"If good as the two 2nd gen I've owned, should be fine."3.5 starson by YY-Syd
Pros: The controls and the sturdiness of the clip.
Cons: ITunes, iTunes, iTunes.
Summary: On the previous shuffles, have used non-i-Tunes software from day one. All you need with a button navigating device like this is the ability to drag and drop and order/reorder content. Not playlists and sync. If i-Tunes is the only option on this device, it will not be worthwhile.