Apple iPhone 4 user reviews (16GB - black, AT&T)

Pros Internet browsing on this phone is a LOT faster than on previous models. I could not be happier with the speed--it blows all other mobile phones away. The apps are fabulous too. Screen is gorgeous. Touch screen is easy to use.

Cons Two words: PROXIMITY SENSOR!! The sensor is broken. It doesn't detect your cheek and the screen activates, calling other people while you are on the line. I can't tell you how many times I've had to apologize to people because of this.

Summary Proximity sensor issues make this phone all but unusable. It's more like a mini iPad.

Pros Everything you like about iphones: apps, web, beauty, design.

Cons It doesn't make calls, so it's not a phone

Summary This phone dropped every single call I made, hence it is not a cell phone, it is a toy.

Pros The convenience of using it. Just like all the other iPhones

Cons Bad reception. In 3 days that I had it, there were numerous dropped calls, failed calls, searching for service. But I think something was not right with carrier.

Summary I had to return it because I missed important calls, but only after I called AT&T customer service. The representative said that he doesn't know why such bad reception, according to his map I live in a very good reception area. Then I went to AT&T store. They replaced the SIM card. I still wonder how that helps. Then I went to Apple store. They replaced the phone. After that I came home, made one call to the iPhone to check the reception. The call failed.
The next day I went back to AT&T and re-activated my old 3GS. Still bad reception, but at least calls get through now.
The next day I returned iPhone 4 to Apple store. They couldn't, for some weird reason, put the refund money back on my credit card. I had to accept cash. And they lied on the "Work Authorization" application. Instead of saying that I was returning it because of problems with reception, they put on the Application "Issue: phone battery only lasts 20 minutes".
I signed it because I didn't care and just wanted to get rid of this phone. But it is a good question why they put the wrong reason for returning on that application.
I am getting disappointed with Apple.

Pros Fast, glitch free operation. No Windows Mobile like sluggishness. Outstanding screen. Accelerometer really works! Apps are magic! This smartphone functions intuitively. Why did I wait so long to buy an Iphone?

Cons Occaisional app hiccups, but this device is still light years ahead of any smart phone or mobile phone I have ever owned or tested.

Summary The antennae issue is so minor. Steve Jobs is correct, the issue is overblown. Buy a case and the problem is gone. You'll want one anyway to protect this jewel. My highest recommendation for the Iphone 4!