"Simply the best controller, bar none."5.0 starson by bcostelloe
Pros: Sturdy controller that just demands respect. Huge surprise in how good it performs compared to the original Xbox disastrous effort. Buttons feel right. Weight is balanced and analogue controls respond beautifully! Best controller since Mega Drive.
Cons: Perhaps doesn't perform as well for one on one fighting games. But this is 2010! Not as many people play them now! Also could be seen as ridiculously expensive. Spare rechargeable batteries cost the earth too!
Summary: Unless you're into Street Fighter your gonna love this controller. Even die hard Playstation fan boys have to admit that Microsoft got the controller right on release. Can be fiddly in getting it to connect to your Xbox 360 for first timers. But once you learn how to connect it you'll have little trouble in getting up to four controllers going at any given time.
The wireless controls operate seamlessly without any lag to speak of and feel just as responsive as a wired controller would. I mentioned that these controllers are darn expensive and one complaint I may have is that MS should have found a way to make all Xbox 360 controllers PC compatible to get more mileage out of the product to make up for the expensive outlay. But if you can pick one up on special by all means do so to avoid buying an inferior third party effort!