-
"Major software problem with other than Netgear Pre-N Cards"
onPros Easy detection of cable modem, and great security.
Cons Released before bugs were properly worked out, & level 1 tech support is unaware of the problems.
Summary This could have been the best of the best in the router picks for me (Could still be if they fix the problems quickly).
The problem is that this router will not let other 802.11B/G devices connect to the internet.
It allows them to connect to the router and the internal network to share files and such, but no internet connection can be made by the device.
I tried two different laptops (Armada 7800 6366/T/10/0/M/1 Win-2K, IBM R31 Win-XP Pro) with 2 different G & B only cards (4 cards total, all different manufacturers, IBM 12P3863 802.11B mini PCI, Microsoft MN-720 802.11G, Buffalo WLI-CB-G54A 802.11G, Orinoco Gold 802.11B), with the same problem. I also tried a total of 2 routers to confirm the problem (both had identical problems). Most people would have just taken it back and purchased something else. I spent about 50 hours of my personal time, over a 3 week period, trying to figure out the problem, and an extra $20 in shipping charges for a second router.
The unit will not detect new firmware with Version 1.0.1.2, and I cannot yet confirm if Version 1.0.1.4 will detect it until the new release comes out.
While I like the automatic internet detection, it is very slow, and could make someone believe their router is defective.
The software that came with the router on the resource CD V1.0 has some problems of its own; it locks up at a certain point. I recommend manually setting up the router rather than using the software.
The size of the router is not really a problem, but they could have made the clip on base an inch wider (and still could). A wall mount using the same Clip-on base holes would be a good idea too.
The level-2 tech support says they will have a fix in 2 more weeks with their next software release (sometime in July 2006).
The rush to the Pre-N deliveries is going to cost companies that have not properly tested their equipment with cards and devices other than their own.
Recommendation for consumers on 802.11N: WAIT! Wait until 3 to 6 months after it is ratified if you want no problems. There are plenty of other great 802.11G MIMO routers that work very well at 100MHz+ if you need something now.
Recommendation to the manufacturers: Re-call your 802.11N product if it is not widely compatible with B&G until you fix it. You're just going to give yourselves a black eye, and cause mistrust with the consumer.
Just one guys opinion...
Updated
The latest software update for the Netgear WNR834B RangeMax router has been released...
I can now honestly say this is a best in class router, my rating is now a 10... Just next time, Netgear, don't be in a rush to be first, just best...
If you are having any issues download the latest update dated 7-14-2006. Version V1.0.2.4.
If you haven't been able to connect before this will fix the problem...
I am happy to now give this router a 10 even if I can only give the Netgear pre-testing group a 2. I think there is probably a job opening (or soon to be) in that group now...Updated
The latest software update for the Netgear WNR834B RangeMax router has been released...
I can now honestly say this is a best in class router, my rating is now a 10... Just next time, Netgear, don't be in a rush to be first, just best...
If you are having any issues download the latest update dated 7-14-2006. Version V1.0.2.4.
If you haven't been able to connect before this will fix the problem...
I am happy to now give this router a 10 even if I can only give the Netgear pre-testing group a 2. I think there is probably a job opening (or soon to be) in that group now...Updated
The latest software update for the Netgear WNR834B RangeMax router has been released...
I can now honestly say this is a best in class router, my rating is now a 10... Just next time, Netgear, don't be in a rush to be first, just best...
If you are having any issues download the latest update dated 7-14-2006. Version V1.0.2.4. http://kbserver.netgear.com/products/WNR834B.asp
If you haven't been able to connect before this will fix the problem...
I am happy to now give this router a 10 even if I can only give the Netgear pre-testing group a 2. I think there is probably a job opening (or soon to be) in that group now... -
"Crashes constantly, then after 6 months completely broke"
on by 1457riataPros looks nice, easy to install
Cons range wasn't that great, maybe 50% better than g, router was constantly crashing, at least once a week, always required restart, now after 6 months it has quit working completely, won't even power on.
Summary
Updated
Talked to Netgear tech support. Power on problem was due to the power adapter. This isn't good news. Unit now powers on, but is now crashing about every five or 10 minutes. So it's completely useless and I now longer can use the excuse that it's just a bad unit that was about to fail. -
"Works but . . . . the firmware is crap."
on by dfmcsePros looks nice, it does work . . . . if you can make it work.
Cons Firmware is crap, interface is slow, firewall is not stealth (firmware V1.0.3.5), Netgear support.
Summary If I had bought this product I'd return it. I have the device because my rangemax 240's Internet port failed and I made a hardware warranty claim. Netgear did not have any 240s to send me so I said go ahead and send me the WNR834B. So, I get the device and plug it in. I browse to the interface and the first thing that greets me is the screen that offers to check for a firmware upgrade, I say sure. It comes back telling me that it's 3 to 4 versions behind so I go ahead and update. Big mistake, basically fries the device (as far as I could tell at that time). So, I call Netgear support back, they make me suffer for 30 minutes or so before escalating to L2. L2 calls me back the next day and they decide they sent a bad device so they are going to overnight another to me. They're so nice . . . I'm sure this will be different. I can't take anymore of they're help, it's killing me. That evening I go to Netgear's website to check out their white papers on the device and I find the exact problem I’m having. I walk through the instructions and fix the device. It seems to be working fine but the performance is not what I had hoped for, my 240 covered my house better than this thing. So, I get the new new one and I'm a glutton for punishment so the first thing I do with it is update the firmware, this time however I do it locally and it still fries it. . . . Man that's quality. I don't know who's writing the code for the firmware but they should take a class or something. I fix this one too. So after tweaking the settings and changing the placement in my home/office I get the coverage I need. So, I'm using it but I was a loyal Netgear customer, now I’m a very displeased Netgear customer. Netgear support was possibly the most painful experience I've had in dealing with tech issues and I'm a Network Administrator. . . so that's saying something. On another note the firewall on this thing is not in stealth mode, I did a port scan and several ports came back as closed. I'm like what the . . . so I have to go through and reconfigure my Network so any scans go off in to nothing so I don't have half the hackers on the internet making my life more fun. . . I mean what the heck are they doing. So now I can call Netgear back to discuss there super duper firmware or just put myself out of my misery.
At least they replaced the devices, I wasn't sure that was going to happen the first call I made to Netgear on my 240 the gal tried to tell me the port failure was a "software" failure and would not be covered. So it might have been over if I didn't know anything, but you know I probably would have been happier because I just would of gone out and bought a Belkin.
-
"good router set up just 15mins"
on by vietanh05Pros good looking ,running cool and upgreade latest firmware no problem
Cons software set up liitle funky but no problem
Summary Bought fromm Circuit city $100 ,good range second floor set ,good signal from Basement ,work with all comp Adapter g/b
-
"Working fine for 4 yrs now"
on by daveyadamsPros Good range and speed through walls
Cons Not wall-mountable,flimsy connection to base.
Summary Good product overall,I don;t know why so many people claim to have problems with this item.
My guess would be not having being as tech-savvy as they think they are,or plain old user malfunction.
Write a Review
Online Stores
| Store | Promotions | In Stock | Price | Total Cost | Initial Sort Order |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
![]() | Get free shipping on orders over $25! | Yes | Ship: TBD Tax: TBD | $119.99 | |
| Memory4Less.com | Yes | Ship: TBD Tax: TBD | $88.95 | ||
| See all prices | |||||
