ReplayTV RTV5508 (80-hour DVR)

Summary: I bought both a TiVo and a Replay TV to compare the services...Replay wins HANDS down!! The one thing I give the nod to TiVo is that it does have a better channel guide. But, if you want an efficient, VERY user friendly interface and quick quick quick navigation, go ReplayTV! Instead of having to fast-forward through the commercials, you can either quick skip by 30 seconds or use the Show/Nav to skip the entire commercial segment! I also found that the TiVo required more menu pages to accomplish what ReplayTV does in 1 step. Replay also has more flexible recording options, much easier to deal with than TiVo.