ie8 fix

CNET Archive

Find more recent CD/DVD authoring products

Adobe Encore DVD (08/20/2003)

Adobe Encore DVD

Entered CNET Catalog: 08/20/2003

SKU: 0718659326050

Manufacturer: Adobe Systems

Manufacturer description

Adobe Encore DVD software takes DVD authoring to a new level of creativity and efficiency. Its powerful interface and unparalleled integration with Adobe Premiere, Photoshop, and After Effects lets professional videographers, DVD authors, and independent producers create sophisticated, multi-language DVDs with interactive menus, multiple audio tracks, and subtitle tracks. Adobe Encore provides everything you need for professional DVD production, including powerful menu design tools, full control over interactivity, and output to all recordable DVD formats. Spend less time mastering the technicalities of the DVD format and work with a variety of source files. Integrated transcoding automatically converts video and audio source files to MPEG-2 video and Dolby Digital audio. Optimize your efficiency with unrivalled integration with Adobe Premiere, Photoshop, and After Effects. Express the ideas you envision. The powerful design and editing tools in Adobe Encore let you style text, design imagery, create sophisticated menu and button styles, and more.

Product summary

The goodThe good: Easy to use for simple jobs; automatically transcodes files; offers some higher-end features; menu design process fully integrated with Photoshop.

The badThe bad: Supports only Windows XP; requires latest video drivers; limited interface; no QuickTime support.

The bottom lineThe bottom line: Adobe's Encore DVD is powerful authoring software with a friendly interface, but pros will want more.

Average user rating: from 15 users
1.5 stars

Editors' review

  • Editors' Choice: No
  • Reviewed on: 01/22/2004
Encore DVD, Adobe's new professional DVD-authoring application, lets you have your cake and eat it, too. It's a tasty cake for beginners, with easy drag-and-drop menu creation and automatic transcoding to DVD formats--basic features common to lower-priced packages such as Sonic's MyDVD. But it's a filling cake, too, with a handful of professional-level features and tools including subtitles, navigation link overrides, and mastering options. Encore is well integrated into the work flow of Adobe's digital media tools, giving you more design control over your production. Still, Encore is Adobe's first attempt in the authoring space, and there are some unfortunate compromises with the interface and certain features. We prefer Apple's DVD Studio Pro 2.0 for its higher-end authoring options, but for Windows users, Adobe Encore DVD offers the most functionality of any similarly priced package.

Adobe Encore DVD runs on Windows XP only: it won't work with previous versions of Windows or the Mac OS. It's a fairly significant limitation, but it's necessary for Encore to take full advantage of Microsoft's new digital media architecture. (You are also required to update to Microsoft's DirectX 9.0.) Encore may ask you to update your video card drivers to avoid video playback glitches, as well. Once all of that's taken care of, installation is quick and easy. The program directory uses about 80MB of space for a basic library of buttons, graphics, and menu backgrounds. The installation disc also includes some 280 additional buttons, images, and menu backgrounds. Adobe's downloadable maintenance release 1.0.1 from December 2003 includes a variety of bug fixes and speed enhancements.

Encore's interface should be familiar and comfortable for users of other Adobe products. There's a Project window to assemble and organize assets and Premiere-like Timeline and Monitor windows. Adobe users will also recognize Menu Editor windows; Toolbars; and Layers, Character, and Library palettes similar to those in Photoshop. Multiple windows can be nested with tabs to save space, but the interface has limitations: you can't resize the palettes or save window layouts.

Encore lets you drag and drop to add clips to menus or to create links between menus and clips. For more hands-on control, palettes let you view and set attributes individually or in a group; you can add a background audio track to a group of menus in one operation, for example, or select buttons on several menus and change the associated link for all of them simultaneously. The Project window lets you keep things organized with sortable lists of Menus and Timelines to make sure clips are consistently defined and linked. There's also a helpful Check Links feature that keeps tabs on orphaned menus.



Encore's Integrated Menu Editor makes menu and button creation easy; just drag and drop.

Encore gives everything you need to create great-looking DVDs. The integrated Menu Editor lets you build custom menus with still or video backgrounds, graphics overlays, titles and text, buttons, and links. Buttons are highly customizable. You can use Photoshop layers to determine a button's graphical shape, highlight colors, and text label; you can even include a thumbnail image or a video from the linked video clip. Best of all, you can transfer menus directly between Encore and Photoshop for more sophisticated design work without flattening layers or making conversions required by other DVD tools.

When you're ready, assemble clips and chapter points on the Timeline with up to 8 audio streams and 32 subtitle streams (the DVD maximums). You can easily add a few subtitles by typing text directly into the Monitor window or subtitle an entire movie by importing a file with a list of time codes and associated text or images.



Use Encore's Timeline editor to add chapter points and multiple audio and subtitle tracks.

Encore can import AVI and DirectShow video files and common still image and audio formats, but not QuickTime formats. It's best to import DV AVI files that are already at DVD resolution and let Encore do the thinking; it will automatically transcode them to MPEG-2 at the appropriate DVD-compatible rates. Encore uses the same MainConcept MPEG encoder as Premiere Pro, giving you full control over the compression parameters in your video if you want it. You can also always encode externally and import the final MPEG-2 into Encore.

After using the Preview window to check the DVD design, Encore will burn your file to DVD. (Like most higher-end authoring products, it can't create VCDs.) You can also export your file as a DVD folder on hard disk, save a disc image file to burn later, or create a DVD master on DLT tape for replication, complete with double-side/dual-layer and content-protection options.

Adobe provides solid documentation. Encore comes with a 155-page printed user guide; an electronic version of the guide is also available under the Help tab. It features two tutorials, and you'll find another 28-page tutorial on the product DVD with associated example project and media files. The DVD also contains hundreds of additional buttons and images, plus menu backgrounds and templates to use in your designs. You can find additional tutorials on the Adobe Encore and Adobe Studio Web sites.

Adobe's new support system is due to kick in February 2004; the company will provide free phone support for registered users of current versions of Adobe software, but there's no toll-free number. You can also check the user forum and search the broad but clumsy knowledge base for help at Adobe's support site.

User opinions

Select a User Opinion to view: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16
User Rating:
0.5 stars

out of 16 user reviews

Awful, awful, awful.

Pros: Sometimes exits without crashing so I can use a different program.

Cons: I sometimes have to use it for work.

Review: I make internet videos and DVDs for a living. I'd rather stab myself in the eyes than have to grind through the piece of trash and its "interface" full of random errors and lost media. Get some kids' DVD program and make your menus with that before you ever try to figure this thing out.
User Rating:
0.5 stars

out of 16 user reviews

This is a HORRIBLE program.. Just aweful...

Pros: Nothing...

Cons: Incredibly ustable... I am using it on my mac to author a simple bluray movie that is less than 40 min... The program has crashed at least 20 times.... In addition, if you render the menus more than a couple of time, they become corrupt. HORRIBLE

Review: This program could be the worst program i have ever used... I decided to use it because it was capable of burning bluray, which DVD Pro could not... I thought it would a program equal in quality to the Final Cut Suite... That is absolutely not true... It is highly unstable and it files become corrupt quite easily... This program has set me back weeks... Adobe needs to either pull the program all together or do some major rewrites to fix it
User Rating:
0.5 stars

out of 16 user reviews

Crashes repeatedly in Vista. Unable to complete project.

Pros: Promises a professional experience: Bad core software

Cons: Memory leaks; Crashes regularly in Vista; Loses saved links to MPEG files; Loses Audio from with AVI.

Review: Avoid buying this junk. It'll break your heart. It cost me a week of heartache on a multimenu project.
User Rating:
0.5 stars

out of 16 user reviews

Worst Software Ever Used

Pros: No pros to speak of

Cons: Too manay to list

Review: As with all Adobe products this one is another RAM and Processor Hog. Even using a brand new 4 GB RAM, Dual layer Chip it locked up sveral times and gave errors that Adobe has not support for but the same errors are all over every forum. This DVD builder in a nutshell is garbageware. Obviously Adobe's rush to market this product was more important than quality.
Even the most mundane processes like removing images from the timeline are over 5 min. to process. Complete Failure, Should be given away as freeware, I am currently researching other candidates. As far as the CNET software reviewer who rated this a 7, he certainly has never used this product nor does he know how to burn DVD's make movies and video. Probably paid off by Adobe.
User Rating:
1.5 stars

out of 16 user reviews

didn't work, stability issues

Pros: intigrated with adobe suite

Cons: stability issues

Review: I have used either premier or final cut to edit video for years. I find them similar as far as applications. I tried the free 30 day trial of encore, it seemed to be worthless. i usually like adobe, but this thing was a little weird. I have now moved on to Sony Vegas+DVD. it is a very stable, capable program that makes tough jobs quick. good luck. I saw encore came out with 2.0. But the version i used was not good.
User Rating:
1.5 stars

out of 16 user reviews

It has cost me lot's of lost hours, in production!

Pros: Intergrate's well with other Adobe products

Cons: You never know when the file will Corrupt on you!

Review: I have used Encore for 2 years producing educational DVD's and was in hopes that Adobe would have fixed the programming errors by now! My boss lost hundreds of hours in having to redue DVD's and I have lost many to this poor excuse for a professional tool. Two days ago as I was on deadline to finish up a DVD project I got the god awful (Internal Error )message! At best that means you have go back to another saved good version...but that too could become Corrupted!!! You never, never know when it is going to happen! So I had to work late on my own time to redue the whole DVD including Transcoding all 15 avi files!!!!! I've had it with this product and I'm searching for an alturnitive now!
User Rating:
4.5 stars

out of 16 user reviews

Gets a 9 for being the best (still not a 10)

Pros: In my opinion it's the most powerful DVD program out there

Cons: DVD PROGRAMS HAVE A LONG WAY TO GO!!!!

Review: Not a great DVD authoring program but it is the best I have used. It was easy to learn but takes a bit longer to master. The layout is not the best and there aren’t enough options. But I have used so called professional / industry standard programs and I haven’t been satisfied yet. This program is so simple and easy to use all you need is a half hour and a loose trigger finger. With all the options as “the big boys” this program integrates with the rest of the adobe collection quite nicely. I think that future releases of this product have the potential of being great if they make the program less user friendly and more complicated with more options.
User Rating:
1.0 stars

out of 16 user reviews

Slow, unstable, far below Adobe's standards

Pros: A few pre-made menus and some support for complicated menus

Cons: Locks up, extremely slow, poor interface, unintuitive

Review: One of the slowest programs ever to run on my rather fast PC. You CAN author a DVD eventually, but only after a lot of effert and many crashes and waiting for the program to respond. Updates did not help.

Try a different program to author your DVDs.
User Rating:
4.5 stars

out of 16 user reviews

Saves Time and Always Yields Pro Results

Pros: Fast, Reliable Authoring

Cons: Gets a Little Moody With File Management

Review: Read some of the negative reviews and I was quite shocked by what I saw. Coming from another "professional" authoring system by a leading competitior, the Adobe Encore program seemed like a breeze and performed quite well under guerilla-like circumstances, working in the post-production video business like I do.

It's a fast program, (cutting down my authoring time in half, at least) and the fact that it works directly with Photoshop files for the menus is awesome. I can jump in and out of Photoshop, if necessary to make changes or even 'tweek' a button right in Encore, if necessary. It's great!

While no program is perfect, (thus the 9 rating), this comes as perfect as it can given the high demands of the DVD spec as directed by the MPAA.

If you have to make a choice, buy this author tool and if you have the money, buy it in the Adobe Video Collection, which is now shipping with Photoshop CS2.
User Rating:
4.5 stars

out of 16 user reviews

If you have XP and like Adobe-style interfaces, this is an excellent choice.

Pros: Very solid, very flexible, integrates w/Photoshop

Cons: No ability to archive projects (workflow)

Review: I have a feeling the other opinions written here were not from true Encore users. I've been successful using several of the other popular authoring solutions (Ulead DVD Workshop 2, DVD-lab Pro, TMPG Inc's DVD Author Pro, etc.), but this one really keeps me coming back. This app is very stable, very reliable, and actually pretty fun to use once you understand the interface. It would be nice if it had a project manager similar to some of the video editing solutions (e.g. Adobe Premiere) that would gather up all resources and package them nicely for archiving. The documentation is very concise and can get you up-to-speed in a couple of hours. This is the software I recommend to all of my friends that want to author their own DVDs. Encore DVD will give you the professional results you are looking for.
User Rating:
0.5 stars

out of 16 user reviews

Horrible, constantly locking up

Pros: Integrates well with Photoshop

Cons: This software is not worthy of the Adobe Name

Review: What was Adobe thinking releasing this piece of garbage and putting their name on it. It has been enormously frustrating using this software. I thought that becuase of all of the other Adobe products that I have that it would be less hassle to integrate with the Video editing and graphics package. It integrates well, it just does'nt seem to want to work for more than 5 minutes without locking up. When it does work, it is so slow it reminds you of what computers were like 15 years ago.
If you are at all serious about authoring DVD's then do not get this program.
User Rating:
1.5 stars

out of 16 user reviews

Garbage, pure and unadulterated.

Pros: You are not required by law to purchase it.

Cons: Bugs, slow, MPEG2 encoding sub-par, Unstable, menu errors abound, unintuitive

Review: This application is total crap and I'd say you'd be better buying one of the consumer level hand-holding apps. This puppy is frought with bugs, crashes, poor design, definitely not what we've come to expect from Adobe. What went wrong? Adobe needed somtething to compete with DVD Studio Pro from Apple. In very un-Adobe-like fashion, they appear to have purchased an upstart, and it shows. This thing is a clunker. Adobe will need to try again, and in a hurry, lest they lose still more ground to the tightly integrated FinalCut Studio.
User Rating:
1.5 stars

out of 16 user reviews

from professional DVD author: DON'T USE THIS

Pros: easy to use

Cons: easy to use it and when it works

Review: I've been using this professionally for a year, to do a few educational DVDs. I've had it with this, and can't believe they haven't fixed the uncountable bugs. The final straw was today when I was trying to build a final DVD, and Encore kept crashing saying "menu error". There are over 95 menus! It doesn't say which menu or which button! It took me over 10 hours to test different menus, deleting and resaving the project, until I discovered which one was the problem. I never figured out what the problem was, but I recreated the menu from scratch. Even worse was in the beginning when projects would continually become corrupt and unusable. I finally found the way around that (transcode the files externally). REALLY BAD.
User Rating:
3.5 stars

out of 16 user reviews

Great package, if you're already familiar with Premiere Pro or willing to invest the time to learn.

Pros: Really professional results possible. Very flexible menu and timeline linking to DVD functions. If you're looking for a professional-grade authoring package for the WinXP platform, and are willing to invest the time to learn the interface, Encore is for

Cons: User interface is a bit daunting, unless you're already familiar with Premiere Pro or some of the other Adobe digital imaging tools. If you're looking for something with a quick drag-and-drop, click-here-to-make-my-DVD-fro m-presets package, Encore isn't

Review:
User Rating:
1.0 stars

out of 16 user reviews

This is Adobe?

Pros: It says Adobe on the box.

Cons: It can't be Adobe in the box. What has become of the powerful products we've come to expect from the leader in digital media?

Review:
User Rating:
0.5 stars

out of 16 user reviews

Use anything but this

Pros: none

Cons: Where do I begin? Limited help file, Adobe-like interface fools you into thinking it's easy to use, but it's really not, when I put an m2v and its wav file in the timeline, the audio didn't syncronize one bit. It wasn't even slightly off, it was WAY off

Review:

About CNET Archive

Welcome to the CNET Archive, a library of product reviews, user opinions, videos, specifications, and manufacturer descriptions for products no longer offered by the manufacturer or most retailers. Here you will find information on replacement parts and replacement ink cartridges. Read what others had to say about that used laptop you are considering buying. Take a trip down memory lane as you browse and reminisce about your favorite old video game or that first digital camera.

Adobe Encore DVD specifications

ie8 fix
ie8 fix
  • Recently Viewed Products
  • My Lists
  • My Software Updates
  • Promo
  • Log In | Join CNET