Karaoke Revolution (PlayStation 2)

GameSpot editors' review

• CNET editors' rating: 3.5 stars Very good
  Detailed editors' rating
  Overall score: 7.5 (3.5 stars)

• Reviewed by:
  Jeff Gerstmann
• Reviewed on: 11/10/2003
• Released on: 11/05/2003
• Originally published on GameSpot: Karaoke Revolution (PlayStation 2) Review

The rhythm genre works with a pretty standard cycle. Once a good, innovative game is released, the company responsible pretty much gets to sit back and release the same game--with different songs--year after year until fans get bored. Since rhythm game fans tend to be pretty diehard in their fandom, this works pretty well. But there's still a hunger out there for something new. So Konami, not completely content to just release Dance Dance Revolution upgrades for the rest of our lives, has teamed up with Harmonix, the developer responsible for the last truly original thought in the rhythm genre, Frequency. The duo has come together to develop a karaoke game that judges you based on your ability to sing in key. The technology is really cool, and the game itself is fun, but your enjoyment of the game will be directly tied to your own personal taste in music.

The game requires a USB microphone, since you'll actually be singing the game's songs. The current package on the market comes with a headset similar to the one originally packaged with SOCOM: U.S. Navy SEALs. A stand-alone package will be available early next year, as will a more conventional USB microphone. The game contains more than 30 different songs that attempt to cover both classic karaoke songs and some more modern hits. Like in an actual karaoke setting, the majority of the songs in the game don't feature the instrumentalists and vocalists who performed the original songs. So you won't get the actual artists, but you'll get "songs in the style of" artists like Michael Jackson, Avril Lavigne, Sugar Ray, Cyndi Lauper, REM, Madonna, Barenaked Ladies, UB40, Huey Lewis & the News, and so on. While the game does try to cover a lot of ground, containing both older and newer, more pop-friendly material, there's a pretty big difference between executing DDR steps to a song you don't care for and actually taking the time to learn the words and melody of a song you don't like. So it's pretty likely that, unless you're a big-time karaoke fan, you'll latch onto a small group of songs and stick to those.

While the game can be configured to work as a standard karaoke product, there's a game here, as well. The software measures your pitch, and it grades you accordingly. If you can hit the notes of the song and stay on-key, you'll do just fine, though for those of you who aren't already fantastic singers, the game has multiple difficulty settings that relax the judging a bit. While the game will keep an ear out for your pitch, it can't actually tell if you're singing the right words. So you can effectively mumble your way through a song or make up your own words as you go, and as long as your timing and pitch are passable, you'll do just fine. Onscreen indicators tell you both what note to sing and whether or not you're singing it properly. Rather than requiring you to read music, the game simplifies its display by showing you lines that scroll from right to left. The lines vary in height depending on the pitch of the note you're being asked to sing. The length of the line tells you how long you're supposed to hold the note. In all, it's a very rigid system that pretty much forces you to sing the song the way the game wants you to sing it, which in many cases isn't completely faithful to the original song.

The game has a few different modes. The arcade mode works like Dance Dance Revolution and just lets you pick any three-to-five songs you like. Showtime mode gives you specific songs to sing as you work your way through the game's different backdrops. You'll start your singing career at a house party, but by the end you'll have unlocked a huge stadium, complete with pyro and a blimp with your name on it. In a multiplayer setting, you and up to seven other players can take turns singing in arcade mode or in the karaoke competition mode. The difference between the two is that the game judges arcade mode, while the karaoke competition is judged by the other players.

Continue reading