-
"Excellent Router / Terrible Router"
3.0 starson by MENDOBOBPros: The 3rd revision of this router is a great deal. It is an 802.11n with good speed and range, good security and easy setup.
Cons: The 1st version of this router was a huge disappointment. It would not connect to the user's satellite adapter (modem) and had to be returned.
Summary: I was looking for an inexpensive 802.11n router for a client's home. The D-Link DIR-615 had very mixed reviews, people either hated it or loved it. and at $40 from Tiger Direct it seemed too cheap. I ordered one from TD and was delighted by it. The setup had very good animations of where everything plugged in and I set it up in under 5 minutes. It had good range for both 802.11n and 802,11g. We tested it with a hard wired desktop, an 80211g ThinkPad and an 812.11n IdeaPad. The client was very happy with the speed, range and reliability.
Friends of mine were looking for their first wireless router and I recommended the DIR-615, without hesitation. The day it arrived, they tried to install it and couldn't, so they called me. Curiously the setup program was not the same one I had used earlier. No matter what I tried, I could not get the router to recognize the signal from the satellite adapter. I swapped cables, computers and even tried it using my ISP. D-Link Tech Support had us run down the usual list of tests and concluded that it was "defective" and should be returned to TD.
I noticed that the DIR-615 I had installed the first time was Hardware version C1 Firmware version 3.00 and the router TD had sent my friends was H/W version A1 F/W version 1.00. I am guessing that the first version is a piece of crap, but by the 3rd revision they got it right. Why TD would ship the latest revision one time and a week later ship an older version is puzzling.My friends are returning it to TD, and have sworn off TD and D-Link and are getting a Linksys router from a big box store. Which is unfortunate because I have had good experiences with Tiger Direct and D-Link
The bottom line is that this is a great router, but make sure that you get the later revision. Since most online merchants don't give the version number, this could be challenging.
- 5 replies to this review
-
How are you measuring range on this router? 10 feet away? This router when matched up to a Dlink DWA-645 adaptor starts to drop signal from 15 feet and declines from there. No better than G.
-
No, version C1 is still a migraine.
-
An interesting observation zenfully13, the first V3 good router was installed with a DSL adapter, the 2nd V1 bad router was installed on a Hugesnet satellite adapter. It is hard to imagine why the router would differentiate between a DSL adapter and a Satellite adapter unless Hugesnet or D-Link are using some non-standard network protocols..I am not a network engineer, but after 30 years in IT, I have come to realize that all things are possible with programming,esp. bad programming.
-
REVISED! oops....
reply by: on December 12, 2008
I think i've had the same problem as your second client with this product. accept mine is h/w ver b2 f/w ver 2.25
Router gives decent wireless signal and cable connected signal is great, but does NOT give me any internet access when connected to my hughes net satellite modem. This seems to be a common thing with routers and satellite modems. your opinion?
Thanks -
I think i've had the same problem as your second client with this product. accept mine is h/w ver b2 f/w ver 2.25
Router gives decent wireless signal and cable connected signal is great, but does give me any internet access when connected to my hughes net satellite modem. This seems to be a common thing with routers and satellite modems. your opinion?
Thanks
Write a Review
Online Stores
| Store | Promotions | In Stock | Price | Total Cost | Initial Sort Order |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
![]() | Get free shipping on orders over $25! | Yes | Ship: TBD Tax: TBD | $44.00 | |
![]() | Call us for quantity discount! Same Day Shipping | Yes | Ship: TBD Tax: TBD | $78.00 | |
![]() | Yes | Ship: TBD Tax: TBD | $84.99 | ||
| See all prices | |||||


