Google Docs & Spreadsheets (10/17/2006)

1. Product summary
2. Editors' review
3. Users' opinions
4. Blogs

Product summary

Editors' review

• Editors' Choice: No
• Reviewed on: 10/18/2006

Google Docs & Spreadsheets can handle the nuts and bolts of daily office work, such as composing and editing text documents. crunching numbers in a spreadsheet, and making basic slide shows. While the features are far fewer than those of desktop software such as Microsoft Office, this online service conveniently lets you do your work anywhere and collaborate with other users.

To get started, just sign in with a Google username using at least Internet Explorer 6, Firefox 1.07+, Mozilla 1.712, or Netscape 7.2 (you must enable JavaScript and cookies). Setup took just a few moments in our tests. If you've already used Writely or Google Spreadsheets, they'll transfer automatically.

Google Docs & Spreadsheets displays text and spreadsheet files in a list that you can organize by subject tags or chronologically in the order edited.

Google Docs & Spreadsheets is built around the now-dead recent addition of Presentations rounds out this suite.

This online bundle has a clean blue-and-white layout that's pretty easy to get to know. The sign-in page displays your word and spreadsheet files in one long list that was refreshed this summer. Similarly to Gmail, content is organized in topical tags, so you can hide all files marked for "family" when signing on at work. This service makes it perhaps too easy to take work home with you. Rather than having to clunkily e-mail ourselves a file of a story we were working on, we just uploaded the text to Google Docs & Spreadsheets to make after-hours tweaks.

When you open a text file, layout tabs contain Edit, Insert, and Revision functions, while a toolbar of graphical icons links to common editing features. Features such as word count conveniently located in the File drop-down menu. Bookmarks easily to find as well, in case you want to set place marks within a long document.

You can pick from many text colors and 19 fonts, and the Insert tab displays wingdings and international symbols in a handy box. That's all the formatting you'll need to write letters and memos for your office or household, as well as papers for school. You can insert images, but a report demanding snazzy graphics would be a better job for Microsoft Word or Corel WordPerfect. We also found it clumsy to work with text tables; you can't use the Tab key to move to the next cell, as you can with Microsoft Word. Nor can you select a table column by using the mouse--a big aggravation. But we like that clicking the Edit HTML link opens a new tab converting your document to relatively clean, Web-ready code. You can post to Blogger, BlogHarbor, BlogWare, LiveJournal, SquareSpace, and WordPress blogs without leaving Google Docs.

Google Docs & Spreadsheets lets you apply various formatting styles and fonts to text, which is good enough for most writing tasks. But beefier desktop software is better for creating a polished professional report heavy on graphics.

If you're working on a spreadsheet, tabs arrange editing, sorting, and formulas. Clicking More within the Formulas tab takes you to a nice list of abbreviations to insert formulas for math, finance, logic, statistics, and so on. Spreadsheets imports XLS, ODS, and comma-separated files, and exports your work in those formats as well as PDF and HTML. We easily imported and exported files in various formats.

The most unique aspect of online software such as Google Docs & Spreadsheets is that it lets you grab and edit files from any computer with Internet access, then invite anyone to make edits or view a document. You can even save your work as a public RSS feed. Luckily, Google has made it harder to accidentally publicize your work than Writely did. Microsoft has still not found a no-brainer way to let regular Office consumers share their text and spreadsheets with other people via the Web.

However, Google many online services. There's no PowerPoint-like app, for instance, unlike the more full-featured Zoho suite. And while you can manage text files and spreadsheets within Google Docs & Spreadsheets' unified interface, other aspects of the service are unevenly integrated. For instance, Spreadsheets lets you chat live with collaborators on your file, which we used to double-check specific formulas; but Google Docs does not. The two tools also display document revisions in different ways.

You can simultaneously edit a spreadsheet and chat with a fellow user, which can save lots of time when you're working with tricky calculations and formulas. Sadly, you can't convert numbers to graphical charts.

The new Presentations is a decent, attempt at a barebones rival to Microsoft PowerPoint. There aren't any animations or transitions available, but that's likely to change as the beta service evolves. Its most useful attribute so far may be the ability to share presentations on the fly with other people, which Zoho and ThinkFree also enable.

We've encountered some odd behavior over nearly a year of beta testing. For example, when we selected text in Google Docs & Spreadsheets and pressed Ctrl+I to italicize it, the toolbar's italics symbol detected the command, but the text didn't change. Still, other keyboard shortcuts worked, such as Ctrl+C to copy. And when we saved and closed a document, the browser window closed and didn't take us back to the list of files. Several times within Internet Explorer, we couldn't get a file to open when clicking on its link from the sign-in page.

Service and support is very good for this Web-based service, though not superb. Google provides a quick tour, a searchable online knowledge base, and user-guided forums for Google Docs & Spreadsheets. You can report beta bugs, but there's no e-mail support to help you with unusual questions.

We expect that Google will gradually add layers of new features to Google Docs & Spreadsheets beta, eventually integrating with Gmail and Google Calendar, and more. Mobile workers and students who are always online might not require more than what Google Docs & Spreadsheets offers for free. But if you ever lack Internet access, there's no desktop version of Google's online services, unlike the rival ThinkFree. For now, Google's office apps make a great traveling companion to desktop productivity software. And despite the beta imperfections, the user experience is more seamless than it has been with Zoho or ThinkFree Online. We'll continue to track updates to Google Docs as they come up.

User opinions

About CNET Archive

Welcome to the CNET Archive, a library of product reviews, user opinions, videos, specifications, and manufacturer descriptions for products no longer offered by the manufacturer or most retailers. Here you will find information on replacement parts and replacement ink cartridges. Read what others had to say about that used laptop you are considering buying. Take a trip down memory lane as you browse and reminisce about your favorite old video game or that first digital camera.

Search Archive

Google Docs & Spreadsheets specifications