-
stars
"Bright idea with some short comings" on by MarcusSternberg
Pros: - It works like it states; Nice small size
Cons: - Hot; some poor engineering; odd disconnecting; slow; annoying autoplay and drive letter recognition; not NTSF nor FAT32
Summary: I was looking for a device to put into my home automation structured wiring cabinet so I could all the computers in the home back up software to this unit. The device does achieve my goal, but I'm returning it because of its short comings.
Netgear needs to fix these simple but basic problems and this device will sell like hot cakes.
Good:
- All computers with Netgear's software downloaded onto it could read/write to this drive.
- It is really small (~ 4 inches wide). They made it very simple (I like simplicity).
Bad:
- Signs of shoddy engineering (particularly in the install software).
- Runs very hot. It needs to be air cooled. It would never be acceptable in a Structured wiring case.
- Having odd disconnects from it. I think the reason is that it gets too hot, that the mechanics make it run unreliable.
- Slow. Writing to it was reasonable (@ 25% the speed of a normal HD), but reading items from it takes unbearably long. This is acceptable to backup items which is what the main purpose for this drive is.
- Can't get it to keep a consistent drive letter on XP. I want it to be always 'H' on all my computers but I'm having no luck. After reading the forums, it is partly Microsoft's problem too.
- Always runs 'AutoPlay' every time the computer boots up. Again, it is annoying.
- Hard disks are formatted in a proprietary format (not FAT32 nor NTSF). They cannot be switched back into one's computer internal drive and be able to read from it.
- 3 replies to this review
-
As you point out, there are 2 'good' points, one of which is "it works", which is a poor argument for linking a product.<br><br>Then the 'bad's.<br>Like you say there are a lot of bads to the product. I agree on those but..<br>You fail to mention the complete lack of standards. I was stupid and thought that if i bought a netgear NAS product (even though SAN is being proposed by netgear) I would be able to link up to NFS, webdav, SMB or any other generally accepted protocol. No such luck.<br><br>one good point vs a dozen bad points.. I wish I would have visited the forums before buying.
-
I had your drive letter collision as well, but just select "This Computer"->"Manage Computer" -> "Disk Management" where you select a drive an give it a letter higher up in the alphabet. Problem solved ...<br><br>I never got it to be all that hot - I have two 200GB Maxtors in it. Some heat is a price paid for the pro that the unit itself adds no sound, so silent disks gives you a very silent solution.<br><br>I do agree on the autoplay - didn't manage to get rid of that either ...
-
I agree with Marcus's comments. <br><br>Also, because it has its own file system, you can't defrag the disk, Norton utilities won't check the disk, ... What happens when the directory starts to get corrupted? Throw away all your data?
Write a Review
Online Stores
| Store | Promotions | In Stock | Price | Total Cost | Initial Sort Order |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
![]() | Yes | Yes | Tax: TBD Ship: TBD | $159.99 Shop Now | |
| See all prices | |||||
