Pros Solid quality, great look, cuts are fairly precise
Cons Could've made it cheaper, toss the clear screen
Summary This case is really good. I went from a leather case, then exchanged it for the black/green two-pack. It's tricky to put together, and don't bother with the clear screen cuz your iPhone has optical glass.
Aside from that, just be careful when you put it on, always start with the upper right edge, lower right, upper left, then the lower left. That's the sequence that works for me whenever I take it apart for some minor cleaning.
The size is appropriate for most pockets, doesn't look or feel bulky. The surface is pleasantly smooth, and the detail on the cuts are very nice (good example is the camera cut-out).
The only complaint that I'll agree with everyone on is the price. As for someone's concern about durability in dropping it, mine survived an accidental drop when someone knocked it out of my hand. It was approx. a 4 foot drop, and it barely scratched the corners of the case.
"I love this case!"on by booch221
Pros I looked a quite a few iPhone cases and this one is rugged and handsome.
Cons So far there is nothing I don't like about this product.
Summary The case is not too hard and not too soft. It slides easily into my pocket. It's frosted and doesn't show fingerprints.I like the plastic screen protector, it doesn't diminish the touch capacity of the screen at all. I paid $15 at Walmart for it. Such a deal!
Pros None I can tell
Cons I have a 32 gb 3GS and this thing doesn't even fit it all the way. Uh, how is it supposed to be fully protected if it doesn't fully close. The paint also chipped off when the case was initially put on. This case should be avoided by all means.
Summary Besides the point of the paint coming off on the first day and it not totally fitting I guess it's a pretty good case. Just not something that I really find usefull at all and I'm glad CNET allows less that a full star for a rating!
Pros Solid build with a nice rubbery feel for easy grip. It has the feel of silicone but it is a hard shell case. Full screen view - edging is open enough to allow you to type without any interference.
Cons A little tricky to get on the first time. I didn't like the screen protector - it felt kinda cheap.
Summary This is a solid case that has a nice design with solid protection. I removed the screen protector because it didn't have a nice feel and it marked very easily. I used one of the screen protectors from the Apple store and coupled it with the case and it is now just right. I have to disagree with the other reviewer that said that the case felt cheap...I don't think it does at all. It's priced pretty well too - $25 in Canada.
Pros Covers most of the iPhone and protects the screen.
Cons Top and bottom covers don't snap together perfectly. The screen cover causes a bubble/smudge effect where it comes into contact with the screen.