July 17, 2008 11:17 AM PDT

The downside of hands-free calling

Hot or not?

At first, I thought California's new hands-free calling law was a great idea. Though it's debatable whether cell phones in the car can ever be safe, I took a lot of comfort in knowing that holding your phone to your ear while driving was now illegal. True, there's no guarantee that both hands will now be on the steering wheel, but I thought my chances of being run down by a yakking driver were just a bit smaller.

But, only a few days after the law went into effect I realized that it had one unfortunate consequence: a very rapid proliferation of Bluetooth dorks. Since headset-use is now required by law, the number of people wearing their headset when they're not in the car or on the phone has exploded. The sight of these people has always made me cringe, but now it appears they're here to stay. I'm know I'm not the only one who feels this way so I encourage my fellow Californians to remember this: please remove your headset when not in use. You're not a Borg drone; it doesn't make you look important or edgy, and it's not a fashion statement. If you need a place to stash it you can always buy the LG Decoy, but otherwise your pocket or purse should suffice.

Recent posts from Cell phone accessories blog
Hang a BlackBerry from your ear
Adobe strategy: Mobile app meets Photoshop Elements, Express updates
Yahoo OneSearch finds a home on your Nokia
Quicken Beam: Your finances made cute
Windows Mobile 6.1 update released for Motorola Q9h
Add a Comment (Log in or register) 16 comments
by dajazyone July 17, 2008 12:01 PM PDT
I agree 100%.
Reply to this comment
by ontoast July 18, 2008 1:04 AM PDT
maddoodads.net agrees everyone should take out their hands-free devices when not in use, but on the other hand we love the new law our hands-free sales have gone through the roof. Thank you, California
Reply to this comment
by kristimetz74 July 18, 2008 6:11 AM PDT
Um, maybe some people just figure it's easier than putting it on and taking it back off all of the time. I think maybe you need something more important to do, if you can write multiple articles about something this incredibly shallow.

I mean, does it affect you in any way? Seriously? Live and let live, dude.
Reply to this comment View all 3 replies
by BenFlavoredCandy July 18, 2008 8:03 AM PDT
The CA law is great, but you have to wait and see how well they enforce it. I'm from NJ, who has had the law in place for a few years [http://just over a year since it became a primary offense, I think... not sure|http://just over a year since it became a primary offense, I think... not sure]. I would be willing to say that 10% of people I pass on the road are still talking on their phones. Furthermore, 90% of people I see making stupid and/or dangerous driving maneuvers are holding a phone at their ear. Check back in a year and see how effective the law is.

And I whole-heartedly agree about the Bluetooth devices.
Reply to this comment
by xtianchristian July 18, 2008 9:02 AM PDT
I never really liked the bluetooth headset but it doesn't make me cringe when I see people having it on at all times. I could care less what people are wearing. So cmon Kent, does that really really bug you???
Reply to this comment
by odessit3 July 18, 2008 10:11 AM PDT
Great article, very informative. Why does it matter, though. Do you have the same reaction to people having wires hanging from their ears? It is convenient to have the headset in you ear all the time, regardless if its bluetooth or wired. What's the point of having one if you're gonna take it off and put it on every time a phone rings, might as well not use it at all. I use mine in the car and at work, but once in a while I forget to take it off when I'm at the store or something, not to show off my tech savvyness or my cool headset, I'm just lazy. Besides, if you have a good headset, you forget you're wearing one.
Reply to this comment
by RadioJoe July 18, 2008 12:10 PM PDT
I agree with the others. We use our bluetooth headsets partially because of the convenience of having our hands free while talking on the phone (and not just because it's a driving law in some places). I've been using one for over a year and a half because I didn't want to deal with holding a phone to my ear while driving. They're convenient to have especially when you need access to a computer while on the phone. Stuffing it in your pocket is not always advisable if your headset has an around-the-ear hook because some of them can be flimsy. The hook may bend or break as you move around or sit down. I've found that out the hard way. I like the idea of the LG Decoy a lot but I'm waiting to see if there will be more like it. They're called "hands-free" for a reason. Having to take off and put on the headset often sort of defeats the purpose. I'm not saying keep your headsets on your ear all the time but we should all get used to seeing people wear them a lot more...including you, Kent! :)
Reply to this comment
by markur69 July 18, 2008 2:03 PM PDT
The other adverse consequence is people who can't be bothered to get a headset or plug it in (corded in my instance) and decide to text message while driving I have found myself doing this as its not illegal. Unintentional consequences! Love the government trying to create better drivers. I actually think this will lead to more text messaging accidents. Only way out is to ban anything but driving... No radio changing. talking. drinking coffee or eating while driving... See what a slippery slope we've created... STUPID idea!

Mark
Reply to this comment
by mindhead01 July 18, 2008 2:05 PM PDT
Get a Motorola t305 (http://reviews.cnet.com/power-protection/motorola-portable-bluetooth-car/4505-14102_7-32153165.html?tag=prod.txt.1).

I have one. It works great. The only downside is that without the earpiece you look like you are talking to yourself.
Reply to this comment
by C433Z July 18, 2008 2:58 PM PDT
This is true. My dad recently got one of the new Jawbones (for only $65 too!). But he can't stand the look of something dangling in his ear so he only uses it at home or in the car.
Reply to this comment
by pkm1967 July 18, 2008 4:38 PM PDT
I had a cell phone for one year back in 1991. I parked my car on the shoulder of the road whenever someone called me so I wouldn't risk my life or somebody else on the highway. I finally decided to hell w/ my cell phone because I just wanted to concentrate on my driving. Getting kill or injury in an auto accident isn't funny. I'm doing just fine without a cell phone for the last 17 years.
Reply to this comment
by make_or_break July 18, 2008 6:38 PM PDT
Bluetooth headsets have always looked dorky, but honestly, is it any more stupid than all those idiots walking around oblivious to the world (and oncoming traffic) with their white ear buds and the click wheel cranked all the way around to 'permanent, impending silence-to-come, fit-me-with-a-hearing-aid-shortly' mode? (that equates to 11 to you Spinal Tappers)

Since Washington State also instituted a hands-free law on the same day that Cali did--except our fines are a LOT MORE that what you southerners are forced to deal with--the headset scourge has also seen some increase here as well. But I guess it doesn't strike me as being any more stupid than what it was prior to the law's enactment.
Reply to this comment
by Unreal_images July 18, 2008 10:18 PM PDT
I do not mind the head set being on the head at all times. For people with smart phones this means no more smudge on the screen. Plus the headset means no more holding a bulking phone to your ear.
Reply to this comment
Powered by Jive Software

About Cell phone accessories blog

CNET's cell phone accessories blog tracks the hottest ringtones, the coolest accessories, and the latest software for your cell phone. Because buying a cell phone is just the first part of the process, we'll help you take your phone and make it your own.

Add this feed to your online news reader

Cell phone accessories blog topics