• On TechRepublic: Five super-secret features in Windows 7
advertisement
March 27, 2009 10:20 AM PDT

A very early review of iPhone OS 3.0

by Kent German

Cut, copy and paste is an easy task.

For the past week, I've been able to play with the beta version on the new iPhone OS 3.0. As you probably know, the 3.0 update brings a long list of features to the iPhone including multimedia messaging, cut and paste and a landscape keyboard. As I said last week, iPhone 3.0 has more many more hits than misses, particularly since it finally adds some very basic features that almost every other cell phone has.

Since this is a beta version, I'm not going to get hung up on the obvious bugs. Yes, my iPhone is much slower, and it has a tendency to crash more often, but such problems are to be expected on an OS that's not quite ready for the real world. Instead, I will tell you about my general experience form a usability standpoint.

Cut, cop and paste This is just as Apple execs described at the OS 3.0 announcement. Just double tap a selection to get the cut/copy/paste commands to appear. You then can change the highlighted area by dragging the blue "grab points" around the page. Once you get to your pasting area, just tap the screen again and select the "paste" button. I like the "shake to undo" option, as well. There's just one caveat: at present it seems to be working for notes only.

Landscape keyboard This is one of those "careful what you wish for" situations. After haranguing Apple over the past twenty months to give us a landscape keyboard for texting, notes and e-mail, I have to admit that it does take some acclimation now that I have it. Though the landscape keyboard is much wider with larger buttons, it's also a lot shorter. It did take me a couple of days to get the hang of it. Don't think that I'm not complaining, though, as it's quite the opposite. I love being able to use two hands, but I had grown accustomed to the one finger tap dance on the vertical keyboard. On the other hand, the new ability to view my e-mail inbox in landscape mode is very welcome.

Typing on the landscape keyboard took some acclimation.

Multimedia messaging While the process is easy, I haven't been able to actually send a message to a phone number just yet. Each time I tried, the connection timed out so I assume that hasn't readied things on its end. I also wasn't able to receive an MMS without the tedious process of clicking the link to to see the image.

Like with other cell phones, you can start an MMS while in the messaging application or you can pick a photo first and then send it in a message. It's an intuitive process in either case--the photo appears in the typing area of the message application and you can delete it if you change your mind.

Text messaging Deleting and forwarding individual messages in a texting thread works just like the e-mail app. When you select the "edit" button, small dots appear next to each message. Hits the dots for your desired messages before pressing the "delete" or "forward" options.

Spotlight results are organized by category.

Spotlight Spotlight is a simple affair, as well. As you type in a search term the results appear below the search bar. What's more, the results are grouped together by category for easy navigation. Swiping to the Spotlight screen was a bit sluggish, but that should improve as the update is perfected.

Stereo Bluetooth I was very glad to see a stereo Bluetooth profile arrive with iPhone 3.0. I tested it with the LG HBS-250 stereo Bluetooth headset. The pairing process was easy and incident-free. In the music player, a small Bluetooth icon appears next to the player controls. Press it to route audio to the headset; you then can toggle back and forth between the speaker and the headset. Music quality was quite satisfactory--a big improvement over the iPhone's external speaker and on par with the standard wired headset. Of course, your experience will vary depending on which stereo headset you choose.

Camera upgrades After you take a photo, a tiny version of the shot will appear in the bottom left corner of the viewfinder. Tapping that image will take you directly to the photo viewer.

Safari In the browser, a useful upgrade makes it easier to open links. If you tap and hold on a Web link, a new menu will appear with choices to open the link, open it in another page, save an image, or copy the link.

Other additions The other new features, like the voice recording app, the shake to shuffle feature, the revamped stocks app and the forwarding of text contacts and meeting invites, worked exactly as described, which is to say they're simple and intuitive.

That's about it for now. I'll continue to play it with over the next couple of weeks and you can be assured that I'll give a full report when iPhone OS 3.0 becomes available this summer. Hopefully, I'll get to check it out on the next version of the iPhone hardware.

Kent German is a senior editor for cell phone reviews at CNET. When he's not testing the newest handsets on the market, he's blogging about cell phone news for Crave. In his On Call column, he answers reader questions and gives his take on the rapidly changing mobile industry. E-mail Kent.
Recent posts from iPhone Atlas
Official NASA app and a hovercraft racing game: iPhone apps of the week
Doom, Command & Conquer revived for iPhone
Blackra1n update adds unlock, Mac support
Why is baby crying? This app translates
RoboForm password manager for iPhone faces hurdles
ReelDirector enhances iPhone 3GS video editing
Retrieve iPhone MMS and Visual Voicemail with PhoneView
Blackra1n RC3 unlocks iPhone 3GS
Add a Comment (Log in or register) Showing 1 of 2 pages (35 Comments)
by GeneC--2008 March 27, 2009 11:28 AM PDT
All the posts regarding Spotlight show search results from several Apps but none I've seen show Calendar entries. Will it find say a Doctor's visit from a calendar appointment?
Reply to this comment
by Fil0403 March 30, 2009 7:10 AM PDT
Maybe in iPhone OS 6.0 (afterall, iPhone users must be already used to have to wait to have features that can be found on the most basic cell phones on the market today).
by libertyforall1776 March 27, 2009 11:34 AM PDT
A2DP & MMS definitely should be added by Apple to the 1st. Gen. iPhone, if not, it will be done via jailbreak. It is ridiculous that Apple is crippling the early adopters who expected functionality like this from the start. I could care less about MMS (which is available via Jailbreak even today), but A2DP should have been on iPhone since day 1.
Reply to this comment
by iroq321 March 30, 2009 9:30 AM PDT
sure, those features SHOULD have been there since day one, but at the same time, those early adopters should have researched before jumping on the bandwagon. if they REALLY wanted A2DP and MMS from the get-go, there are plenty of other phones out there with those features...just sayin'.
by santakrooz March 27, 2009 11:37 AM PDT
iphone 4.0 features are on http://www.iphonewishbook.com

lots of activity around the post-3.0 featureset
Reply to this comment
by thalassicus March 27, 2009 11:47 AM PDT
Does the Spotlight search look in the notes fields of contacts? A lot of times, I meet people and write notes to help me remember them. With the current search options (even jailbroken) there is no way to search the notes field of contacts, thus with my iphone if I can't remember their name, I'm not calling them until I get back to my computer to look them up.
Reply to this comment
by bigslamajama March 27, 2009 12:26 PM PDT
Kent,

As a senior editor shouldn't you hold your contributions to a relatively high level of grammatical correctness? Though the content is interesting and important for readers, once again we are forced to bear spelling and grammatical errors to obtain the information. Maybe I'm expecting too much from a gadget blog.


As for 3.0, has any additional way to take a picture been implemented? It is still unnecessarily difficult to take a self portrait by snaking your finger around the phone and attempting to hit the camera button.
Reply to this comment
by KentGerman March 27, 2009 1:00 PM PDT
bigslamajama -

At present there is no way to take a self-portrait. Perhaps it will be added later. My apologies for the errors, I posted a little too soon.
by dluxfresh March 27, 2009 3:34 PM PDT
There's no need to "snake your finger around the phone" to hit the camera button. The camera doesn't actually take the picture until you release your finger from the button, so, as you're looking at the camera screen, hit the button, hold your finger on it, turn the phone around and do your best from that point. It's not perfect, but it's a better way to do it.
by incargeek June 17, 2009 10:45 AM PDT
If you press and HOLD your finger on the shutter button, the camera will only take a photo when you RELEASE your finger off the button. So you can place your finger on the button first, re-orient the camera ensuring your finger doesnt leave the button. Then when you are ready, take your finger off the button. Et voila. This saves you turning the camera around and searching for the button then trying to aim your finger on that button when you cant see the button :-) Just remember to wait a half sec or a second to ensure the camera has time to register the image. Dont move the phone too soon after letting go of the button...however akward the position is! The shutter / capture delay is a bit long on the iPhone (1st gen with iPhone "pre 3.0").
by tcr071 March 27, 2009 1:11 PM PDT
The only thing that works without bugs in the new OS is copy and paste and Bluetooth.

Landscape keyboard: Buggy in MMS and buggy in e-mail. Rotates awkwardly sometimes in MMS where there are black spots at the top, sometimes doesn't orient correctly and places the actual messages that I'm trying to respond to BEHIND the keyboard, and sometimes just flat out won't show up. In email it isn't as bad but that could be because I rarely send emails on the phone just check them.

Stereo Bluetooth: Works. Not buggy.

MMS: Doesn't work. Not at all. Hangs right at the end of sending it and fails to send. Can't receive MMS either. Apparently Apple never told AT&T they were launching a beta to 50,000+ iPhones.

Camera: No quality upgrade and no timer so taking a self portrait is still ridiculously hard. The icon in the bottom left is the only thing I have noticed and it is pretty much worthless because it was already quite easy to go directly to the photo album from inside the camera app.

Safari: Easier to open links and save pictures. An option to send a picture you hold your finger down as an MMS but it doesn't work. All gains are negated by taking fifteen bagillion giant steps back in terms of stability. Crashes like clockwork.

Shake to Shuffle: Won't turn off. I am using my old Nano to jog now because I can't get my iPhone to stop changing tracks when I jog.

Spotlight: Works most of the time but some times the keyboard won't pop up and sometimes the keyboard will pop up but you can't type anything. A lot of the times swiping to it is not nearly as fluid as swiping to other pages.

One big problem: Maps application. I can understand 3rd party app instability (haven't experienced any yet) but the Maps application freezes for something along 20 when it is opened and is completely unusable. After that 20 seconds it works fine but it happens every.single.time.

It is a beta so you shouldn't be expecting everything to work like a charm but I think Apple rushed this beta out a tad too early. There is a lot of work to be done before I can recommend this to anyone.

Should be a great update in its final form.
Reply to this comment
by Ade79 March 27, 2009 2:26 PM PDT
Is there chinese zhuyin input included for traditional chinese??
Reply to this comment
by chrisrodney March 28, 2009 10:17 PM PDT
Yes there is. It's also available in the current iPhone.
by jtaylor475 March 27, 2009 2:46 PM PDT
RANT 101:

Complaining about bugs in a BETA (versus reporting or anecdotally describing your experience with them) is more than a bit cranky. And it irritates this reader.

When you get a BETA, it's a voluntary acknowledgement that bugs and mishaps WILL INDEED OCCUR. A GIVEN. ASSUMED. IT WILL HAPPEN. Why go online and whine about them? It's part of the process.
Reply to this comment
by swimmy6279 March 27, 2009 5:25 PM PDT
I'd like to see the same option to delete incoming and outgoing numbers from the phone as they are implementing with messages, where I can delete individual numbers instead of the whole list. Will this be available?
Reply to this comment
by MisterTechie March 27, 2009 9:02 PM PDT
The beta version of the 3.0 OS looks very promising - sure to give the IPhone a clear edge over the Palm Pre, though from reviews I am reading (see below), the Palm Pre features are impressive and innovative in many areas...

http://blogs.itworldcanada.com/idol/2009/03/27/palm_pre_vs_apple_iphone/
Reply to this comment
by 1812dave March 27, 2009 9:51 PM PDT
Spoken like a true Apple fanboi. You haven't even had a chance to play with a Pre yet. Don't count the Pre out until it's on the market.
by tmelsayed March 27, 2009 11:34 PM PDT
Just buy a Nokia E71 with a qwerty keyboard. I have apps on it that make the phone smoke any blackberry or an iphone:
(1) Profimail for push email with html support. You can even have email rules like the ones on your computer! Copying from emails is a breeze.
(2) Skyfire as browser with full flash support. I can watch any CNN video just like on my computer.
(3) Telmap for navigation!
(4) I tether the 3G phone by turning it into a Wifi hotspot!
(5) I have several apps running at the same time and I can copy and paste between them.
(6) Google maps with latitude.
(7) 3.2 MP camera with autofocus.
And finally, I don't have to sign a contract and don't have to go through an app store, I can install any app that is written for Symbian V3. This phone is indeed a mini-computer.
Reply to this comment
by Leland7 March 28, 2009 8:18 AM PDT
The one app that I want is the true turn by turn nav.
Leland
Reply to this comment
by tcr071 March 28, 2009 4:05 PM PDT
And you will get it. But you will be paying for it. The 3.0 OS and the 3.0 SDK gives developers access to use the GPS for turn-by-turn but we have to provide our own apps.

There are already fully built and debugged turn by turn GPS apps available but Apple will not let them on the App Store until 3.0 is officially released. Pricing is completely up in the air. There could be an up front fee to cover unlimited use or they could charge a fee each month for use. It would probably depend on each developer to decide for themselves.
by Michelle Steiner March 28, 2009 9:19 AM PDT
If copying text starts with a double tap, what happens to the existing double-tap to zoom feature?
Reply to this comment
by chrisdenton April 15, 2009 8:45 PM PDT
interesting question so i had to try it...when in safari, just tap and hold then the drop pins pop up
by igorccc March 28, 2009 11:09 AM PDT
@Kent German

There are some rumors that iphone support new audiocodec HE-AAC.
Can you confirm that?

HE-AAC is very efficient at low bitrate as 64 kbit/s http://www.listening-tests.info/mf-64-1/results.htm
Reply to this comment
by wahoo252 March 28, 2009 6:42 PM PDT
This article mentions the ability to forward meeting invites. However, sometimes I'll receive an iCal meeting invite on my iPhone (as a .ics file), but can't do anything with it. (Except download it onto my computer later, and add it to iCal that way). Just wondering if iPhone 3.0 adds the ability to accept iCal invites on the iPhone? (Or at least view them, -right now they're just a greyed-out .ics file).

Another thing I was thinking about, was that the Mac OS for many many years has had voice recognition and text-to-speech built in. Are either of these activated in iPhone 3.0? There are some 3rd party apps that have added voice recognition, but both features could be very useful system-wide. For instance, for voice dialing or giving turn-by-turn directions in GPS apps.
Reply to this comment
by FocusedOnMe March 29, 2009 10:45 AM PDT
I just wanted to know if the simple feature of deleting calls from the call log will be available to do now. I mean even the cheapest phone has the ability to delete numbers.
Reply to this comment
by chrisdenton April 15, 2009 8:48 PM PDT
yeah you would think that apple would have done that, but im on beta 3 and it still doesnt give the option only thing different is that it gives alot more details about the call like call times and such
by vikasmaurya01 March 29, 2009 10:13 PM PDT
I have come across interesting article which compiles that statistics from iPhone OS 3.0 preview .
http://iphonek.com/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=76&Itemid=69
Reply to this comment
by wahoo252 March 30, 2009 3:54 AM PDT
hi FocusedOnMe, - the ability to delete the call log has always been there. On the "Recents" screen, just press the "Clear" button at the top right. Or are you talking about deleting one call at a time? (It's all-or-none right now.)
Reply to this comment
by Fil0403 March 30, 2009 7:12 AM PDT
A mobile device that doesn't even allow you to delete individual call log entries: now that's what I call a smartphone.
by Fil0403 March 30, 2009 7:16 AM PDT
I still find it rather amazing (read sad) that the 3rd OS update to a supposedly-so-advanced so-called-smartphone adds such basic features that can be found on almost any smartphone released in the last 5 years.
Reply to this comment
by jtaylor475 March 31, 2009 2:48 PM PDT
The thing that Apple haters, and by consequence iPhone haters don't get is that it's not "how many apps," "how fast the network," "another phone also has such and such a feature" or any of those things. It's simply "how." Apple figures out a great way to do something. And everyone follows. I had a Blackberry for more than a year and never felt the desire to try and figure out how to sync to my Mac so I could have all my contacts on the phone. I still don't know if I could. When I got my iPhone, it had already been figured out for me. And everyone follows.
Reply to this comment
Showing 1 of 2 pages (35 Comments)

Search iPhone Atlas

advertisement

About iPhone Atlas

iPhone Atlas helps you navigate the ins and outs of Apple iPhone ownership with how-tos, troubleshooting information, news, reviews, and more. Got a tip? Want to contact us? E-mail iphoneatlas@cnet.com.

Add this feed to your online news reader

iPhone Atlas topics