October 23, 2009 5:00 PM PDT

Rate your Windows 7 upgrade experience

by Seth Rosenblatt
  • Font size
  • Print
  • 142 comments
Share

Last weekend we ran a casual, unscientific poll asking what your plans were for Windows 7. It closed Monday morning, but because of the overwhelming response, we decided to reopen it until today. Out of the 13,108 readers who voted, 59 percent (7,669) of you said that you were going to upgrade from Windows XP or Vista to Windows 7.

So, for those of you who are upgrading an older version of Windows to Windows 7 this weekend, we'd like you to rank your experience for us in a new poll posted below. Please share both your horror stories and your tales of easy installation in the comments. The new poll will close Monday afternoon at 5:00 p.m. Pacific time.

The remaining results from previous poll were mostly unsurprising. Fourteen percent, or 1,856 voters, said that they were planning on buying a new computer with Windows 7 already installed. Slightly more of you, 2,146 respondents (16 percent), said they had no plans to change computers or upgrade at the moment. A small but not insignificant percentage, 865 voters, said that they were going to switch to a Mac or a Linux computer.

After we reopened the poll on Monday afternoon, we added two questions by popular demand. Less than one percent of voters said they were going to switch from a Mac or Linux computer to Windows 7, while 454 people (3 percent) said that they already had a Mac or Linux computer and were planning on also using Windows 7.

What these numbers confirmed is that a majority of current Windows users will be upgrading current systems, meaning that most people not only believe that their hardware can adequately run Windows 7, but also that they can comfortably perform the upgrade themselves. However, sizable minorities will either be buying Windows 7 fresh or ignoring it entirely, while a tiny group will be using it as an excuse to abandon ship.

Seth peers into the deep, dark corners of software so that you don't have to. He has yet to suffer a single nightmare about OS/2. You can follow him on Twitter.

advertisement
Recent posts from Windows 7 Insider
Windows Starter Kit refreshed for 2010
$999 Blu-ray laptop with game:
Sony Vaio FW560F/T reviewed
Home Server Power Pack 3: It's all about Windows 7
Enable Ctrl-Alt-Del log-in window in Windows 7
New Netbooks get subsidized for the holidays: Samsung Go and Acer Aspire One go for $199 at AT&T
Windows 7: If it were my idea
Rename a virtual machine in VMware Fusion
Windows 7 use continues to climb
Add a Comment (Log in or register) Showing 1 of 5 pages (142 Comments)
by ghnata October 23, 2009 5:38 PM PDT
Mine was flawless; it is RAID 0 with three VelociRaptor drives, add-on RAID hardware controller and an Invidia 200-series video card. It is a dream machine!!!
Microsoft, keep up the good work.
Reply to this comment
by timmyg756 October 23, 2009 6:19 PM PDT
RAID 0 with 3 raptors eh? I'm calling bulls***. RAID 0 uses 2 hard drives. If using 1 for a backup you've overpaid by 80 bucks on a lesser solution. If using 3 in a RAID it's likely 0 + 1, which you don't mention. And "Invidia"? Are you serious? That may be how it's pronounced, "IN-VI-DEE-UH", but any fool who actually owned a GPU from them would damn well know the company is spelled NVIDIA.
[CNET editor's note: Personal attack deleted.]
by tommyg562000 October 23, 2009 6:31 PM PDT
RAID 0 needs at LEAST two hard drives and up to 4.
by JimmyJump October 23, 2009 7:38 PM PDT
Hey Timmy, you got so many facts right that there's a slight chance you might be talkin' bout personal experience, heh?

But serious dude, a RAID 0 array can be set up with as many drives as you like, as long as there's more than one. They don't even have to be the same size nor speed, because the array will adapt to the smallest and slowest disc in the array, meaning that bigger drives will be reduced to the size of the smallest one and use the same speed as the slowest disc.

And, by the way, what's wrong with the K-Mart in Tennessee?


JJ
by david1234banner October 25, 2009 12:49 AM PDT
Keep up the good work? Oh Please .They need to do better on the OS its a memory hog for one and you need a pretty decent machine to run properly. You have a n expensive "200series and a dream machine " toot your horn my friend nothing wrong with that its good for your ego and getting through the day in these hard economic times but what about the budget people out there that just have a machine. This compliment of windows sucks because of the resources it needs to run.
So come on M-soft do better.
by InkyRed October 25, 2009 6:32 AM PDT
My Windows 7 Ultimate signature edition I WON from houseparty.com installed perfectly easy using bootcamp on the Macbook I WON from Axe Win The SWEETLIFE Sweepstakes! Jealous much?
by varase October 26, 2009 9:34 AM PDT
Until one of those drives fail ...
by mtkotsay October 27, 2009 7:02 AM PDT
No problems installing it but it took about 7 hours. I am disappointed that I am still experiencing IE 8 Not responding issues.
by GEO2003 October 27, 2009 8:15 AM PDT
ABSOLUTELY FLAWLESS - There was not issues what so ever, all drivers for my 5 year old laptop were available for download - Video - PCMCIA wifi - audio and all the rest.
Since Dell dropped support for my laptop just a few months after Vista came out, Back then I had to look around to find an Audio and Video driver that would work with my XPS GEN 2. MS has since a long time ago aquire an Audio driver for Vista download, but that driver does not allow the Sub-Woofer in my laptop to work, so I use the old Vista driver. 1 other driver not available was for my Mouse Pad, again I blame Dell for thism, But I found one that work.
So in total, ONLY 1 DRIVER, the mouse pad driver was not available.

Therefore for me it was ot a hassle, I really like having a clean installation, so I did a clean install.

My CPU utilization is better, under Vista with a sincle CPU, Vista would take quite a few seconds to release cpu cycles when doing intensive applications. Even IE would max the cpu since I have every secion information wipe out. NOW NO ISSUES WHAT SO EVER.

Everything has been working fine, once I finish setting Windows 7 the way I like it, I created an IMAGE - I HIGHLY RECOMEND ALL TO DO THIS.

Even though I tested both Beta and RC, I am still amazed at how well a 5 year old laptop is doing.

I will be updating 5 for pc's soon belonging to my family and other for friends.

I am giving some LOV to this new operating system from Microsoft.

Geo
by tommyg562000 October 23, 2009 6:32 PM PDT
RAID 0 needs at LEAST two hard drives and up to 4.
Reply to this comment
by tommyg562000 October 23, 2009 6:44 PM PDT
Oh yeah, 3 windows 7 installations all have been amazing. Love the fluidness of win 7 and look is awesome. Some stuff is a little confusing to get to but once i use it for a while all will be well. mighty fine job Microsoft! Microsoft for life!
by nhirsch October 23, 2009 6:40 PM PDT
I upgraded three machines. All worked well. One is old HP Pavilion 7000 series laptop, another an Itronix XR-1 (i'm on this one now) and a third a ACER Aspire One NetBook. Only two issues so far is 1: the on screen display on the XR-1 doesn't show itself when I function-Fkey one of the shortcuts such as brightness up/down, volume up/down. The function works it's just I don't see the moving bar graph on the screen. Also, 2: the Omnipass fingerprint software doesn't support Windows7. The actual device driver is OK, but I need a finger print software to utilize the hardware on the XR-1.
My overall experience with using Windows 7 is very good, better than XP, smoother, faster, cooler, and more modern look. I highly recommend it. Run the Advisor, have a USB Hard Drive available and go for it if advisor doesn't have too many hiccups. Good luck!!!
Reply to this comment
by spaceyguy October 23, 2009 7:06 PM PDT
The upgrade itself is easy, the most difficult part is waiting, it took me probably around four hours if you include backing up and what not. The entire process might be difficult for some though.
Reply to this comment
by FirewaveZ October 23, 2009 7:16 PM PDT
My upgrade was incredibly long and stressful. The first time it tried to restart, I had to press the power button on my PC, and then turn it on again. Upgrade took four hours. I almost had a heart attack when the unpacking windows files got stuck at 21% for what seemed to be an eternally long time. It seemed to get stuck around 5 times during the entire upgrade process. Thankfully, it proceeded without any issues.
Reply to this comment
by thydavidcome October 24, 2009 4:57 AM PDT
You do realize when upgrade it has to move a TON of files? If you expected the upgrade process to be LESS then 4 hours you were being delusional
by jakemochas October 25, 2009 8:14 AM PDT
this is why its simply easier to clean install.... that way, it guarantees the best experience
by marcgreenberg October 26, 2009 7:33 AM PDT
Wiped my 3 year old tablet two weeks before installing windows 7. Took a little under an hour to install.
by reddog00 October 26, 2009 11:19 AM PDT
I installed upgrade 1st try through and was finshed in about an hour and-a-half then decided to do a wipe and that total reformat (1 partition at 653MB) time ended up around 4 hours. I do not see any noticeable speed differences between upgrade install or clean wipe with a fresh install. Kind of disappointed about that but overall I am very very happy with Windows 7. If you have a relatively up-to-date PC to run it I can vouch for it! It blows Vista away! As for leaner PC's I do not know. Not bad this time Microsoft.
by JimmyJump October 23, 2009 7:26 PM PDT
Did a clean Win7 Ultimate install, as I skipped Vista and still had XP-Pro running. All went smooth, except that the start-up of W7 is way slower compared to XP. Has to do with the 5 internal SATA HD's (totaling 3TB) and a 1.5TB external drive, all Seagate.
When dismounting all but the OS drive, start-up is between 25 seconds and 1 minute faster than with all drives connected, but still twice as slow as my little HP dc7600 sff, hitting the road in 25 seconds flat running on XP-Pro SP2.
Seems Win7 does a thorough system check before/while booting.
Main machine runs an E8400 core duo on an ASUS P5K-E with 4x1GB Kingston HyperX PC8500@1066MHz with an ASUS EN8800GTS 512-TOP VGA card. The HP runs on a socket775 P4@3.2Ghz with 2x2GB Kingston PC6500@667MHz and a cuddly Gigabyte GeForce 8400GS, with a 80GB &200GB Seagate SATA HD
Everything was rigged in about 2 hours. Only thing I had to backup were some firefox settings, my PST files and Photoshop/PhotoImpact profiles. All the rest is spread over different drives.
All in all, I'm pretty satisfied with Windows 7. So far, no hassles with drivers, except for my HP Scanjet 4670 vp, which refuses to work under its own sowftware. The latter isn't supported any longer by HP, so I had to hook it up to my HP dc7600...
JJ
Reply to this comment
by shadow303 October 23, 2009 8:29 PM PDT
Well, I'd love to comment on all of my upgrades but, I have yet to get my PREORDER from Best Buy, after they committed to shipping for arrival on launch day, and now we are being told we'll see it by the 27th of the month... talk about some ridiculous customer service. Their forum is full of disgruntled customers; I'll be returning my copy as soon as it arrives as I also was able to get 2 other preorders from Costco who somehow managed to coordinate their shipping arrangements beautifully to arrive on launch day. I'd be curious to see how Best Buy continues to spin this mess. The one laptop I've upgrade, I did a clean wipe of the harddrive, installed the 32 bit upgrade no problem. DIdn't even ask for qualifying product... Been using the RC for months, and I love it.
Reply to this comment
by RicksDaRuler October 25, 2009 8:11 AM PDT
Same here, if a product is to be available on the 22nd in store, why not ship it in time for me to get it on the 22nd at home? It's just sitting in a a warehouse anyway?
by Absolution2009 October 26, 2009 8:30 AM PDT
I had the same experience but luckily we got it for $49.99 each lol. I'm going to put that on my gaming rig but meanwhile I bought the full version (Mac stupid crap doesn't allow upgrade version to work with parallels).
by agriffith96 October 26, 2009 11:11 AM PDT
I pre-ordered from Best Buy too. My shipment should arrive sometime this week. I complained to BB but they said they are "happy" to inform me my order has been shipped. Tracking just showed up for it today.

Never pre-order from Best Buy.
by kcmobile October 23, 2009 10:58 PM PDT
Well,, got the upgrade version of Win 7 - Home Premium, Install was a bit over an hour or so ( 64bit version ). Did had a printer driver problem, but soon solved, by downloading the update driver for my HP printer. I didn't do the full clean installment, just upgrade ( Still works fine - all my previous programs
run, well. ) I just wish the Task bar would look stylish - not a big change there. My current PC is a
Intel Core 2 Quad Processor at 2.40 GHz with 4GB of Ram. It is much smoother and feel abit more faster, running applications ( but I don't see it on, from booting up, ( took 30 seconds ) to finish.
As long as it reliable and stable and more user friendly features to use, then I am fine with that. Changes in : Paint, Wordpad, Calculator ( which i liked ) ( Shake Shake feature, Jump lists, Cornering windows - side by side ) fun to use. They took off the 3D Flip window switcher button ( My favorite ). Now, you had to press Window button + tab, to use it ,,o...well.. Also, now you can put your Sidebar widget, anywhere on the desktop ( :
I haven't test, playing any of my games, so i don't know the performance of it, just yet. Windows 7 is using the Directx 11,, which should run much more smoother on games. I love this OS over my apple computer, running on Snow Leopard, which i don't use offten.
I did wish they're interface on Windows 7, would look more 3D " Type" - a forum of a cube interface, would be cool,,switching around. I have been using all version of windows from 3.11, 95, 98, 2000, Me, XP, and Vista, and I couldn't be happier to use this version, too. Make sure you get a good anti virus program to protected your computer ( i use Kaspersky Anti Virus 2010 ) works great, very smooth. Ok, wish you guys enjoy, using Windows 7 . " I'M A PC "
Reply to this comment
by Software_Lover October 24, 2009 12:15 AM PDT
Mine wasn't difficult at all. Then again, I'm a bit more experienced with computers than most other people.
Reply to this comment
by hakeis1 October 25, 2009 4:18 PM PDT
Oh your the only bright one out there huh? Probably not..................
by jaybonline October 24, 2009 1:55 AM PDT
I do love windows 7.. its so fast...
Reply to this comment
by HazZ_117 October 24, 2009 5:35 AM PDT
Windows 7 is brilliant, have had it since last month (not legally).
Reply to this comment
by lugnut64x October 25, 2009 9:48 AM PDT
Windows 7 Loader may I guess?
by sacapiloa October 24, 2009 5:39 AM PDT
man, i use vista and its great. no need to change for me.
Reply to this comment
by Rvermi October 25, 2009 6:31 AM PDT
Yeah! Vista is good.....but 7 is sooooooo much better!!!
by tipoo_ October 26, 2009 6:57 AM PDT
I have Vista too, and while I've had nothing but a pleasant expirience with it, I qualified for the free upgrade so I'll be nuking it anyways.

Hope Dell doesnt take forever with that shipment :-P
by CCCCnetttt October 26, 2009 7:47 AM PDT
I had Vista, no problems with it and thought it was great. But, as other posters say, Win 7 is just wonderful. There isn't one thing that stands out; just everything is more intuitive and smoother and there are many little things that just work better. Now I'm looking to upgrade the other computers in my house; there is no going back.

Upgrade adviser says my five year old laptop (now running Vista ultimate student version)) will handle Win 7 except I won't get Aero (as with Vista).
by DanHolloran October 24, 2009 10:59 AM PDT
By far the best operating system I've EVER used yet! It's if Windows XP and MAC OS X got married and had children lol.
Reply to this comment
by jakemochas October 25, 2009 8:15 AM PDT
vista was the ugly twin of the two
by dlonra78 October 24, 2009 11:56 AM PDT
Replaced original HD from my notebook and performed a clean install W7 Ultimate 64 bit. Waited for some time to open files and install to HD. Needed to connect via wired broadband to get drivers for notebook wireless b/g. After wireless drivers were installed, connected via wireless and did all necessary updates. Clean install took about 2 hours. Happy with W7, using Vista Business previously.
Reply to this comment
by DocG411 October 24, 2009 12:26 PM PDT
Buggy crappy piece of $#!t. My computer ran better on Vista. Now it crashes all the time for no apparent reason. Hopefully this can be fixed though I dread the wait times for getting CS. System is much slower than under Vista. I wish I was happy with 7 but so far not at all.
Reply to this comment
by lugnut64x October 25, 2009 9:47 AM PDT
If Vista treated you nice, upgrade. If Vista gave you fits, you should do a clean install.
by eriknokc October 24, 2009 12:27 PM PDT
I upgraded my mom's latptop from Vista to 7 and lets just say the Apple commerical was correct when the Microsoft guy said "Just trust me." The 1st time I tried to install I had to stop because I had to uninstall the manufacturer display program and driver. Then 7 would not install so I had to stop it and restart the computer. Then Vista wanted to do some updates and 7 would not install until the updates were complete. Of course, I had restart for this also. Each time the installation of 7 runs a compatibility checker and takes 10-15 minutes to complete. I finally got the installation to go through and went to bed, but this morning I woke up to the computer being turned off. I started it up and it appeared to be booting normally, but then the horrid recovered from a crash screen popped up as Windows 7 was personalizing the Media Player settings. It said that Windows recovered from a "blue screen error" and then the Media Player personalization froze. I had to manually power the computer off and restart it yet again. This time it started up and booted as normal. It seems Windows 7 still has plenty of the issues that Vista had and even the dreaded Blue Screen of Death, but they have just hidden it and made it appear nicer. The only thing that does seem to work better is the boot up and shut down. I'm so glad I paid $120 so the computer will boot up and shut down faster and still crash the same as Vista.
Reply to this comment
by thydavidcome October 25, 2009 11:14 AM PDT
1st off there is no "blue screen error" second personalizing Windows Media Player occurs after it finished installing and when you first open it.
[CNET editor's note: Personal attack deleted.]
by hakeis1 October 25, 2009 4:23 PM PDT
I think your being alittle pestamistic. Upgradeing Pc's can normally be a challenge on any system. Your amoung a small percentage that has had problems, and it is probably more to do with a single component in your PC, like a video card or bridge. Chances are you will get if running nice and your bad day will soon be behind you! Cheers............
by viper396 October 26, 2009 10:50 PM PDT
@eriknokc, as another has pointed out, the Media Player personalization doesn't happen until after the OS completed setup and you actually launch Media Player for the first time. Your story simply doesn't add up.

Looking thru your prior post history it's amazing how you've had a convienient worst case experience for all sorts of technology. You've had Dell's fail, Mac's fail, ipods fail, Slingbox failed you, even your Sirius XM service has failed you. Either you have the absolute worst luck ever or you're full of BS.
by bm09 October 24, 2009 2:00 PM PDT
I purchased Windows 7 Home premium 64 bit with the student special. I downloaded and installed W7 to a new partition. The entire process took about 1 hour. I chose not to do the upgrade because, at this point, I didn't know how W7 would work. I am dual booting currently. So far, so good. It is a bit snappier, because there is a lot less junk, but it seems to take a little longer to start up than Vista. I did have one issue with W7, when I changed the wallpaper, I got a message that Windows explorer had stopped working and needed to restart. Nothing major, but still... Networking seems a lot more user friendly. So far, I am not really impressed. It does seem better than Vista, but I don't think that really says much.
Reply to this comment
by calebstein October 24, 2009 2:03 PM PDT
I have been using the Windows 7 RC 32 bit since it was available and went up to the 64 bit RTM the day before Windows 7 came out. So the update was kind of tough because it is hard to go from 32 to 64 bit systems. I had to keep a dual OS config between 32 bit RC and 64 bit RTM until I could figure out how to preserve my programs, license keys, and settings.
Reply to this comment
by John181818 October 24, 2009 3:23 PM PDT
I installed over a Vista installation on a machine with a Q6600 processor. I had not participated in beta or downloaded a RC.

It took 1:45 and went very well. The machine definately seems a bit quicker and I have had no problems in two days.
Reply to this comment
by david1234banner October 25, 2009 12:59 AM PDT
Waite till you accumulate temp files, internet trails, data trails and other stuff that just sit there .Try leaving you machine on for a week without turning it off and doing your normal stuff you'll see the difference. The speed drop considerably and you see the real OS.That's the true test my friend the time factor try i and then you really have a comment.
by lugnut64x October 25, 2009 9:44 AM PDT
I had my 32 bit Windows 7 Ultimate on for about a month strait. It suffered no speed loss on my desktop, or my laptop. Heck with my laptop, I put it in standby everyday, so it hasn't shut down for around two weeks. Microsoft did well preventing speed loss compared to Vista.
by exactlyy October 26, 2009 2:38 AM PDT
@ david1234banner
you'll be upset to know that on my test machine, which is 4 years old, with 2 GB of SD Ram and 2400 Mhz processor, 6200 nVidia gfx Windows 7 RC1 was installed on 25 May till 23 Oct .
during that time i only turnd off my PC for once. downloaded Stargate SG1 season1-season 10 "about 30 GB"
downloaded more than 120 movie ..
and i always watch..burn and delete .
i am a gamer ..so warcraft 3 and battle for middle earth are always opend .. and since i am a designer , photoshop cs3 and illustrator cs3 are always opend also ..
and i can assure you , during that time and till i installed the retail. my windows 7 speed/performence stayed the same as the day i installed it on 25 May .
by viper396 October 27, 2009 7:59 PM PDT
@david1234banner, if people where running Windows 95/98 or XP you might have a point but neither Vista nor Win7 suffer from the stereotypical problems you assume will happen. Maybe you should actually make an effort to validate your assumptions before commenting. Ignorance is your problem.
by slubilliken31 October 24, 2009 4:26 PM PDT
I bought the 64 bit home premium with the student discount and online download. I figured 30 bucks for windows 7, might as well give it a try. Everything goes smoothly in the installation process, until its about 90% done. It is transferring files and then I get the "blue screen of death" for a few seconds, it automatically shuts down the computer, restarts and says they could not install...so then it restores vista. this has happened 5 times. called windows 7 IT support, and after two hours...all they could do was tell me to hit the install button and collect my name, phone number, and email address 8 times with 8 different people...and promise to call me back sunday morning. I have an athlon dual core processor 4850e, 2.5 ghz, 4gb ram, and 64 bit vista service pack 1 right now. DOES ANYBODY HAVE ANY IDEAS ON WHAT IS WRONG????!!!!
and all of my friends upgraded just fine, which makes me even more frustrated
Reply to this comment
by lugnut64x October 25, 2009 9:45 AM PDT
Can you give your computer model, as with what graphic cards and internal parts? More info helps.
by aussietech October 26, 2009 5:43 AM PDT
At least your student version installed :S It seems a lot of peoples, including mine, downloaded incomplete or corrupted files that wont unpack & if they do work you have to do a work around involving an ISO program you download from MS and run through command prompt. Fortunately I opted to purchase the backup media and have them send me the DVD's as it looks much better than vista, has just left a bit of a sour taste initially
by jheinikel October 26, 2009 1:36 PM PDT
You bought a 64bit OS and the 64bit installer is not compatible with your 32bit processor. Next time buy the 32bit version and you wont have a problem.
Showing 1 of 5 pages (142 Comments)
advertisement

About Windows 7 Insider

Windows 7 Insider helps you navigate the ins-and-outs of Windows 7 with how-tos, troubleshooting information, news, reviews, and more.

Add this feed to your online news reader

Windows 7 Insider topics