Pros Graphics are great, looks like they fixed the running bases problem with camera angles. the ability to train pitchers and defensive side of the position players is a BIG plus. Ability to play as a closer pitcher is great as well.
Cons Yeah the commentary is sad, I thought there would be some great additions , but sadly no. I found a cheat to be able to pause any commentator I wanted, so no more color commentating I don't need to hear this guy could get his 100th rbi all game.
Summary Still a great game, you also have the ability to buy points for your RTTS player or Franchise, although most feel this is cheating or putting your player on virtual steroids. I did try it and even though my fastball is advertised at 96 mph I can't get it up past 86...so not sure is it age of player or points are sort of artificial.
Pros I love this game. Started playing last years version and fell in love with the game. The graphics are wonderful the PRO stadiums are as realistic as possible and it is a great way to feel part of the game.
Cons The coomentary is horrible, there's no weather, guys don;t drop fly balls minor league players and stadiums are not real.
Summary THIS IS NOT THE MOST REALISTIC BASEBALL GAME EVER!!!! I will however say its the BEST baseball game ever. Let's start with the commentary. Yes, there are some catchy lines when you first play, but overall the commentary is dryer than the Mojavi desert. Guys, nails on a chalk board sound better than these three guys. Let's hear them talk about stuff around the league or players chasing milestones. update update update!!! There's no weathre in this game. you CANNOT be realistic without weather. Rain snow, hurricanes tornados, something, anything to make it more realistic. Outfielders NEVER drop fly balls. Recently saw Carlos Beltran and Jason Bay crash into eachother and into the wall and Beltran didn't drop the ball. I understand that replacing an injured pitcher is a mess but come on, i've drilled pitchers, not little dribblers that hit them, but DRILLED pitchers in the arm, leg, chest and back, with LINE DRIVES, and they stay in the game, not realistic guys sorry. Umpires are part of baseball too, so lets make the umpire list realistic, use more then 10 guys for an umpire crew. Sony, im sorry to say but until you guys can fix these flaws, you will never be the most realistic baseball game ever, just the BEST and even MLB 2K will find a way to get past you.