Pros Ease of use, picture quality. I had -zero- problems setting it up, and the network of three works flawlessly, even though I have them in slightly different configurations. Anyone who can't use a Replay deserves a TiVo.
Cons Replay caved in to the big guns; therefore, no more commercial advance or Internet program sharing. Bah.
Pros Guide is very functional. Recorded shows are easier to find than on Tivo.
Cons No HI-def recording or output.
Pros the best features going, still skips commercials with the show nav feature, great video quality, simple no nonsense interface, hackable!
Cons awful tech support from India, did not understand english very well, support is not toll free and only operates monday through friday. I had to go through 3 units before I got one that worked. I almost gave up but finally got one that worked and I love
Pros Easy to use and reliable
Cons Some stations programming is off which creates errors in recording.
Pros Excellent video, commercial skip, home network incorporation, good tech support, and ease of use.
Cons channel change is a little slow, photo share is difficult to setup on network