Pros Weapons design are cool, graphics decent but animations seem worse than the previous two games.
Cons Next to no decisions made in the past two games carry any real weight towards the conclusion in the third game. No final boss fight like in the previous two games. Crew members uninteresting, especially the new members. Ending disgraceful.
Summary Very disappointing end to probably the most innovating game series I have ever played. To bad that the franchise had to be turned into a cash cow, instead of continuing what was started in ME1 and made better in ME2.
Pros Graphics (maybe) - the backgrounds in a lot of places were pretty good. (Some) Improved mechanics.
Cons Decisions of past games carry very little weight on campaign and none on the end. No end boss fight. Illogical ending. Zero story and character closure including teammates. Lack of variety in endings.
Summary Sorely disappointed. The game leaves behind it's RPG elements and original fan base and instead plays more like a shooter in an attempt to draw in a new fan base. The game has 0 replay value and makes you not ever want to play any game in the series again. It just feels pointless.
Pros Story, weapons and characters, makes you care for them in a nice way for a videogame.
Cons Graphis are alright, not as good as ME2 for the PS3 anyway, i felt the graphics had to be trimmed for the xbox.
Summary 10/10 characters, 7/10 graphics, story 9/10, multiplayer meh the game didnt need it realy
Pros Great gameplay, satisfying ending and addictive multi-player feature. Glad that the end was intellectually challenging and not overly predictably. Felt more cinematic while still providing enough uniqueness for it to be a rich RPG.
Cons Some of the writing is a little weak at times. The graphics, especially the facial animations are falling behind some of the other leaders in the game industry.