-
CNET editors' rating:
stars
Good
Detailed editors' rating -
Average user rating:
Write your own review
Product summary
The good: Fast FireWire 800 throughput; FireWire interface is bus-powered; OS X-ready, cool and quiet during operation, three-year warranty.
The bad: High cost per GB; subpar FireWire 400 throughput speed; not Windows XP-friendly, USB 2.0 requires separate power adapter purchase.
The bottom line: Unless you are using a Mac with a FireWire 800 port, G-Tech's G-Drive mini Triple portable hard drive holds little appeal.
Specifications: Hard drive size: 200 GB ; Interface type: IEEE 1394b (FireWire 800) / IEEE1394 (FireWire) / Hi-Speed USB ; Spindle speed: 5400 rpm See full specs
Price range: $189.99 check prices
CNET editors' review
- Reviewed on: 06/04/2008
We have mixed feelings for the G-Drive mini Triple. On one hand, this portable hard drive boasts three connection options, a rugged design, and an internal hard drive that spins at a fleet 7,200rpm (most 2.5-inch drives spin at only 5,400rpm or slower). But a drive's rotation speed offers little difference in performance, particularly when operating on a FireWire 400 or USB 2.0 connection as we saw in testing. The other interface option is FireWire 800. The drive is quite friendly with Macs, but those running Windows XP will need to engage in a rather advanced reformatting process before you get up and running. We also found that when operating via USB 2.0, the drive requires you to purchase the separate power adapter. Finally, at around $250 for the 200GB model, the G-Drive mini Triple does not offer good value per GB. Thus, we are left to conclude that the G-Drive mini Triple is suited only for Mac users with FireWire 800 ports. The SimpleTech Signature Mini Black Cherry or the OWC Mercury are portable drives with broader appeal--both offer more storage space, a lower cost per GB, and better support for USB 2.0 connections.
| Drive type | External hard drive |
| Connector options | FireWire 400, FireWire 800, USB2.0 |
| Available capacities | 160GB, 200GB, 250GB |
| Capacity of test unit | 200GB |
| Drive speed | 7,200rpm (200GB version) and 5400rpm (the others) |
| Cache | 8MB |
| Dimensions (LWH) | 4.9 x 3.2 x 0.9 inches |
| Notable design features | Rugged aluminum casing. |
| OSes supported | Windows XP, Vista, Mac OS X |
| Software included | None |
| Service and Support | Three-year warranty |
Design and features
The G-Drive mini Triple ships in a simple package that includes a traveling pouch, a CD with the manual in PDF format and data cables for all the connection types it supports (USB 2.0, FireWire 400 and FireWire 800). The drive has a power port for an optional $20 power adapter, which is not included. Unfortunately, we discovered that the USB 2.0 connection, unlike the FireWire 400 and FireWire 800 connections, needs this adapter for the drive to operate--with both PCs and Macs. (If you have a MacBook Air , which has no FireWire connection port, make sure you get the adapter when you order the drive.)
The G-drive boasts a very rugged and Mac-friendly design with an aluminum case that also works as a heat sink to dissipate the heat generated by the internal hard drive. On the front, hidden inside the case, there's a LED that glows white, indicating the status of the drive when working. In the G-Drive mini Triple series, the 200GB is the only version that spins at 7,200rpm (which is also the one we reviewed); the other models spin at 5,400rpm.
If you have a Mac running OS X, you need to simply plug the drive into a FireWire port and voila, it works. The drive is preformatted in HFS+ with Journaling and is Time Machine ready right out of the box. However, if you want to use it with Windows, it's a different story entirely.
Unlike any drives we've reviewed before, the G-Drive is preformatted using GUID Partition Table (GPT) mechanism, which is a new and more flexible way to partition hard disks that replaces the older Master Boot Record (MBR) scheme. Though more advanced and compatible with Intel's new Extensible Firmware Interface (EFI) initiative, GPT is not backward compatible with MBR and therefore is not supported in Windows XP or older versions of Windows. For this reason, contrary to the instruction of the G-Drive's manual, the disk management tool within Windows XP can't manipulate the G-Drive's default partitioning method. To make this happen, you will first need to use some advanced third-party disk-partitioning software, such as Acronis DiskDirector, to reformat it into an MBR-based file system.
Windows Vista, on the other hand, supports GPT natively, and you will not have much trouble getting it to work with this operating system. However, it's important to note that Windows Vista's built-in tool doesn't change the G-Drive's partitioning mechanism. This means the drive still doesn't work with Windows XP once reformatted by Windows Vista. In order to make the drive work with both operating systems, you need to convert its partitioning scheme from GPT-based into MBR-based using some third-party software as mentioned above.
By comparison, the OWC Mercury drive is also preformatted for OS X but retains the MBR partitioning scheme and therefore can be reformatted to work with other operating systems very easily. Nonetheless, we found the G-Drive mini Triple worked well with Windows XP once successfully reformatted.
Cost per GB
Priced at around $250 and offering only 200GB, G-Drive mini Triple is one of the more expensive drives per GB. Compared with competing portable hard drives that feature 2.5-inch laptop drives, such as the SimpleTech Signature Mini Black Cherry that we reviewed recently, the G-Drive costs more than double per GB. To its credit, however, the G-Drive mini Triple is the only one spinning at 7,200rpm; the rest on the chart spin at 5,400rpm.
| Model | Capacity | Est. street price | Cost per GB |
| SimpleTech Signature Mini Black Cherry | 320GB | $180 | $0.56 |
| Maxtor OneTouch 4 Mini | 160GB | $90 | $0.56 |
| Iomega eGo Portable Hard Drive | 160GB | $100 | $0.63 |
| OWC Mercury On-The-Go | 500GB | $350 | $0.70 |
| Toshiba USB 2.0 Portable External HDD | 160GB | $140 | $0.88 |
| G-Tech G-Drive mini Triple (7,200RPM) | 200GB | $250 | $1.25 |
Performance
Considering the higher revolutions per minute, we had relatively high expectations for the G-Drive mini Triple's performance. The drive failed to meet our expectations and registered mixed scores in CNET Labs' testing.
The drive's FireWire 800 performance was excellent, registering 218.6Mbps, which is a considerable 17 percent faster than that of the OWC Mercury on our write test. As we see with most drives, differences in read speeds were slight, with the G-Drive mini Triple hovering around the 200Mbps mark with the rest of the pack.
The drive's performance using the FireWire 400 connection was disappointing. The drive's 7,200rpm speed didn't translate into better throughput. The G-Drive finished behind the OWC Mercury, which spins at 5,400rpm, on both our read and write tests.
The drive did a little better with the USB 2.0 connection scoring 147Mbps and 163Mbps on the write test and read test, respectively. Its write score was noticeably faster than that of the Mercury but practically the same as the Signature Mini Black Cherry's. Its read score, on the other hand, was about the same as the Mercury's, while significantly faster than that of the Black Cherry.
The G-Drive mini Triple's casing worked very well as the intended cooling solution; the drive managed to operate quietly and stay relatively cool during our testing process.
Service and support
G-Technology has a lot of love for the G-drive mini Triple and backs it up with a three-year warranty. The company's toll technical phone support is available from 9 a.m. to 5 p.m. PST weekdays. You can also get help via e-mail. At its Web site, you can download firmware and the manual and browse a rather simple FAQs section.
(Longer bars indicate better performance)
 |
Write | |
Read |
- See more CNET content tagged:
- FireWire,
- USB 2.0,
- adapter,
- Apple Macintosh,
- USB
User reviews
Write your own review Be the first one to review G-Tech G-Drive mini Triple (200GB, 7200rpm) and share your experience with the CNET community!
Submit your review
Where to buy
G-Tech G-Drive mini Triple (200GB, 7200rpm):
$189.99
| store | price | in stock? | rating |
|---|---|---|---|
|
Amazon.com Marketplace
|
$189.99 | Yes |
|
%20External%20Hard%20Drive%20reviews%20-%20CNET%20Reviews&srcUrl=http://reviews.cnet.com/external-hard-drives/g-tech-g-drive/4505-3190_7-32795110.html){kind=small}