-
"More Hype Than Necessary"
2.5 starson by daddyboxersPros: Intuitive, Simple to Use, Familiar Layout, Highly Responsive, 3G/WiFi/Bluetooth Capable
Cons: Expensive Accessories, Low Resolution, No External Memory Support, No Flash Support, No Real Multitasking, iPhone OS
Summary: Apple's Marketing team are true geniuses. They have taken a device and created a Mass Media Hype over technology they have claimed to be "magical". In an industry like this, being magical shouldn't be your selling point. Anyhow, on with the review.
I fail to see how this is innovative software when it borrows almost directly from the iPhone. As far as this being a game changer, I am a bit skeptical. If there were any evidence to support this claim, I may yield to the statement, however, just stating it only leaves it as an opinion.
First and foremost, the Apple iPad has many great features that will woo the general population with its easy-to-use, finger friendly design. Those who are familiar with the iPhone will find the iPad very familiar due to the Operating System that is shared on both form factors. For every reason that has created the huge success for the iPhone will be the same reasons why the iPad will have success. The device is not built to do everything for everyone. It's limited in its scope to do very precise things, and the things it does, it does well.
Right off the bat, the iPad will share the vast array of applications from the App Store. On launch, the iPad will also have ~1000 iPad-dedicated Apps ready to go as well. With the ample real-estate that is the screen, the iPad will allow users to watch video, review photos, read books and all of the enjoyment that is the multimedia world. This is where it ends though.
Web browsing experience is going to be somewhat limited until HTML5 becomes the more accepted standard in web-designing. Currently, over three-quarters of the web utilizes Flash in most of its sites to engage the user which the iPad will never support. Although the video may look great, it won't be HD quality. Even 720p quality requires a minimum resolution of 1280x720 which the iPad's resolution will cap out at 1024x768. The device will not be able to multitask between multiple programs and third-party apps, so the device will be limited to running very few apps (if more than one) simultaneously. One other downfall is the inability to use external memory devices (SD-cards for example) to either transfer files or use as extra storage if you do not feel like shelling out an extra $200 for an additional 48GB (32GB SD card can run as little as $70USD).
One last thing is the accessories. In order to use an external keyboard, one must purchase the keyboard dock which will run about $70USD where as tablets like the HP Slate will be able to use USB-keyboards.
Again, for what it can do, it's great. For what it could be, it's lacking quite a bit in several departments. I still see this product being a huge success simply based on the fanbase that supports Apple and its products and Apple's superb Marketing Team.
Updated on Apr 3, 2010
There have been many tablets before the iPad. I will admit, prior to the iPad, the general population was unaware of this genre of computer devices. In that aspect, the iPad has definitely shed some light in this once-thought dead avenue. Otherwise, I do not see how the iPad is bringing anything new to the table that has not already been done either by its own company (iPhone) or any other tablet-manufacturing company.
- 5 replies to this review
-
I have carefully read hundreds of reviews about the iPad. I bought the 64 GB model and carefully studied it's capabilities. I discovered that you need some fairly cheap apps to mould it to your needs. And that's the genius of the device ! You can make it your own, by downloading cheap applications. Once this is done - Volia ! You have qn incredible machine !
I do emails , web surfing ( ok no Flash is an annoyance), I have my favourite videos, my songs, some very interesting games and some excellent apps for writing. I can download , save and email all sorts of attachments , watch movies during travel , play games , like chess etc , and finally read books ! I have over 50 books on my iPad, and all free downloads !
I hardly use my laptop these days. Ofcourse I am not into geeky stuff - that's for sure - but hey that's not a mast have is it ? Otherwise it's a design which I am sure will be hard to beat. And in closing - flash seems to create problems for mobil devices.Jobs was right. -
I agree Apple tends to create a lot of hype for a product which shares a OS with the iPhone. This is a very good piece of hardware for Apple to get you into their ecosystem of selling Applications and Books. Its too bad many do not see the flaws and limitations in such a device. I bought a $500 WiFi only and am glade I spent no more on it. The lack of Flash and Java really breaks Safari and I end up back using my laptop. Its almost too heavy to read with for any length of time. But this is one product that has been over sold and I think in the end many will find it lacking its magical hype.
-
Great review, I am a little disappointed with the product. My first thought was why not buy an IPad, for $150 more than the latest nook or kindle; I can browse the web, watch movies and listen to my music on the go. I went to an Apple store to give it another try. What's the point? So, the IPad is just an e book reader with lots of extras? Shouldn't the name change to IBook or something. It's between an e book reader and a tablet PC, but a little more expensive? Great design, it's sexy as hell but the performance and everything else you mentioned just made it more obvious to me that it is pointless. Thank god I waited and thank you for being unbiased.
-
thanks. good review. i was swinging back and forth. my kids (both very happy with iPhones and Mac pros) told me to get an iPhone if what i wanted was a small webster.
-
Great review, you managed to keep it unbiased too. One thing I thing you should add. While It technically can run any iPhone app, they look horrible. Obviously they are designed for the iPhones screen, so you choice is to view them as a little square or zoom in and have them be all blurry.
Write a Review
Online Stores
| Store | Promotions | In Stock | Price | Total Cost | Initial Sort Order |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
![]() | Get free shipping on orders over $25! | Yes | Ship: TBD Tax: TBD | $559.47 | |
| Memory4Less.com | Yes | $763.18 (Refurbished) Ship: TBD Tax: TBD | $763.18 | ||
| See all prices | |||||


