-
CNET editors' rating:
stars
Good
Detailed editors' rating - Average user rating: 3.5 stars out of 4 reviews
- See all user reviews
Product summary
The good: Small and light; inexpensive; 802.11g; repeater mode.
The bad: External power adapter adds bulk; lacks NTFS write support; poor service and support.
The bottom line: Unless you need the WL-HDD 2.5's portability, consider a nonwireless networked hard drive such as our Editors' Choice, the See full specs
CNET editors' review
- Reviewed on: 10/06/2004
- Released on: 06/01/2004
Basic setup is simple, but there are many installation scenarios for the WL-HDD 2.5, and you'll need to call forth your inner geek and flip through the 90-page manual to take full advantage of the unit. The drive enclosure comes with a helpful, printed quick-start guide, which walks you through the initial steps. You begin installation by unscrewing the outer shell, pulling out the circuit board, and adding a 2.5-inch hard drive. (We used an 80GB Hitachi Travelstar drive in our informal tests.) Then, screw the device back together and connect it to a computer or a router with a standard Ethernet cable.
Next, you configure the WL-HDD 2.5 via the unit's browser-based configuration tool. The tool allows you to format the enclosure's drive and prepare it for use. Supported formats include FAT, FAT32, NTFS, EXT2, and EXT3. Unfortunately, NTFS support is read-only, which means that if you're using an NTFS volume on the drive, you won't be able to write to it.
By default, the WL-HDD 2.5 is set to allow all connections to access the drive, but the browser-based tool lets you set user permissions and passwords. You can also use the configuration tool to assign read and write access permissions to specific folders and partitions.
The WL-HDD 2.5's integrated 802.11g access point sets it apart from other network drives we've tested. You can use the unit either as a standard access point or as a repeater/bridge by enabling the WL-HDD 2.5's proprietary WDS, (wireless distribution system) feature. This feature lets you wirelessly connect the enclosure to other Asus WDS-enabled access points and routers, such as the WL-500g router. You can also connect the unit to your network via the Ethernet port, and a USB 1.1 port on the unit's back panel lets you transfer files automatically from a flash drive to the WL-HDD 2.5.
The WL-HDD 2.5 has a good security offering that includes support for both WEP and WPA encryption, as well as access control based on MAC address. You can also set the unit to hide its wireless network name, or SSID, which conceals the WL-HDD 2.5 from wireless clients that are not preset to connect to the secret SSID.
Performance for the WL-HDD 2.5 depends on how you use the drive. The unit's 100Mbps Ethernet interface provides the fastest data rates. In contrast, the WL-HDD 2.5's integrated 802.11g access point is capable of peak throughput speeds approaching 25Mbps, adequate for transferring large files but about 75 percent slower than Ethernet.
The Asus service-and-support package could be better. You get a perfunctory one-year warranty on the WL-HDD 2.5, on the low end for consumer networking gear. Asus also agrees to support the unit for as long as you own it. Unfortunately, that service may cost you because the tech-support line is a toll call, staffed only from 8:30 a.m. to midnight (ET), Monday through Friday. Worse yet, you may not even benefit from the call: when we left a message, our call wasn't returned. And although the Asus support Web site contains some useful resources, it's a poorly organized jumble of drivers, firmware, warranty info, and user documentation that has yet to be updated with downloads for the WL-HDD 2.5.
- See more CNET content tagged:
- enclosure,
- access point,
- ASUS,
- IEEE 802.11g,
- NTFS
User reviews
- Average user rating: 3.5 stars out of 4 reviews
- My rating: 0 stars Write review
