"The Windows one is GREAT- I got the black one"5.0 starson by Saltiva
Pros: It's wireless, fairly straigtforward- smaller than placing a wireless keyboard and mouse in my lap, alos less laggy than those. starting to prefer it to keyboard and mouse because I can set back comfortably on my couch in front of my big screen.
Cons: None that I can think of except there aren't as many buttons as a keyboard but honestly in a FPS I typically don't get to all the keys- accuracy when targetting is tricky- only works in games without 3rd party s/w.
Summary: Cnet didn't really do a good job of distinguishing the difference in the Xbox 360 controllers so I will review this one- the one I actually got was the black one with the wireless usb adapter for PC- it works like a charm right out of the box. Was thinking about getting the social keyboard accessory for this because you could use the extra keys for some other games but not sure how well that will work.