Apple iBook G4 14.1-inch

hide (x)CNET editors' review

Reviewed by: Troy Dreier
Edited by: Justin Jaffe

Reviewed on 12/22/04    Release date: 10/19/04    With its refreshed 14-inch iBook G4, Apple delivers another clean, white, minimalist notebook, but with a few upgrades. For one, the company has finally decided that wireless is no longer an option but a necessity, so every iBook now comes with an AirPort Extreme card that supports 802.11g Wi-Fi. While the iBook still represents the budget wing of Apple's notebook lineup, buying one involves fewer compromises than with previous iBooks. Our fully loaded 14-inch test iBook featured a generous software bundle and a SuperDrive DVD burner that burns DVDs and CDs (the CD-RW version costs $200 less). On the downside, the iBook still ships standard with only 256MB of RAM, which is far too little, but it can accommodate up to 1.25GB; we recommend upgrading to at least 512MB. At $1,499 (as of December 2004), this machine is fairly expensive compared to most mainstream laptops, which generally cost closer to $1,200. Nevertheless, it's a dependable and affordable choice for home users and students. If you're willing to do without slick Apple style, check out the less expensive but better-outfitted Gateway M520X Plus.

Design of Apple iBook G4 14.1-inch

With this refresh of the successful 14-inch iBook G4, Apple sticks with the minimalist white design the company has used since abandoning the bright, two-color models several years back. You won't find much new with the case, which keeps its classic Apple design along with several refinements made to the last iBook, including a matte-white, almost dull-gray, interior and a glossy, bright-white exterior; a solid, responsive keyboard; and four battery-charge indicator lights on the machine's underside.

Weighing 5.9 pounds and measuring 12.7 inches wide, 10.2 inches deep, and 1.35 inches thick, the 14-inch iBook G4 has average dimensions for a mainstream laptop, but it's not the best model for frequent fliers. For business travelers and commuters, we recommend the sleeker Apple PowerBook. The 14-inch iBook G4's touch pad is a nice size and sits above the simple, single mouse button. Otherwise, there isn't much to the interior besides the two small stereo speakers, which sit in the corners above the keyboard, and a tiny, built-in microphone on the upper-right bezel around the display.

Along the left side of the 14-inch iBook G4, you'll find a handful of connections, including one FireWire 400 port, two USB 2.0 ports, a video out, Ethernet (10/100BaseT) and modem (56Kbps, v.92) ports, and a headphone jack. The right side holds the 14-inch iBook G4's cool SuperDrive, which reads and writes DVD-R and CD-RW. Instead of the flimsy sliding disc tray found on many PC laptops, the 14-inch iBook G4 has a simple slot that smoothly accepts and ejects discs like a car stereo. There's no memory-card reader, however. This feature is included on more and more PC laptops, and it would be a nice addition to future models.

Features of Apple iBook G4 14.1-inch

You can choose to configure the Apple 14-inch iBook G4 in a number of ways (see more information in our series review). Our test model featured a 1.33GHz G4 processor with 512MB of Level 2 cache, a 133MHz system bus, 256MB of system RAM, a 60GB hard drive, and the rather ancient ATI Mobility Radeon 9200 graphics controller with 32MB of video memory. The G4 processor--the same one used in the lower-end PowerBooks--is plenty fast for most tasks, as evidenced in CNET Labs' tests. The iBook's minimal RAM, however, leads to degraded performance when you try to do too much at once, such as running video and graphics programs at the same time. Fortunately, the 14-inch iBook G4 can accommodate much more RAM than comes standard (the previous generation topped out at 640MB, but the present one can hold up to 1.25GB), and we recommend shelling out for at least 256MB more ($100 as a build-to-order option).

The iBook's 14.1-inch TFT XGA screen, with a 1,024x768 native resolution, produces a vivid image, but you'll need to adjust it carefully to get the colors right. We also found that tilting the display only slightly too far forward or back muddied colors at the top of the screen. All iBooks now have an AirPort Extreme (802.11g) card built-in--about time, now that most PC laptops include Wi-Fi capability.

The notebook comes with OS X 10.3 as well as Apple's home-computing bundle, which includes a generous selection of apps such as iLife (with iTunes, iPhoto, iMovie, iDVD, and GarageBand), Mail, iChat AV, Safari, iSync, iCal, Quicken 2005, World Book 2004, and the games Nanosaur 2 and Marble Blast Gold. Unfortunately, the 14-inch iBook G4 doesn't come with a full-featured productivity package.

Performance of Apple iBook G4 14.1-inch

Application performance
The iBook 1.33GHz G4 14-inch delivered performance virtually identical to that of the PowerBook G4 17-inch we tested last year. CNET's test measures the time it takes to convert a 10-minute CD audio track to the MP3 format using iTunes. Both the PowerBook and the iBook took about 40 seconds to convert the file, which is not surprising, since they use the same 1.33GHz G4 processor. Thanks to its speedy CPU, the iBook 1.33GHz G4 scored on a par with the PowerBook 1.33GHz G4 in our iTunes test.

Performance analysis written by CNET Labs assistant lab manager Eric Franklin.

iTunes MP3 conversion
(Shorter bars indicate better performance)

Seconds

PowerBook G4 1.33GHz 17-inch

41 

iBook G4 1.33GHz 14.1-inch

42 

iBook G4 800MHz 12-inch

71 

System configurations:

Apple iBook 12-inch G4 800MHz
OS X 10.3.2; PowerPC G4 800MHz; 256MB DDR-266 SDRAM; ATI Radeon 9200 32MB; 30GB 4,200rpm

Apple iBook 14.1-inch G4 1.33GHz
OS X 10.3.6; PowerPC G4 1.33GHz; 256MB DDR-266 SDRAM; ATI Radeon 9200 32MB; 60GB 4,200rpm

Apple PowerBook 17-inch G4 1.33GHz
OS X 10.2.7; PowerPC G4 1.33GHz; 512MB DDR-333 SDRAM; ATI Radeon 9600 64MB; 80GB 4,200rpm

Battery life of Apple iBook G4 14.1-inch

With a slightly more powerful battery and a smaller screen, the 14-inch iBook G4 lasted longer than the 17-inch PowerBook 1.33GHz G4 in our DVD battery-drain test. The older 12-inch iBook 800MHz G4 tied for first place, thanks to its lower-speed CPU and smaller screen, each of which draws less power. With Apple notebooks, larger screens tend to come at the cost of battery life. Still, the 14-inch iBook 1.33GHz G4 lasted well over three hours in our tests, long enough to watch a full-length DVD (or two).

To drain the battery of an Apple notebook, CNET Labs plays a DVD movie in full-screen mode with brightness and sound set to half.

Battery-life analysis written by CNET Labs assistant lab manager Eric Franklin.

DVD movie battery-drain test
(Longer bars indicate better performance)

Hours

iBook G4 800MHz 12-inch

3.4 

iBook G4 1.33GHz 14.1-inch

3.4 

PowerBook G4 1.33GHz 17-inch

2.7 

System configurations:

Apple iBook 12-inch G4 800MHz
OS X 10.3.2; PowerPC G4 800MHz; 256MB DDR-266 SDRAM; ATI Radeon 9200 32MB; 30GB 4,200rpm

Apple iBook 14.1-inch G4 1.33GHz
OS X 10.3.6; PowerPC G4 1.33GHz; 256MB DDR-266 SDRAM; ATI Radeon 9200 32MB; 60GB 4,200rpm

Apple PowerBook 17-inch G4 1.33GHz
OS X 10.2.7; PowerPC G4 1.33GHz; 512MB DDR-333 SDRAM; ATI Radeon 9600 64MB; 80GB 4,200rpm

Service and support of Apple iBook G4 14.1-inch

Some of Apple's support policies are downright stingy. You get only 90 days of toll-free telephone support, so it's up to you to ask every question you'll ever have during those first three months. Otherwise, Apple offers an industry-standard one-year warranty for parts and labor. After that, you'll have to go it alone with the 108-page printed user guide and the online forums and help resources that Apple provides on the support section of its site. The documents can be a bit much to wade through, but the forums are a great place to get help from other users. If you want to extend your support options, choose the AppleCare Protection Plan when you check out. For $249, it gives you three years of phone support and three years of parts and labor.

Basic Specs

Product Specifications:
Product Description: Apple iBook G4 - PowerPC G4 1.33 GHz - 14.1 in TFT active matrix
Dimensions (WxDxH): 12.7 in x 10.2 in x 1.3 in
Weight: 6 lbs
System Type: Notebook
Built-in Devices: Stereo speakers , Wireless LAN antenna
Processor: PowerPC G4 1.33 GHz
Cache Memory: 512 KB - L2 cache
RAM: 256 MB (installed) / 1.25 GB (max) - DDR SDRAM - 266 MHz - DDR266/PC2100
Floppy Drive: None
Hard Drive: 60 GB - 4200 rpm
Optical Storage: CD-RW / DVD-ROM combo - Integrated
Optical Storage (2nd): None
Storage Removable: None
Display: 14.1 in TFT active matrix 1024 x 768 ( XGA )
Graphics Controller: ATI Mobility Radeon 9200 - 32 MB
Audio Output: Sound card
Telecom: Fax / modem - 56 Kbps
Networking: Network adapter - Ethernet , - IEEE 802.11b , - IEEE 802.11g , - Fast Ethernet
Input Device: Keyboard , Trackpad
Voltage Required: AC 120/230 V
Battery: Lithium ion
Run Time (Up To): 6 hour(s)
OS Provided: Apple MacOS X 10.4
Manufacturer Warranty: 1 year warranty