- CNET Editors' Rating 7.2/10 Very good Editorial policies >>
- Average user rating from 17 users 7.7/10 Very good Read user opinions >>
The good: Fast 12x optical zoom lens; convenient joystick control; manual exposure controls; optical image stabilization; raw image capture.
The bad: Noisy images; so-so image quality; ISO 3,200 hidden away in a scene mode.
The bottom line: A fast, long 12x optical zoom lens and easy-to-use controls help make up a little for the DMC-FZ8's image-quality issues.
Specs: Digital camera type: Full body; Resolution: 7.2 megapixels; Optical zoom: 12 x See full specs >>
CNET editors' review
- Reviewed on: 04/10/2007
Like the FZ7, the FZ8's body design is just what you'd want in a superzoom. Surprisingly compact but still big enough to shoot comfortably with two hands, the FZ8 has all the controls on the right hand side, so one-handed operation is possible if needed. Overall, Panasonic did a good job of the control system. The tiny yet responsive joystick lets you quickly select AF points or set exposure compensation. White balance, ISO, AF mode, and image size and quality find their home in the main menu. Other functions, such as bracketing, flash compensation, timer, and flash mode are accessed through the five-way touch pad. We found these buttons a bit small, and there is definitely room for larger ones, but we didn't have much trouble using them in our field tests.
In case you don't want to shoot in one of the manual exposure modes, which include aperture- and shutter-priority, as well as full manual, Panasonic includes 20 preset scene modes. We were a bit miffed to find that the camera's ISO 3,200 setting is available only by selecting the High Sensitivity scene mode. However, it seems Panasonic's motives may be pure, as the manual clearly points out that the aggressive, and in our field tests fairly effective, noise reduction algorithms blur away a lot of the images' effective resolution in this mode. Sometimes manufacturers like to set apart modes such as these that can have an adverse effect on image quality. Panasonic doesn't suggest making prints larger than 4x6 inches with this mode, and we agree, but it might come in handy in particularly dark shooting conditions. We would rather Panasonic had just put the setting with the rest of the ISO options and made the same note in the manual under that heading.
We wish the company were just as straightforward with the naming of its "extended optical zoom" feature. This feature, sort of like digital zoom, lets you extend the camera's effective zoom by cropping down the pixel resolution. The name of the mode is extremely misleading and shows a blatant disregard for their consumers' understanding of cameras. Ultimately, if you don't mind ratcheting the resolution down to 3 megapixels or less, you can let the camera crop down the lens' field of view to approximate what you'd get from an 18x zoom. Since you could just as easily crop after the fact, we see little point in doing this, especially since you never know what photographic gems may lie in the cropped-out portions.
In our tests, the Lumix DMC-FZ8 performed well, though in most cases it was a tad slower than its 5-megapixel predecessor. The FZ8 took 2.71 seconds from start-up to capturing its first JPEG. Subsequent JPEGs took 1.78 seconds between shots with the flash turned off, and 2.08 seconds with the flash enabled. When capturing raw images, the FZ8 took 3.88 seconds between shots. While that may seem like a long time, it's not shabby for a superzoom. The 11-point AF system tends to lock on subjects rather quickly, so it's no surprise that the shutter lag measured 0.6 second in our high-contrast test, which mimics bright shooting conditions, and 1.3 seconds in our low-contrast test, which simulates low-light conditions. In continuous-shooting mode, the DMC-FZ8 churned out 2.12 VGA-size JPEGs per second or 1.47 7.1-megapixel JPEGs per second.
The Lumix DMC-FZ8's image quality isn't quite equal to its performance. But, while its ISO noise was probably its worst point, it wasn't as bad as we've seen in the past from other Panasonic models. On the other hand, while the lens is plenty fast with its f/2.8 maximum aperture at its widest angle, it also showed more distortion than we'd like at that same 35mm-equivalent setting, so some straight lines may appear a bit bent when shooting wide. Of course, some photographers like that effect, so it's not always bad, but it also shouldn't be this pronounced at 35mm, though we were pleased that we saw almost no fringing. As we often see, the FZ8's automatic white balance yielded yellowish results with our lab's tungsten test lights. The tungsten setting gave much more neutral results, and the manual white balance worked the best. The metering and flash systems work well together, providing a very nice balance of fill flash when shooting in a room with some, but not enough, ambient lighting.
Even at its lowest sensitivity setting of ISO 100, we saw some noise in our test images, along with other image artifacts, such as the tell-tale jaggy lines that often come along with substandard JPEG processing. Colors were well-saturated though, and we saw an adequate, though not stellar, amount of finer detail. At ISO 200, we saw slightly more noise that, while noticeable on monitors, probably won't adversely affect your prints. At ISO 400, noise begins to pick up, softens fine details, and decreases some shadow detail. At ISO 800, noise becomes very prevalent, lots of finer detail is lost, and shadows take on a mottled look, holding little detail but plenty of blurred, off-color speckles. ISO 1,250 yields extremely noisy results with almost no fine detail anywhere in the image. We suggest you stick to ISO 400 and below whenever possible with the DMC-FZ8, and don't expect to get decent prints with the camera set to ISO 1,250.
While the Panasonic Lumix DMC-FZ8 has problems with noise, in many other ways it is a very nice camera. Its controls make it easy to use, and it packs a very impressive feature set. If you're not persnickety about noise or image quality, it makes a nice camera for beginner and intermediate photographers to learn on. Advanced shooters who want pristine image quality should look elsewhere.
(Shorter bars indicate better performance)
 |
Typical shot-to-shot time | |
Time to first shot | |
Shutter lag (typical) |
(Longer bars indicate better performance)
User opinions
WRITE YOUR OWN REVIEW How would you rate this product?
-
9/10 Spectacular April 2, 2007
"Accept the limitations and you have a great photography tool." Read more >>
-
7/10 Very good May 8, 2007
"Great Camera" Read more >>
-
9/10 Spectacular May 14, 2007
"Excellent light compact walk-around camera" Read more >>
- WRITE YOUR OWN REVIEWSee all 17 user opinions >>
Overstock Clearance - TigerDirect
