DMR-E50S DVD Video Recorder

CNET editors' rating: 3.0 stars Good
Detailed editors' rating
Design: 5.0
Features: 7.0
Performance: 7.0
Overall score: 6.2 (3.0 stars)
• Average user rating: 2.5 stars out of 11 reviews
• See all user reviews

Product summary

CNET editors' review

• Reviewed by:
  David Katzmaier
• Reviewed on: 07/29/2003
• Released on: 03/15/2003

By this time next year, you'll probably be able to buy a DVD recorder for around $200. But if that's too long a wait for you, consider Panasonic's DMR-E50S, the most-affordable option on the market right now. The company's 2003 entry-level model, available online for as little as $370, can do everything that last year's DMR-E30S can--and for less money. Sure, the E50S is missing some cutting-edge features and a built-in hard drive, but for straightforward VHS archiving and VCR-like TV recording, this Panasonic fits the bill.

Editor's note: We have changed the rating in this review to reflect recent changes in our rating scale. Click here to find out more.

The S in the name tells you the color is silver; the same recorder is also available in black as the DMR-E50K. The unit looks like an extrathick regular DVD player with a skinny, black belt bisecting its face and a big, unattractive DVD Recording logo on the drawer. The central, animated display is well organized, especially the recording information: one glance at the cool-looking spinning-disc icon gives you the status.

Access to the E50S's many functions is provided by a series of boring, complicated menus that beginners will find hard to understand. Unfortunately, the manual is dense and doesn't do a very good job of explaining the options.

Unlike the step-up DMR-E60S, the E50S has the same clunky, plastic remote that came with earlier Panasonic recorders. The control's principal downfall is a slide-down hatch that inconveniently conceals a slew of useful buttons, such as Open/Close. Very little space separates the keys, and the three menu buttons look too alike. But once we were accustomed to the layout, we appreciated the ability to access functions without resorting to the menu.This entry-level deck comes with a 64-page manual and can present quite a learning curve. Thanks to the DVD-RAM format, the E50S gives you some of the functionality of a hard-disk recorder. While a recording is in progress, you can watch it from the beginning or play back something else. Basic editing, such as shortening segments and dividing one program into two, is also available. That said, you're better off performing advanced video editing on a PC.

Each disc you burn bears a relatively unattractive, unalterable main menu. The four recording modes give you one- to six-hour discs; the picture quality decreases as the length increases. There's also a convenient flexible recording mode that lets you fill the remainder of a disc with a certain amount of video--say, 2 hours, 35 minutes.

Although DVD-RAM isn't compatible with as many machines as the other two rewritable DVD formats, Panasonic says more manufacturers, such as Samsung and Hitachi, will produce DVD-RAM-capable players in the future. You can also record on write-once DVD-Rs. They're highly compatible and less expensive than DVD-RAMs, which cost $5 to $8 per disc.

The E50S includes VCR Plus, but the recorder's inability to control a cable or satellite box limits its real-world usefulness for TV recording. The front and back panels each have two A/V inputs with S-Video. Also on the rear are an RF input and output for cable or an antenna (just like on a VCR), a pair of A/V outs with S-Video, a progressive-scan component-video output, and an optical digital output. The only missing items are a FireWire input, which is available on the E60S, and a component-video input. Philips's DVDR75 and DVDR80 have both connections but cost more.As expected, the E50S delivered video quality superior to VHS's. Even in the four-hour EP mode, recordings looked stable and had well-saturated colors, although blocky MPEG noise tinged the images. The two-hour SP mode nearly eliminated that problem in the backgrounds, and the one-hour mode's smooth picture was almost indistinguishable from the original, even on our large Samsung HLN617W reference set.

A serious difference in resolution separates the SP and EP modes: SP measured 450 lines, while EP came in at barely 230. You should avoid the six-hour LP mode; it was significantly softer than EP, tended to introduce stutter in pans, and managed barely 200 lines of resolution.

In our side-by-side comparison of the E50S and Philips's DVDR75, we played the Monsters Inc. DVD via S-Video. Overall, the Panasonic in its one- and two-hour modes won by a very slight margin. The Philips introduced more MPEG blocks but also looked a tiny bit sharper, especially in the background and the walls of Sully and Mike's apartment. In the four-hour mode, the Philips edged out the Panasonic by a blue hair: Sully's coat was noticeably more detailed compared with the E50S's oversmooth rendition. The Philips delivered an impressive 275 lines of resolution in EP.

At one point, we tried a somewhat scuffed DVD-R blank. The player went into Recover mode and spit out the unusable disc. Progressive-scan DVD playback was fine, although we did see some jagged edges in 30-frame-per-second video-based material.

See more CNET content tagged:

Philips Electronics N.V.,

Panasonic,

resolution,

MPEG,

DVD

User reviews

• Average user rating: 2.5 stars out of 11 reviews
• My rating: 0 stars Write review

• Showing 3 of 11 user reviewsSee all 11 user reviews

• 4.0 stars

  "Reads all cheap media except -"

  by georgesbak on April 17, 2005

  read more

• 1.5 stars

  "Be very careful!!"

  on September 1, 2004

  read more

• 4.0 stars

  "Excellent machine easy to use"

  on April 23, 2004

  read more

• See all 11 user reviews Write review

Where to buy DMR-E50S DVD Video Recorder

This product is currently not in stock at any of our online merchants.

Find from our auction partner, eBay

Email me when this product is available