowerBook's built-in SuperDrive:
"I am using a Aluminum Powerbook 1.25 GHz, OS 10.3.3, iLife'04, internal Superdrive. After creating an iMovie project, with video clips at the front and a slide show at the end, I created an iDVD project by hitting the iDVD button within iMovie. All played perfectly in iMovie BUT THEN I burned the DVD.
"When I played my DVD on my DVD player to my TV, the Audio was actually ahead of the video by a half a second or so."
Resources
chapter transitions. In order to make the slide show "interactive" (that is,
allowing the viewer to move backward/forward with the arrows on their
remote) each picture is rendered as it's own chapter. This is true even IF you
deselect the arrows to be displayed on the bottom of the screen.
Unfortunately, 90% of the DVD players these days are mishandling chapters,
and the photo slideshows end up looking, and sounding horrible. This makes
iDVD's photo slideshows an unlucky bet. The only safe solution is to avoid
using sound entirely!
Apple should offer the option in iDVD to render the slideshow as one long
complete movie (of course, at the expense of viewer interaction.) At least
then the finished product will have a fighting chance of working in the
majority of DVD players out there.