Nokia 5140

More on this product: review; user reviews; specifications; compare; shop

Print
E-mail
Share

CNET editors' rating: 3.5 stars Very good
Detailed editors' rating

Average user rating: 4.0 stars out of 10 reviews
See all user reviews

Product summary

The good: Quirky features; sturdy design; speakerphone; solid call quality; support for EDGE.

The bad The bad: Small display; buttons are not very tactile.

The bottom line: The Nokia 5140 wins points for originality, but its design will stymie frequent cell phone users.

Specifications: Carrier: No Carrier; Band / mode: GSM 850/1800/1900 (Tri-Band); Talk time: Up to 300 min; See full specs

CNET editors' review

Reviewed by: Kent German
Edited by: William O'Neal
Reviewed on: 01/27/2005

It is believed that only three things will survive a nuclear war: Volvos, cockroaches, and Twinkies. But with its 5140 cell phone, Nokia might have added another item to the mix. Wrapped in rubber and solidly constructed, the 5140 is a sharp departure from the common mobile form factor. The black-and-blue candy bar-style handset looks like it could stand up to any manner of abuse. It also has an assortment of oddball features--including a thermometer, a compass, and a flashlight--that would benefit anyone lost in a post-apocalyptic world. The 5140 camera phone promises push-to-talk (PTT) capability, but its weirdness may in fact work against it by limiting its appeal to a mass audience. At the time of this writing, the GSM and EDGE-enabled mobile is not offered by a carrier, so its $249 price tag isn't cheap. But that could change if a carrier decides to pick it up.Most mobiles--particularly your average silver flip phone--wouldn't qualify as durable. Nokia, however, has endeavored to design mobiles that can take a few blows. The company's latest attempt is the Nokia 5140, which supports GSM and EDGE networks. The black-and-blue 5140 has a signature style that incorporates rubber padding on its side and bottom, as well as a rubber covering for the controls and the keypad. To be sure, the 5140 survived a few drops on the floor, and the casing is designed to resist dust and water, though that doesn't make it waterproof. While those elements may appeal to fitness fanatics and the outdoorsy set, the phone is bulky (4.1 by 1.7 by 0.9 inches; 3.3. ounces), and it won't win any design awards. On the other hand, you can choose from an assortment of changeable faceplates.

Wear and tear: The 5140's rubber casing protects against bumps.

The 5140 has a 4,096-color display that measures a rather small 1.5 inches diagonally. Though it's easy to see in most lighting, the low-resolution screen has an overall washed-out appearance, and you can adjust contrast but not brightness. On the plus side, you can specify the backlight time, but the unchangeable text size may be too small for users with visual impairments. The menus are easy enough to use, but we aren't pleased with the navigation keys. Due to the rubber covering, the controls are difficult to manipulate, and we often misdialed. A five-way toggle provides shortcuts to four user-defined functions, but its small size also makes for some misdials. Other controls consist of two soft keys and dedicated Talk and End buttons.

Though they are also covered in rubber, the keypad buttons are easier to use. A raised profile makes it easy to dial by feel; our only complaint is the backlighting is too dim. On the left spine is a volume rocker, on the top is the power button, and the PTT key sits on the right spine. Though they're easy to find when you aren't looking, pressing them was another matter. The volume rocker requires an especially firm push, which is difficult to do while on the phone. We like the rubber door on the bottom of the mobile that covers the charger and headset ports, but we're puzzled as to why the rubber doesn't extend to the phone's backside. There you'll find the camera lens, but there's no flash or self-portrait mirror.

The Nokia 5140 has a customary complement of features with a few extras thrown in. The 250-name phone book holds five standard and one push-to-talk numbers; e-mail, Web, and street addresses; and notes for each entry, while the SIM card holds an additional 250 names. Contacts can be organized into caller groups and paired with a picture for photo caller ID; you can even add a voice tag to each entry. There's also ring tone caller ID, but the 6 monophonic and 24 polyphonic ring tones can only be assigned to a caller group. Additionally, you can send an electronic business card to other callers.

Other features included a vibrate mode; text, multimedia, and instant messaging; a WAP 2.0 wireless Web browser; an alarm clock; a calendar; a calculator; a to-do list; a notepad; a voice recorder; an infrared port; and support for PC syncing via wireless means or a data cable. A speakerphone is included, but it can be activated only after a call is made. The 5140 also is the first Nokia handset that we've seen with push-to-talk capability, but be advised that it's network dependent.

The most memorable goodies on the 5140 go hand in hand with the mobile's sturdy form factor. There's a thermometer (in both Celsius and Fahrenheit), a stopwatch, a countdown timer, a decibel meter, and a tiny flashlight that will do in a pinch. There's also a compass, and the miniscule leveler bubble on the front face will help in calibration. Though fun, the compass and the flashlight aren't necessarily useful, so we doubt they will appeal to many people. Also, the thermometer's accuracy depended on how close you hold the phone to your body.

See more CNET content tagged:: Nokia Corp.,; T-Mobile

User reviews

Average user rating: 4.0 stars out of 10 reviews
My rating: 0 stars Write review

Showing 3 of 10 user reviewsSee all 10 user reviews
4.5 stars

4 out of 4 people found this review helpful

"Great outdoor phone"

by greenthumb on July 13, 2005

read more
4.0 stars

3 out of 3 people found this review helpful

"Great durable phone full of features!"

on February 20, 2005

read more
4.5 stars

2 out of 2 people found this review helpful

"No drops, picks up calls where others won't, spkr is g8"

by bumperman on March 14, 2005

read more
See all 10 user reviews Write review

Submit your review

Nokia 5140

1. Rate this product:: (Mouse over the stars to rate this product and click to set your rating.)
2. One-line summary:(Summarize your review in one line. 10 characters minimum; required.): 0 of 55 characters
3. Pros:(Tell us what you like about this product. 10 characters minimum; required.): 0 of 250 characters
4. Cons:(Tell us what you don't like about this product. 10 characters minimum; required.): 0 of 250 characters
Bottom-line summary:(Explain to us in detail why you like or dislike the product, focusing your comments on the product's features and functionality, and your experience using the product. This field is optional.): 0 of 5000 characters; Submit

Reviews from
around the WebPowered by alaTest

laptopmag.com

Read full review
techtree.com

Editors' rating: 70

Read full review
pocket-lint.co.uk

Editors' rating: 90

Summary: If the take-up on the networks for push-to-talk happens this is a go, but when you need an upgrade this will have been updated- check it out then

Read full review
goodgearguide.com.au

Editors' rating: 70

Summary: The rugged design of the Nokia 5140i will handle the rough and tumble of outdoor adventures or even just everyday life. If you want a phone that can go the distance and don't need bluetooth this is a contender.

Read full review
pcmag.com

Editors' rating: 60

Summary: The Nokia 5140 is not exactly a push-to-talk walkie-talkie phone (à la Nextel), at least not yet. But it's the closest you can get on a GSM network, and its rugged nature will appeal to backyard Indiana Joneses.

Read full review