Entered CNET Catalog: 04/21/2007
SKU: MA886Z/A
Manufacturer: Apple Inc.
Manufacturer description
Final Cut Studio 2 helps take you beyond mere editing. Discover the intuitive power of new creative tools designed expressly for Final Cut Pro editors. Rapidly move through editing to motion graphics, audio editing and mixing, color grading, and delivery - all as a natural extension of the work you already do. Final Cut Studio 2 puts a powerful new version of Final Cut Pro at the center of an integrated post-production workflow. Final Cut Pro 6, Motion 3, Soundtrack Pro 2, Compressor 3, DVD Studio Pro 4, and Color - a brand-new application for professional color grading - are all included in Final Cut Studio.CNET editors' review
- Editors' Choice: No
- Reviewed on: 06/29/2007
Final Cut Studio 2 is a tightly integrated software package serving would-be Hitchcocks and Coppolas who edit, mix, grade, and produce video and audio. New to this bundle is Color, which brings professional color-grading tools down to the WYSIWYG consumer level. In addition, the updated Final Cut Pro 6, Motion 3 and Soundtrack 2 offer improved interfaces and a variety of fun and practical features for mixing and buffing up film and video projects. Final Cut Studio 2 costs $1,299 or $499 to upgrade; thankfully, the price has not increased, even with the addition of Color. Those with any prior version of FinalCut Pro may upgrade to the full Studio 2 for $699.
Installation
At bare minimum, Final Cut Studio 2 demands a 1.25GHz Mac computer running OS 10.4.9 with 1GB of RAM, and nearly 60GB of free hard drive space for all the programs, templates, and tutorials. You'd be wise to check Apple's fine print for more recommendations. Unfortunately, Studio 2 won't work well with integrated Intel graphics processors, and of course, Windows users are out of luck. Those without Macs who are seeking hearty video-editing software could turn instead either to the Master Collection or Production Premium versions of Adobe Creative Suite 3. Amateurs on a budget may be better off with Final Cut Express, Corel VideoStudio 11, or Apple iLife.
Kick back with a strong cup of coffee when installing FinalCut Studio; this nine-disc suite took us nearly four hours to load on a MacBook Pro with 2 GB of RAM and a 2.3 GHz processor. Installation took just about an hour when using a dream machine Mac Pro with 4 GB of RAM and two dual-core processors.
Interface
The look and feel of Final Cut Studio remains largely the same as in prior versions.
For professionals and longtime users, the multipane, task-based layouts shouldn't be a problem, especially with the workspace customizations as well as resizable, drag-and-drop feature modules. And many tools are relatively intuitive, such as the scopes within Color. But we don't recommend that any newbie tackle Final Cut Studio without reading up on it first, as it's easy to make a mess out of a project by setting it up incorrectly from the get-go. You will need a spacious monitor--ideally two of them--to give your eyes a break. For example, the labels of nested folders are tiny. And as with other complex applications, learning the keyboard shortcuts will pay off in the long run.
Final Cut Pro 6
This video-editing application is at the core of Final Cut Studio 2. The interface consists of multiple panels, including a file browser, timeline, canvas displaying the timeline, clip viewer, and tool palettes. Master Templates can help you add polish quickly to a project.
We were highly impressed by Final Cut's updates, such as the ease enabled by the new Open Format Timeline, which lets you drag and drop assorted layers of clips in varied formats into a project without any transcoding. PAL, NTSC and MPEG content that we popped into the timeline scaled automatically. (Just double-check the properties of the first clip you drag, as clips added subsequently will match its settings.)
In this era of transition, few people have DVD players and televisions that display high-definition footage in its full splendor. Editing software has only slowly caught up with the many high-definition cameras and formats. But Apple's new ProRes 422 format makes it possible to pack high-definition work into the space that a standard-definition project would normally take up. In theory, rather than needing a RAID drive to render a 13-minute video, for instance, you could get by with a 170GB drive and achieve results that look identical to the naked eye.
Final Cut Pro 6 supports industry-standard formats, including DV, HDV, XDCAM HD, and DVCPRO HD. However, there is no support for Blu-ray. AVCHD support has been added with version 2.0.1 updates, which can be found online. Of course, there's support for many next-generation cameras, but you'll have to pay for extra tools to hook up to legacy, non-Firewire cameras. And professionals won't find built-in support for the widespread Sony V1U or JVC 60fps HDV cameras. Apple is known for its elegant software and gadget designs, but we'd like Final Cut to be more intuitive both overall and in the fine details. For instance, there's no estimate of the final file size when you're exporting a project; even Sony Vegas offers that. On the deluxe Mac Pro, we waited 35 minutes for Final Cut Pro to export a half-hour wedding video to MOV format at rinky-dink, 320x240 size, only to get a colossal 5GB file in the end. And while we like what we've seen of Adobe CS3's Device Central, Apple doesn't offer comparable previews of how movies will look on handheld gadgets.
Also, unfortunately, on our MacBook Pro, we encountered glitches. For instance, Final Cut Pro 6 crashed when we tried to export a project to a video iPod. We suspected a corrupted file, but QuickTime achieved the same task without a hitch. Indeed, Apple has already released an update to Final Cut Studio; visit the company's Web site to find what's new. Nevertheless, even after we added version 2.0.1 updates, Final Cut Pro crashed multiple times with general errors and "Out of Memory" messages while performing various functions. Oddly, even taking these downsides into account, Final Cut Pro 6 is a dramatic improvement that sped up our workflow compared to using version 5. However, we advise against multitasking while running the software; dedicating your machine solely to the editing tasks would be wise.
Color
This addition to Final Cut Studio includes a slew of ways to view and adjust color beyond grading capabilities of Final Cut Pro, including with 3D scopes and flatter-looking levers. This application doesn't resemble its brethren in the suite, but it was relatively intuitive. We were able to adjust shadows, midtones and highlights, and customize RGB and luma curves, while presets quickly achieved various mood effects. Color preserves luma values, which saves time when moving work into editing with Adobe AfterEffects. You can also make colors match from various sources or create special effects, such as tinting only a rose red in an otherwise black-and-white movie. Color will likely enable independent moviemakers and editors to achieve lovelier-looking work.
However, Color is limited to 10-bit resolution support. Plus, it handles 2K RGB but not high-end 4K RGB, which Adobe Premiere Pro does handle. Another limitation is that you must break down projects sent to Color into 22-minute reels, ideally with 200 edit points or fewer. Some users have complained that the timecode in a rendered file in Color didn't match that of the original clip. However, we were unable to duplicate this problem.
Motion 3
The Motion 3 animation application offers a cleaner interface and cool 3D compositing capabilities. A bunch of new behaviors allow for creative options without requiring the use of a curve editor, filling in coordinates, and using keyframes. You can view and drag around the 3D space from multiple angles, including the camera's vantage point, and then easily zoom in, set drop zones, and duplicate behaviors.
SmoothCam technology let us take otherwise unusable footage shot from a helicopter and stabilize it for a result that was usable, albeit slightly blurry. We achieved this fix in a series of short steps without having to pick and lock down a stable point, and without using the separate Shake application.
New vector painting tools provide brushstrokes as wacky as feather boas and birds on a wire. Tracking and match moving, optical flow retiming, and a pattern replicator are other notable options. Apple has also added 3D animated text effects and plenty of new stock design elements. And among the new cross-application integration features is the capability to edit templates from Motion 3 without leaving Final Cut Pro 6.
Soundtrack Pro 2
Also with a new look and feel, this update to Final Cut Studio's audio-editing software features support for converting stereo to 5.1 surround sound or combining the two. (Obtaining the necessary equipment for optimal listening is another matter.) An enhanced spectrum view, similar to that in Adobe Soundbooth CS3, resembles a heat map that can display pops, hisses, and telephone rings better than a waveform can, allowing for quick corrections. Visual fade selectors are set up to allow tweaking transitions quickly. And nondestructive waveform editing enables making changes without losing earlier work, should you change your mind.
The new Conform tool lets you sync video and audio changes, such as when dubbing over actors' flubbed lines, made from within the various Studio programs. This worked smoothly in our tests. And a lift-and-stamp tool analyzes two audio clips and matches them without making you grapple with an equalizer. Plus, you can edit more than 1,000 new royalty-free music samples and sound effects from "ambience" to "sci-fi."
Compressor 3
Compressor 3 is set up to allow batch processing and flexible job chaining. You can apply and access dynamic filters, such as watermarks, without rendering. Apple intends for encoding to be 2.8 times faster than in Compression 2, and it supports formats such as MPEG-2 and H.264. However, preparing content for mobile devices isn't as easy as Adobe Creative Suite 3 makes it. For instance, you don't see skins to preview how your work may look on various gadgets.
Final Cut Server
Apple intends to serve professionals while also bringing lofty digital media creation tools down to earth. To that end, Final Cut Server asset management--which we did not test--could enable users to do what only a billion-dollar broadcast network could previously afford. For example, college kids with access to this $999-per-10-user technology could edit each others' video clips from dorm rooms across the world and operate, say, a 24-7, Web-based broadcast network. Access for unlimited users of Final Cut Server will cost $1,999.
Support
Unlike many applications these days that only come with PDF manuals, you can thumb through four volumes of printed manuals for Final Cut Studio 2. Free videos are also available. Professionals will likely find these a handy reference. But despite the wealth of resources, learning Final Cut from scratch could be a hair-pulling task without seeking advice from someone in the know; otherwise, something as mundane as trying to add titles to a movie could waste hours. Luckily, you'll find many passionate online. AppleCare representatives are on hand live via telephone and e-mail 12 hours each day, once you pay a $799 fee. But at that price, we wish someone were on the line 24-7 to assist with the inevitable predawn deadline.
Conclusion
Film editors who use Macs will relish the future-forward tools within Final Cut Studio 2. And as more film freelancers are called to multitask, this suite provides an all-in-one toolkit that more than pays for itself by handling color correction and other projects that might otherwise costs tens of thousands of dollars to outsource. That said, we find the features within Adobe CS3 more appealing for creative projects that need to be repurposed for large and small screens, including handheld gadgets and Web sites.
It's too bad that we still encountered some crashes with Final Cut Pro, but we've grown accustomed over the years to its sensitive personality. We expect that Apple will roll out updates to address bugs as they surface. Overall, however, the many new features in this suite are speedy, impressive time savers. Other software packages may be friendlier for beginners or even seasoned amateurs, but Final Cut Studio 2 remains a solid choice for experienced film professionals.
User opinions
Select a User Opinion to view: 1 2 3 4 5
User Rating: 
10/10
Absolutely amazing.
Pros: Great interface, easy integration of software. Easy enough to move from program to program to get what you need done.
Cons: Motion and color is a little difficult to learn.
User Rating: 
5/10
Stable but Clunky
Pros: Cheap and Solid
Cons: Non-integrated and Non-functional
Final Cut has a couple problems- snap to doesn't work well, so clips will often be off by one frame or so. Bins are problematic too because you can't organize thumbnails except by drag and dropping and the list mode doesn't have thumbnails.
Apple Color looks nice, but integration with FC is not fun. It's difficult to go back and re-adjust clips without exporting the whole project again.
Apple Motion's presets get in the way. I've found that many tools are tedious or unintuitive while others just don't work.
User Rating: 
1/10
The most awful collection of rubbish I've had to use
Pros: It's Cheap compared with Professional systems
Cons: It simply doesn't work
I have been a professional online editor / colourist for over 10 years using Avid products - mostly Symphony and now Symphony Nitris.
Many of my clients are moving over to FCP as a result of low cost compared with Avid products which is why I'm being forced to learn FCP.
In my professional opinion, FCP and it's associated applications, DO NOT WORK. It's as simple as that. I've tried to reproduce my day to day work-flow with the products available. This will either take about four times longer than the Avid route or is impossible.
FCP, Motion and Livetype may be capable of high end, gimmicks which will never be used by a broadcast editor but is simply incapable of doing simple things quickly and elegantly.
If this is the future, I'm getting out.
User Rating: 
8/10
CNET - Stay within your knowledge base.
Pros: Final Touch added at no cost, Ability to handle high end files
Cons: Workflow limited to Mac workstations
User Rating: 
9/10
Apple impresses again
Pros: Full featured production suite. Not much you can't accomplish.
Cons: I'd like to see a full media management tool.
I should start by saying I'm an Avid user. There are things that drive me CRAZY in Final Cut. I don't blame Apple for these issues, it's just what happens when you're raised on a certain set of tools. I wind up hacking my way through the manuals looking for something that was "so easy to do!" on the Avid. Final Cut isn't worse, just different.
That bit of business out of the way, this package really rocks. Editing is snappy, the programs are all rock solid. It really does everything you'd want in an editing package. Apple is to be commended for the wealth of features it debuts with each release. Avid's industry standard Media Composer application has had very little development in the software over the past five years, and has fallen behind in the feature department. Apple continues to forge ahead, giving users more options and tools with each release. What's missing is a quality paint tool. Motion is supposed to be the answer for paint, but editors could use a good paint tool within Final Cut in their arsenal.
Soundtrack Pro is an application that started out as a nice supplement to Final Cut, but it's developed into an essential part of my workflow. With the new release, Apple has beefed up surround sound mixing and given users a massive library of sound effects for mixing. It's become my second most used application in this suite.
DVD Studio is probably the weak link here. Mostly because it's not as elegant as Final Cut or Soundtrack. It's in need of a serious overhaul, simplifying some of the tasks like returning to the home menu after playing. Today's DVD software should be smarter, intuiting where I'm going with a design, and auto-completing the mudane settings. Still, it's a powerhouse DVD design tool and I still use it a lot.
Motion is an app that many designers swear by. I can't get my head around it. I've used Adobe's After Effects program for so many years now, it's just impractical for me to change applications. So I can't give a fair review of this module.
Color is the freshman entry. I haven't done any serious grading on it, but I did pull some footage over and I've got to say, my days of using Synthetic Aperature's Color Finesse for grading and correction are over. Color fits the bill, it's snappy, and it's got a ton of secondaries, which are key to doing serious color work. The only downside is learning curve. It bears no graphic similarities to the other programs as far as interface, and operating it with good results takes practice.
LiveType is an app I wore out when it first came out. But the promise of LiveType has never panned out. There needs to be a huge aftermarket library of LiveType fonts, and it's just never developed. After a few years, the font animations seem dated. Still, for quick animated text, it does the job adequately, and the volume of presets makes it really useful for producing quality titles in a hurry.
The only real sticking point with Final Cut is the media manager. They desperately need to dissect what Avid is doing with regard to tracking assets and adopt their own version.
But in the end, these are just niggles. I rate the program a 9, because it really is nearly perfect editing platform. The biggest advantage to choosing Final Cut Pro is its hardware independence. You can put virtually any capture card on the system and it will work, and work well. Purchasing a capture card won't set you back the cost of a new car any more, and this makes Final Cut a wise choice.
