Sony DCR-IP5

CNET Editors' Rating

3.5 stars
    Overall score: 7.5 (3.5 stars)

Very good

Average User Rating

2.5 stars

75 reviews

All prices Set price alert
Sony DCR-IP5 - front Sony DCR-IP5 - back Sony DCR-IP5 - left Sony DCR-IP5 - right
Scroll Left Scroll Right
  • Sony DCR-IP5 - front
  • Sony DCR-IP5 - back
  • Sony DCR-IP5 - left
  • Sony DCR-IP5 - right

CNET Editors' Review

CNET Editors' Rating

3.5 stars Very good
    Overall score: 7.5 (3.5 stars)
  • Design: 8.0
  • Features: 7.0
  • Performance: 7.0
  • Image quality: 8.0
  • Reviewed by: Rob McGee
  • Released on:
  • Reviewed on:
  • Updated on:

The good: Very small and portable; relatively high coolness factor.

The bad: Incompatible with most video-editing software; pricey first-generation model; some controls awkward to operate.

The bottom line: For portability in a camcorder, you can't top the IP5, but its MPEG-2 footage won't meet every videographer's needs.

Review: Sony's DCR-IP5 is remarkably tiny--thanks to Sony's new MicroMV format, which uses cassettes about one-third the size of standard MiniDV tapes. However, MicroMV also uses a different data-compression scheme than MiniDV, which may spell trouble if you already have DV-editing software. Unless you're an early adopter, weigh the cost of going Micro. MiniDV cameras--and cassettes--are more affordable, better supported, and almost as portable. If you still want to give the new format a try, compare the IP5 with its higher-priced cousin, the IP7BT, which adds a Memory Stick for still-photo storage as well as a wireless Bluetooth ... Expand full review
Sony's DCR-IP5 is remarkably tiny--thanks to Sony's new MicroMV format, which uses cassettes about one-third the size of standard MiniDV tapes. However, MicroMV also uses a different data-compression scheme than MiniDV, which may spell trouble if you already have DV-editing software. Unless you're an early adopter, weigh the cost of going Micro. MiniDV cameras--and cassettes--are more affordable, better supported, and almost as portable. If you still want to give the new format a try, compare the IP5 with its higher-priced cousin, the IP7BT, which adds a Memory Stick for still-photo storage as well as a wireless Bluetooth modem for Internet access right from the camcorder.

This little five-way controller lets you navigate the LCD menu; we wish there were a separate Select button.

Weighing just 13 ounces with battery and media loaded, the DCR-IP5 qualifies as shirt-pocketable--a designation that sometimes applies to digital still cameras but rarely to camcorders.

The five-way control button close to the 2.5-inch LCD on the other side of the camera was easier to use as we navigated menus, but we found ourselves wishing for a separate Select button.
Built-in memory on each of the tiny MicroMV cassettes stores a thumbnail index of your video clips.Included accessories.

The camera offers plenty of shooting features through the LCD menus, including picture effects, presets for shooting different types of scenes, 24-step exposure compensation, and manual focus. Built-in memory on each MicroMV cassette gives you a convenient way to locate previously recorded footage when the camera is in VCR mode; a still frame from the beginning of each recorded segment is displayed in an index of thumbnails.
Small buttons require a deft touch.MicroMV cassettes are tinier than MiniDV.




Input/output ports.
This camera's extreme portability comes at a price. There's not a lot of free real estate, which means that the physical controls are shrunken and consolidated, and that can be bad news for fumble-fingered users. Our biggest beef was with the tiny wide/telephoto toggle that zooms the 10X Carl Zeiss lens; manipulating it requires a deft touch and a certain amount of practice.

Video quality matches that of midrange consumer MiniDV cameras.


As we said, MicroMV differs from MiniDV at the level of the digital data stream itself, not just in physical dimensions. While MiniDV footage uses compression within each frame, MicroMV adds the frame-to-frame compression of MPEG-2, the same compression scheme used for DVD and digital satellite broadcasts. To the user, this translates into a theoretical drop in quality when compared to MiniDV, with the likeliest problem being motion artifacts, pixelated footage that occurs if your subject is moving too fast, if there are a lot of sudden color changes, and so forth. That said, we didn't notice any such problems; video quality was on a par with that of midrange consumer MiniDV cameras.

Low-light shots in normal (left) and low-light (right) modes.

Hide Review

User Reviews

See all user reviews

Average User Rating

2.5 stars out of 75 user reviews

Rating Breakdown

  • 5 star: 3
  • 4 star: 22
  • 3 star: 26
  • 2 star: 11
  • 1 star: 13

My Rating

0 stars click stars to rate product

CNET Community

This product is on 1 user lists. Add to my list

Most recent user reviews

Showing 3 of 75 reviews

4.5 stars

"Simply the great !" By VaioStyle

Pros: Light-weight and handy, good video quality,easy to use

Cons: Less manual control, weak battery, expensive media,

Summary: I bought this product after going thorough all these reviews last month. I didn't find any problem in exporting and editing the clips into PC. What I feel now is, this product got a lot of criticisms because Pinnacle studio 9.00 was late to arrive in the market. ... Expand full review

2.5 stars

"Survived 5 wks of rugged outdoor professional use, but transporting content sucked." By Livio Bestulic

Pros: Size matters when you are in the wilds.

Cons: The content takes too much effort & time to transport to editing software.

Summary: I intended to used this camera as a second unit in 5 weeks of professional mountain filming (Austrian Alps, Moroccan Atlas Mtns, and Greece's Olympus Mtns) but its size (and lack of weight) made it a first unit very often. However, I was concerned about the final quality.

Upon

... Expand full review

Where to Buy

See all prices Set price alert

Specifications

See full specs

Quick Specs

  • Optical sensor type: CCD
  • Flash type: None
  • Weight: 0.7 lbs

Compare to Editors' Top digital camcorders

See All Best digital camcorders

Sponsored Premier Brands on CNET

Where to Buy

See all prices Set price alert

Which camcorder is right for me?

Laptop Finder

Before you fall in love with just any old camcorder, you need to know precisely what you're looking for, lest you realize somewhere down the road that you chose the wrong machine.

We've compiled a handful of typical user profiles that should help outline what type of camcorder is right for you. Ask yourself the hard questions, then match your needs to one of these user profiles. To bone up on the audio specs that matter for your user type, take a look at our section on capturing good sound with video.

Read our guide | Step-by-step camcorder finder