JVC XA-A50CL Digital Audio Player

Reviewed by

Rachel Wolan

on 08/11/2005

Add to my list
Print
E-mail
Share

See all JVC products

CNET editors' rating: 2.0 stars Mediocre
Detailed editors' rating
Average user rating: Write your own review

Price:

$79.87

Compare prices:

Amazon.com Marketplace

$79.87

Compare prices from 1 store

Quick specs
Device type: Flash player
Sound output mode: Stereo
Color: Piano black
See full specifications

Add to my list Product summary

The good: Compact and very lightweight; robust sound quality; ability to create and save playlists on the go.

The bad: Expensive; voice-guided navigation system is neat but awkward; earphones have a propensity to flop around or come off the ear with even mild activity; only 128MB of built-in and unexpandable flash memory.

The bottom line: If you are looking for a technologically outdated, awkwardly designed, excessively expensive digital audio player, then look no further than the JVC XA-A50CL.

Read full review

See all prices

CNET editors' review

CNET editors' rating: 2.0 stars Mediocre
Detailed editors' rating

Reviewed by:
Rachel Wolan
Edited by:
James Kim
Reviewed on: 08/11/2005
Released on: 03/01/2005

JVC's foray into the world of flash digital audio players is literally a flop. The distinctive clip-on, earphone-style XA-A50CL MP3 player desperately needs a makeover mostly due to an earpiece design that flops around, making it unusable during even moderate physical activity. Other annoyances range from the flimsy USB port cover, which broke off in less than 5 minutes of use, to its cumbersome name (try saying "XA-A50CL" quickly three times) to the annoying cord that connects the two earphones. Although promising in theory, this quirky, 128MB flash-based player needs more storage capacity; a better navigation system, although the existing voice-aided system is a neat idea; and most important, an improved method for securing the earphone to the ear.

Don't expect this earphone to stay on during physical activity.

The grandfather of this device is the headband AM/FM radio that joggers and sports fanatics alike wore during the '80s. The JVC XA-A50CL--which is made of black plastic with the right side measuring 1.8 by 2.1 by 0.9 inches, excluding the ear clip--is certainly lighter than its predecessors at just a hair more than 2 ounces, but its ill-conceived design makes it considerably less comfortable for workout warriors. In its press release for the player, JVC touts the XA-A50CL to be "especially well suited for active use," which, on the surface, is true in that the skipless flash-based player is enclosed in one of the headphones, leaving the user's hands free. However, in CNET field activity tests (jogging), the ear clip's overly flexible hinge caused the ear cup to flop around, irritating our participants. While the earphones sit comfortably on your ears, the fit is not snug enough for even mild physical activity, and making matters worse, the felt headphone covers soak up sweat. Despite the fact that the cord between the two earphones is necessary to get audio signals to the left earphone, as well as to prevent an earphone from dislodging and falling to the ground, it is an annoying presence.

That said, the engineers of the JVC XA-A50CL did manage to get a few things right. The device runs for a rated 20 hours on one AAA battery. In real-world testing, CNET Labs was able to get a little more than 17 hours per battery, which is still acceptable. Additionally, the player has a surprisingly robust sound, with four preset equalizer modes and simulated digital surround sound.