• On TechRepublic: 10 cool USB flash drive tricks
advertisement
July 14, 2008 12:00 AM PDT

Dozens of accessories don't work with the iPhone 3G

by Ben Wilson
  • Font size
  • Print
  • 9 comments

A huge swath of accessories that were compatible with the first-generation are not compatible with the iPhone 3G, either failing to charge the device or losing functionality completely.

iPhone Atlas reader Carson's case is exemplary:

"I upgraded form the first generation iPhone to the 3G iPhone and noticed that it does not work with all my accessories.

  • Doesn't work with the iPod AUX connector in my car, a $350 adaptor
  • Doesn't work with the Monster Cable FM tuner
  • Doesn't work with the cigarette power adaptor

Charging The most common problem is one in which various accessories fail to charge the iPhone 3G. The explanation for this issue is as follows: most accessories on the market charge iPods/iPhones through either USB or a 12V connection that works through the FireWire portion of the pin connector. The latter method is cheaper, and hence more common. Apple has removed 12V (FireWire) charging from the iPhone 3G; this means that these devices are no longer able to deliver a charge. As such, some accessories will still perform their intended function, but fail to charge the iPhone.

Audio/video connectivity The iPhone 3G is also not capable of pushing audio through some previously compatible devices. This is apparently because of a new sensing mechanism that obviates functionality of non-compliant devices.

Incopmatible or partially incompatible (unable to charge) devices include:

  • Monster FM tuner
  • Monster car charger
  • BOSE SoundDock
  • Dension ICE
  • OEM iPod Connection Kit for several cars (Mazda 3, Scion XB, Audi)
  • Sony XA-110IP iPod Interface Adapter

If you've experienced incompatibility with a specific accessory, please let us know.

Recent posts from iPhone Atlas
Motorola, RIM leading, with Apple on the rise
Tales2Go: Get on-demand audiobooks for children
iCatchall: 27 apps for free--Monday only
Caps lock--David's iPhone tip of the week
HouseKeeper app reminds you to do forgotten chores
App Genie: 27 apps for 99 cents
Apple extends iTunes Web previews to apps
Possible proof surfaces that iPad supports a camera
Add a Comment (Log in or register) (9 Comments)
  • prev
  • next
by da_bombdiggidy July 14, 2008 11:39 AM PDT
I tried on the iPod HiFi by Apple and it wouldn't charge. I also tried buying a Belkin car charger and it didn't work either. This is really frustrating. So is this a complete hardware issue or can a fix be done through firmware?

Small note too: my dock connecter cable that came with my iPhone was extremely tight and hardly fit inside. Be nice to use other power options. Luckily my video iPod cable works fine.
Reply to this comment
by shetaan819 July 14, 2008 1:46 PM PDT
Just fyi, the Altec Lansing iMotion speakers do work with the new 3G iPhone....i can't believe Monster is on that list, with the outrageous prices they charge there shouldn't be anything cheap about their charging products.
Reply to this comment
by jhersco July 14, 2008 2:20 PM PDT
This quote from the Griffin Technology website claims exactly the opposite regarding USB vs. Firewire charging: "The 3rd Generation iPods are only compatible with FireWire chargers, such as the Griffin PowerPod. The PowerJolt is a USB charger, and is compatible with most USB charging MP3 players and devices." Confused. I am.
Reply to this comment
by jhersco July 14, 2008 2:23 PM PDT
Sorry for the above post. The quote was for iPods, not iPhones. I missed that completely. You cansafely ignore the comment.
jhersco
Reply to this comment
by neonmarg_dotmac July 15, 2008 5:49 AM PDT
The Belkin Auto Kit for iPod w/ Dock Connector that has the handy audio jack in the lighter plug does not work. Not thrilled, as I have in both cars and they were $40 each... and worse I have not found any replacement currently available. Old iPhone worked fine with this cable.
Reply to this comment
by mm0001 July 15, 2008 6:42 AM PDT
@da_bombdiggidy

You said the iPhone 3G doesnt charge with the Apple Hifi, but does it play music or not?

As i have a Apple Hifi and i am planing to buy a iPhone 3g this would be very interesting for me.

By the way, it is an hardware issue and can?t be fixed by the firmware. Apple has changed the pins of the Dock Connector a little.
Reply to this comment
by rickkarrer_dotmac July 16, 2008 4:24 AM PDT
I have the iLuv i202 wireless bluetooth headset [http://www.i-luv.com/iLuv/product_info.php?cPath=74&products_id=303]. I can hear people and music perfectly, but for some reason they can't hear me. The headset works with my old Razr with no problem so I know they're not defective. The i202 supports the original iPhone. I'm sending them an email today to see if they know about this issue.
Reply to this comment
by mediavein November 24, 2008 2:42 AM PST
Hi, Does anyone know if there is some form of adaptor on the market to connect the Iphone 3g to older devices?

Or any DIY versions?

Thanks
Reply to this comment
by mdapena February 6, 2009 1:35 PM PST
Just purchased a 3G and the belkin audio wire that connects to my car auxiliary jack works but the sound is horrible... I took the car to the dealer and they said it is the wire. What is the best audio wire to use withe the 3G to push sound out to a stereo system?
Reply to this comment
(9 Comments)
  • prev
  • next

Search iPhone Atlas

advertisement

About iPhone Atlas

iPhone Atlas helps you navigate the ins and outs of Apple iPhone ownership with how-tos, troubleshooting information, news, reviews, and more. Got a tip? Want to contact us? E-mail iphoneatlas@cnet.com.

Add this feed to your online news reader

iPhone Atlas topics